On this pageAre employee repayment or stay-or-pay terms enforceable?
State Law Practice Guide

Stay-or-Pay and Employee Repayment in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania has no general statute on stay-or-pay or training-repayment terms, so a repayment promise is tested as a contract under the penalty rule, while the Wage Payment and Collection Law allows deductions from wages only as the law or a Department of Labor and Industry regulation authorizes them. A 2024 statute on health care practitioners' non-competes preserves recovery of certain relocation and training expenses.

Authorities relied on17Primary sources
About this guide
Editor
  • Lawyer
  • Harvard Law '18 (J.D.)
  • MIT '13 (S.B.)
  • Former Ropes & Gray (6 yrs)
  • Admitted in NY
License
CC BY 4.0

Are repayment terms enforceable in Pennsylvania?

A Pennsylvania employee repayment term that fixes an amount owed on early departure is tested under the penalty rule, which refuses to enforce a liquidated damages clause intended as a penalty rather than as a measure of foreseeable business losses . A county trial court has applied that rule to refuse a training-related early-departure charge . No Pennsylvania statute of general application governs stay-or-pay, training-repayment or bonus-repayment terms in private employment, and parties may agree in advance on liquidated damages, particularly where actual damages would be hard to estimate or prove . The one statute located for this guide that addresses repayment is limited to health care practitioners: the Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act preserves an employer's recovery of reasonable relocation, training and patient-base expenses that meet its conditions .

In Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., the court distinguished a penalty, fixed as a punishment, from a pre-estimate of probable actual damages , and stated that contracting parties may provide for pre-determined liquidated damages, particularly where actual damages would be difficult to estimate in advance or to prove after a breach . In Holt's Cigar Co. v. 222 Liberty Associates, the Superior Court reaffirmed Pennsylvania's policy of refusing to enforce a liquidated damages clause intended as a penalty rather than as a measure of foreseeable business losses . Neither decision involved an employee repayment term, and no Pennsylvania appellate decision located for this guide applies them to a training-repayment or stay-or-pay clause. In Mannino v. Lazerpro Inc., a Centre County Court of Common Pleas decision, an employment contract set liquidated damages of three months' salary for leaving before a two-year commitment as compensation for lost training and workload redistribution. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. The court stated that such costs are difficult to measure but that the amount must still be a reasonable forecast of the harm , and it held the $8,250 charge unreasonable on the evidence presented . The conservative course is to set any fixed repayment amount by reference to a documented estimate of the employer's loss from an early departure, such as the cost of the training or the hiring incentive, rather than as a deterrent.

A repayment term that operates as a restraint on later work raises a second question. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has stated that restrictive covenants are not favored in Pennsylvania and have historically been viewed as a trade restraint that prevents a former employee from earning a living , and it enforces one only if it is ancillary to employment, supported by adequate consideration, reasonably limited in duration and geographic extent, and designed to protect the employer's legitimate interests . No Pennsylvania appellate decision located for this guide decides whether a repayment obligation that applies whether or not the employee competes is a restrictive covenant, so the conservative course for a repayment triggered only by competitive work is to draft it to meet the Socko requirements as well.

Drafting caution

A repayment schedule that fixes an amount unrelated to any estimate of the employer's loss from an early departure risks being struck as a penalty. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Case law · 1991-05-23A.1
Holt's Cigar Co. v. 222 Liberty Associates, 591 A.2d 743 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1991)

The Superior Court reaffirmed Pennsylvania's policy of holding unenforceable liquidated damages clauses intended as a penalty rather than as a measure of foreseeable business losses.

In sum, today we reaffirm this jurisdiction’s policy of holding unenforceable those liquidated damages clauses intended as a penalty rather than as a measure of foreseeable business losses.

See Holt's Cigar Co. v. 222 Liberty Associates, 404 Pa. Super. 578, 591 A.2d 743 (1991).

Primary source · Case law · 2005-10-11A.2
Mannino v. Lazerpro Inc., 76 Pa. D. & C.4th 526 (C.P. Centre Cnty. 2005)

The Centre County Court of Common Pleas held that an employment contract's liquidated damages of three months' salary for leaving before a two-year commitment, described as compensation for lost training and workload redistribution, were unreasonable on the evidence presented.

Eight thousand two hundred fifty dollars in damages for redistributing plaintiff’s workload, in addition to loss of time from training plaintiff, is unreasonable based upon the evidence presented.

See Mannino v. Lazerpro Inc., 76 Pa. D. & C.4th 526 (C.P. Centre Cnty. 2005).

Primary source · Case law · 2002-06-19A.3
Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., 798 A.2d 1277 (Pa. 2002)

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court stated that contracting parties may provide for pre-determined liquidated damages, particularly where actual damages would be difficult to estimate in advance or to prove after a breach.

Thus, contracting parties may provide for pre-determined liquidated damages in the event one party fails to perform, particularly in circumstances where actual damages would be difficult to estimate in advance or to prove after a breach occurs.

See Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., 568 Pa. 601, 798 A.2d 1277 (2002).

Primary source · Primary lawA.4
Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act § 4(c)(1)

Section 4(c)(1) of Act 74 of 2024 provides that the noncompete section does not prohibit enforcing a contract provision letting an employer recover reasonable expenses from a health care practitioner that are directly attributable to the practitioner and accrued within three years before separation unless separation is caused by dismissal, related to relocation, training and establishment of a patient base, and amortized over up to five years from separation.

(c) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be construed to: (1) Prohibit the enforcement of a contract provision that allows an employer to recover reasonable expenses from a health care practitioner, if the expenses are: (i) Directly attributable to the health care practitioner and accrued within the three years prior to separation, unless separation is caused by dismissal of the health care practitioner. (ii) Related to relocation, training and establishment of a patient base. (iii) Amortized over a period of up to five years from the date of separation by the health care practitioner.

See Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act, Act of July 17, 2024, P.L. 846, No. 74, § 4(c)(1) (Pa.).

Primary source · Case law · 2002-06-19A.5
Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., 798 A.2d 1277 (Pa. 2002)

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court stated that a penalty is fixed not as a pre-estimate of probable actual damages but as a punishment designed to prevent the breach.

A penalty, by contrast, is fixed, “not as a pre-estimate of probable actual damages, but as a punishment, the threat of which is designed to prevent the breach.”

See Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., 568 Pa. 601, 798 A.2d 1277 (2002).

Primary source · Case law · 2005-10-11A.6
Mannino v. Lazerpro Inc., 76 Pa. D. & C.4th 526 (C.P. Centre Cnty. 2005)

The Centre County Court of Common Pleas described the employer's claim for $8,250 in liquidated damages, equal to three months' salary under the employment contract, for the employee's failure to remain employed for the full two-year commitment.

Defendant further requests liquidated damages in the amount of $8,250 based upon plaintiff’s failure to remain employed for the full two-year commitment. Pursuant to attachment A, subsection C, of the employment contract, defendant is entitled to liquidated damages equivalent to three months salary if the breach occurs after the employee’s first year of employment.

See Mannino v. Lazerpro Inc., 76 Pa. D. & C.4th 526 (C.P. Centre Cnty. 2005).

Primary source · Case law · 2005-10-11A.7
Mannino v. Lazerpro Inc., 76 Pa. D. & C.4th 526 (C.P. Centre Cnty. 2005)

The Centre County Court of Common Pleas stated that although training and workload costs from an early departure are difficult to measure, the liquidated amount must be a reasonable forecast of compensation for the harm the breach may cause.

These are costs that are difficult to measure. However, the amount must be a reasonable forecast of compensation for the harm which may be caused by the breach.

See Mannino v. Lazerpro Inc., 76 Pa. D. & C.4th 526 (C.P. Centre Cnty. 2005).

Primary source · Case law · 2002-10-16A.8
Hess v. Gebhard & Co. Inc., 808 A.2d 912 (Pa. 2002)

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court stated that restrictive covenants are not favored in Pennsylvania and have historically been viewed as a trade restraint that prevents a former employee from earning a living.

However, restrictive covenants are not favored in Pennsylvania and have been historically viewed as a trade restraint that prevents a former employee from earning a living.

See Hess v. Gebhard & Co. Inc., 808 A.2d 912 (Pa. 2002).

Primary source · Case law · 2015-11-18A.9
Socko v. Mid-Atlantic Systems of CPA, Inc., 126 A.3d 1266 (Pa. 2015)

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that restrictive covenants are enforceable only if ancillary to employment, supported by adequate consideration, reasonably limited in duration and geographic extent, and designed to protect the employer's legitimate interests.

Consistent with this legal background, currently in Pennsylvania, restrictive covenants are enforceable only if they are: (1) ancillary to an employment relationship between an employee and an employer; (2) supported by adequate consideration; (3) the restrictions are reasonably limited in duration and geographic extent; and (4) the restrictions are designed to protect the legitimate interests of the employer.

See Socko v. Mid-Atlantic Systems of CPA, Inc., 126 A.3d 1266 (Pa. 2015).

Can a Pennsylvania employer claw back pay the employee already earned?

No Pennsylvania appellate decision located for this guide decides whether a bonus or other payment that has already vested can be recovered under a stay-or-pay term. The Wage Payment and Collection Law gives an employee no substantive right to compensation beyond the right to enforce payment of what the agreement provides , and a federal district court applying Pennsylvania law has required a departing executive to repay a portion of incentive awards under the award terms .

The Wage Payment and Collection Law defines wages to include all earnings of an employee, however calculated . In Willis Re Inc. v. Hearn, the court stated that a bonus is a protected wage under the statute if it is earned, meaning the right to it vested under the terms of employment , and it found that the executive, who owed repayment unless he retired, had not retired under the award agreements . The statute's protections themselves cannot be contravened or set aside by a private agreement , but no decision located for this guide decides whether that bars a separate obligation to repay compensation that had already vested. The conservative course is to state in the award or bonus agreement, before payment, that the payment is an advance that vests only over the commitment period, rather than to try to recover pay the agreement had already made unconditional.

Recovering the money from wages is a separate question. Wages may be paid net of a deduction only where the deduction is provided by law or authorized by Department of Labor and Industry regulation , so an enforceable repayment debt does not by itself permit an employer to withhold it from pay.

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Case law · 2000-05-03B.1
Hartman v. Baker, 766 A.2d 347 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2000)

The Superior Court held that the Wage Payment and Collection Law does not create a substantive right to compensation but only a right to enforce payment of wages to which the employee is entitled by the terms of an agreement.

The WPCL “does not create an employee’s substantive right to compensation; rather, it only establishes an employee’s right to enforce payment of wages and compensation to which an employee is otherwise entitled by the terms of an agreement.”

See Hartman v. Baker, 766 A.2d 347 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2000)

Primary source · Case law · 2016-08-03B.2
Willis Re Inc. v. Hearn, 200 F. Supp. 3d 540 (E.D. Pa. 2016)

The Eastern District of Pennsylvania treated a departing executive's obligation to repay a portion of incentive awards as turning on whether he retired under the award agreements, and found that he did not retire under their terms.

If Hearn “retired” from Willis Re, he has no obligation to repay incentive awards; if Hearn did not “retire” from Willis Re, he is obligated to repay a portion of incentive awards. We find Hearn did not “retire” under the terms of the parties’ agreements.

See Willis Re Inc. v. Hearn, 200 F. Supp. 3d 540 (E.D. Pa. 2016).

Primary source · Primary lawB.3
43 P.S. § 260.2a

43 P.S. § 260.2a defines wages to include all earnings of an employee, however calculated, and fringe benefits or wage supplements.

"Wages." Includes all earnings of an employe, regardless of whether determined on time, task, piece, commission or other method of calculation. The term "wages" also includes fringe benefits or wage supplements whether payable by the employer from his funds or from amounts withheld from the employes' pay by the employer.

See 43 P.S. § 260.2a

Primary source · Case law · 2016-08-03B.4
Willis Re Inc. v. Hearn, 200 F. Supp. 3d 540 (E.D. Pa. 2016)

The Eastern District of Pennsylvania stated that under the Wage Payment and Collection Law bonuses are protected wages if they are earned, meaning the right to the bonus vested under the terms of employment.

Similarly, under Pennsylvania’s Wage Payment and Collection Law, bonuses are wages protected under the statute if they are “earned,” meaning the “right to the wage or bonus vested under the terms of employment.”

See Willis Re Inc. v. Hearn, 200 F. Supp. 3d 540 (E.D. Pa. 2016).

Primary source · Primary lawB.5
43 P.S. § 260.7

43 P.S. § 260.7 provides that no provision of the Wage Payment and Collection Law may be contravened or set aside by a private agreement.

No provision of this act shall in any way be contravened or set aside by a private agreement.

See 43 P.S. § 260.7

Primary source · Primary lawB.6
43 P.S. § 260.3(a)

43 P.S. § 260.3(a) requires wages to be paid in money or by check, except that deductions provided by law or authorized by Department of Labor and Industry regulation for the employee's convenience may be made.

The wages shall be paid in lawful money of the United States or check, except that deductions provided by law, or as authorized by regulation of the Department of Labor and Industry for the convenience of the employe, may be made including deductions of contributions to employe benefit plans which are subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, 29 U.S.C. § 1001 et seq.

See 43 P.S. § 260.3(a)

Can a Pennsylvania employer take a repayment out of the final paycheck?

A Pennsylvania employer may deduct a repayment from final wages only when the deduction is provided by law or authorized by Department of Labor and Industry regulation . The regulation's list includes repayment of a bona fide loan from the employer when the employee authorizes the deduction in writing when the loan is made or afterward . A deduction that does not fit a listed category needs the employee's written authorization and the Department's approval .

The written authorization alone is not enough for an unlisted deduction. In Ressler v. Jones Motor Co., the Superior Court held that a wage deduction of the kind before it, which the regulation did not list, is unlawful absent a showing of both Department approval and the employees' written authorizations , and it found that without Department approval the employer had wrongfully withheld wages even though employees had signed authorizations . The regulation also lists deductions for an employee's purchases from the employer of goods, services, facilities and similar items, if authorized in writing or by a collective bargaining agreement . No Pennsylvania decision located for this guide decides whether a training, relocation or sign-on bonus repayment obligation is a bona fide loan or a purchase of services for these purposes, so the conservative course is to document the advance as a loan with a written deduction authorization, or to collect the balance by demand rather than from wages.

The minimum wage still limits a deduction. The deduction rules do not authorize a deduction below the Minimum Wage Act minimum for an expense or charge the employer requires or authorizes in connection with the employee's assigned duties , and the state minimum is $7.25 an hour for all hours worked, subject to the Act's exclusions and exemptions . An agreement to work for less than the minimum wage is no defense to the employee's action for the shortfall . Where federal law applies, wages count as paid only when they are paid finally and unconditionally, or free and clear .

Timing runs while the deduction question is open: a separated employee's earned wages are due no later than the next regular payday on which they would otherwise be due . The statute separately provides that an employer's good-faith assertion of a set-off is not a violation if the employer has paid all wages due in excess of the amount asserted . No Pennsylvania appellate decision located for this guide reconciles that set-off provision with the deduction rules for a training or bonus repayment, so the conservative course is to pay the final wages in full and pursue the repayment separately. If withheld wages remain unpaid for 30 days beyond the regular payday and no good-faith dispute or set-off accounts for the nonpayment, the employee may also claim liquidated damages of 25 percent of the wages due or $500, whichever is greater .

Practice caution

A final-paycheck deduction for a training or bonus repayment that is not a listed deduction and has no Department approval risks being treated as an unlawful deduction even when the employee signed an authorization, leaving the withheld amount owed as unpaid wages .

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Primary lawC.1
43 P.S. § 260.3(a)

43 P.S. § 260.3(a) requires wages to be paid in money or by check, except that deductions provided by law or authorized by Department of Labor and Industry regulation for the employee's convenience may be made.

The wages shall be paid in lawful money of the United States or check, except that deductions provided by law, or as authorized by regulation of the Department of Labor and Industry for the convenience of the employe, may be made including deductions of contributions to employe benefit plans which are subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, 29 U.S.C. § 1001 et seq.

See 43 P.S. § 260.3(a)

Primary source · RegulationC.2
34 Pa. Code § 9.1(10)PDF

34 Pa. Code § 9.1(10) authorizes deductions to repay bona fide loans from the employer if the employee authorizes them in writing when the loan is made or afterward.

(10) Deductions for repayment to the employer of bona fide loans provided the employe authorizes such deductions in writing either at the time the loan is given him or subsequent to such loan.

See 34 Pa. Code § 9.1(10)

Primary source · RegulationC.3
34 Pa. Code § 9.1(13)PDF

34 Pa. Code § 9.1(13) authorizes other deductions authorized in writing by employees that the Department, in its discretion, finds proper and in conformity with the Wage Payment and Collection Law.

(13) Such other deductions authorized in writing by employes as in the discretion of the Department is proper and in conformity with the intent and purpose of the Wage Payment and Collection Law (43 P. S. §§ 260.1—260.12).

See 34 Pa. Code § 9.1(13)

Primary source · Case law · 1985-01-18C.4
Ressler v. Jones Motor Co., 487 A.2d 424 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1985)

The Superior Court held that a wage deduction of the kind before it, not listed in 34 Pa. Code § 9.1, is unlawful absent a showing of both Department of Labor and Industry approval and the employees' written authorizations.

We therefore hold that a deduction from wages as herein described in the case before us is unlawful absent a showing of Department of Labor and Industry approval and written authorizations by employees.

See Ressler v. Jones Motor Co., 337 Pa. Super. 602, 487 A.2d 424 (1985).

Primary source · Case law · 1985-01-18C.5
Ressler v. Jones Motor Co., 487 A.2d 424 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1985)

The Superior Court held that a wage withholding plan not listed in 34 Pa. Code § 9.1 was invalid absent Department approval, even though employees had signed written authorizations, so the employer wrongfully withheld wages.

Absent departmental approval, the Plan was invalid, and Jones Motor wrongfully withheld wages due to its employees.

See Ressler v. Jones Motor Co., 337 Pa. Super. 602, 487 A.2d 424 (1985).

Primary source · RegulationC.6
34 Pa. Code § 9.1(11)PDF

34 Pa. Code § 9.1(11) authorizes deductions for the employee's purchases from the employer of goods, services, facilities and similar items if authorized in writing or by a collective bargaining agreement.

(11) Deductions for purchases or replacements by the employe from the employer of goods, wares, merchandise, services, facilities, rent or similar items provided such deductions are authorized by the employe in writing or are authorized in a collective bargaining agreement.

See 34 Pa. Code § 9.1(11)

Primary source · RegulationC.7
34 Pa. Code § 9.2PDF

34 Pa. Code § 9.2 provides that nothing in the deduction rules authorizes a deduction below the Minimum Wage Act minimum for an expense or charge the employer requires or authorizes in connection with the employee's assigned duties.

Nothing in this subchapter authorizes a deduction below the minimum wage applicable under The Minimum Wage Act of 1968 (43 P. S. §§ 333.101— 333.115) for an expense or charge which is required or authorized by the employer in connection with the employe’s performance of the duties assigned by the employer.

See 34 Pa. Code § 9.2

Primary source · RegulationC.8
34 Pa. Code § 231.101aPDF

34 Pa. Code § 231.101a(a) requires employers to pay at least $7.25 an hour for all hours worked, subject to the Minimum Wage Act's exclusions and exemptions.

Under section 4(a.1) of the act (43 P.S. § 333.104(a.1)), an employer shall pay at least $7.25 an hour to all employees for all hours worked subject to exclusions and exemptions contained in the act and this chapter.

See 34 Pa. Code § 231.101a(a)

Primary source · Primary lawC.9
43 P.S. § 333.113

43 P.S. § 333.113 lets an employee paid less than the minimum wage recover the shortfall with costs and attorney's fees, and makes an agreement to work for less than the minimum wage no defense.

If any employe is paid by his or her employer less than the minimum wages provided by section 4 of this act or by any regulation issued thereunder, such worker may recover in a civil action the full amount of such minimum wage less any amount actually paid to the worker by the employer, together with costs and such reasonable attorney's fees as may be allowed by the court, and any agreement between the employer and the worker to work for less than such minimum wage shall be no defense to such action.

See 43 P.S. § 333.113

Primary source · RegulationC.10
29 C.F.R. § 531.35

Under the federal rule, wages count as paid only when paid finally and unconditionally, or free and clear.

Whether in cash or in facilities, “wages” cannot be considered to have been paid by the employer and received by the employee unless they are paid finally and unconditionally or “free and clear.”

See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35

Primary source · Primary lawC.11
43 P.S. § 260.5(a)

43 P.S. § 260.5(a) makes earned wages due to a separated employee no later than the next regular payday on which they would otherwise be due.

Whenever an employer separates an employe from the payroll, or whenever an employe quits or resigns his employment, the wages or compensation earned shall become due and payable not later than the next regular payday of his employer on which such wages would otherwise be due and payable.

See 43 P.S. § 260.5(a)

Primary source · Primary lawC.12
43 P.S. § 260.11a(b)

43 P.S. § 260.11a(b) provides that an employer's good-faith dispute of a wage claim or good-faith assertion of a set-off or counterclaim is not a violation of the Wage Payment and Collection Law, provided the employer has paid all wages due in excess of the amount in dispute or asserted as a set-off.

The good faith contest or dispute by any employer of any wage claim or the good faith assertion of a right of set-off or counter-claim shall not be considered a violation of this act: Provided, That the employer has paid all wages due in excess of the amount in dispute or asserted to be subject to a right of set-off or counter-claim.

See 43 P.S. § 260.11a(b)

Primary source · Primary lawC.13
43 P.S. § 260.10

43 P.S. § 260.10 entitles an employee to liquidated damages of 25 percent of the wages due or $500, whichever is greater, when wages remain unpaid for 30 days beyond the regular payday and no good-faith contest, dispute or assertion of a set-off or counterclaim accounts for the nonpayment.

Where wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the regularly scheduled payday, or, in the case where no regularly scheduled payday is applicable, for sixty days beyond the filing by the employe of a proper claim or for sixty days beyond the date of the agreement, award or other act making wages payable, or where shortages in the wage payments made exceed five percent (5%) of the gross wages payable on any two regularly scheduled paydays in the same calendar quarter, and no good faith contest or dispute of any wage claim including the good faith assertion of a right of set-off or counter-claim exists accounting for such non-payment, the employe shall be entitled to claim, in addition, as liquidated damages an amount equal to twenty-five percent (25%) of the total amount of wages due, or five hundred dollars ($500), whichever is greater.

See 43 P.S. § 260.10

Are training or tuition repayments treated differently in Pennsylvania?

Pennsylvania training, tuition and relocation repayment terms generally face the same penalty rule and wage-deduction rules as bonus repayment terms, because no statute of general application gives them a separate rule. Covered health care practitioners are the exception, under a statute effective January 1, 2025 that covers medical doctors, doctors of osteopathy, certified registered nurse anesthetists, certified registered nurse practitioners and physician assistants .

The Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act preserves enforcement of a provision that lets an employer recover reasonable expenses that are directly attributable to the practitioner and accrued within three years before separation, unless separation is caused by dismissal; that relate to relocation, training and establishment of a patient base; and that are amortized over up to five years from separation .

The Act's main rule is a limit on non-competes. A health care practitioner noncompete covenant entered into after the effective date is void and unenforceable , except that an employer may enforce one of no more than one year if the practitioner was not dismissed . The Act defines a noncompete covenant by its effect: an agreement that impedes the practitioner's ability to continue treating patients or accepting new patients after the term of employment . Subsection (c)(1) is a rule of construction for that section, so an expense-recovery provision that meets its conditions is not prohibited by the non-compete rule; it still has to be enforceable as a contract. The three-year accrual condition in subsection (c)(1)(i) carries an exception where separation is caused by dismissal of the practitioner , and the Act does not say how that exception changes the recovery; no Pennsylvania decision located for this guide decides whether an expense-recovery provision outside those conditions is itself a noncompete covenant. The conservative course for a covered practitioner is to limit any repayment to expenses that meet all three conditions and not to seek recovery from a practitioner the employer dismissed.

A pending bill would add a general rule. H.B. 421, introduced in the 2025-2026 session, would bar an employer from requiring a training repayment agreement as a condition of employment and would make such an agreement void . As of November 19, 2026, the bill's last recorded action is referral to the House Labor and Industry Committee on January 30, 2025 , so it is not current law.

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Case law · 2002-06-19D.1
Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., 798 A.2d 1277 (Pa. 2002)

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court stated that a penalty is fixed not as a pre-estimate of probable actual damages but as a punishment designed to prevent the breach.

A penalty, by contrast, is fixed, “not as a pre-estimate of probable actual damages, but as a punishment, the threat of which is designed to prevent the breach.”

See Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., 568 Pa. 601, 798 A.2d 1277 (2002).

Primary source · Primary lawD.2
43 P.S. § 260.3(a)

43 P.S. § 260.3(a) requires wages to be paid in money or by check, except that deductions provided by law or authorized by Department of Labor and Industry regulation for the employee's convenience may be made.

The wages shall be paid in lawful money of the United States or check, except that deductions provided by law, or as authorized by regulation of the Department of Labor and Industry for the convenience of the employe, may be made including deductions of contributions to employe benefit plans which are subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, 29 U.S.C. § 1001 et seq.

See 43 P.S. § 260.3(a)

Primary source · Primary lawD.3
Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act § 7

Section 7 of Act 74 of 2024 provides that the Act takes effect January 1, 2025.

Section 7. Effective date. This act shall take effect January 1, 2025.

See Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act, Act of July 17, 2024, P.L. 846, No. 74, § 7 (Pa.).

Primary source · Primary lawD.4
Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act § 3

Section 3 of Act 74 of 2024 defines a health care practitioner as a medical doctor, a doctor of osteopathy, a certified registered nurse anesthetist, a certified registered nurse practitioner or a physician assistant, each as defined in the cited licensing statutes.

"Health care practitioner." The following: (1) A medical doctor as defined in section 2 of the act of December 20, 1985 (P.L.457, No.112), known as the Medical Practice Act of 1985. (2) A doctor of osteopathy under the act of October 5, 1978 (P.L.1109, No.261), known as the Osteopathic Medical Practice Act. (3) A certified registered nurse anesthetist as defined in section 2(16) of the act of May 22, 1951 (P.L.317, No.69), known as The Professional Nursing Law. (4) A certified registered nurse practitioner as defined in section 2(12) of The Professional Nursing Law. (5) A physician assistant as defined in section 2 of the Osteopathic Medical Practice Act or section 2 of the Medical Practice Act of 1985.

See Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act, Act of July 17, 2024, P.L. 846, No. 74, § 3 (Pa.).

Primary source · Primary lawD.5
Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act § 4(c)(1)

Section 4(c)(1) of Act 74 of 2024 provides that the noncompete section does not prohibit enforcing a contract provision letting an employer recover reasonable expenses from a health care practitioner that are directly attributable to the practitioner and accrued within three years before separation unless separation is caused by dismissal, related to relocation, training and establishment of a patient base, and amortized over up to five years from separation.

(c) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be construed to: (1) Prohibit the enforcement of a contract provision that allows an employer to recover reasonable expenses from a health care practitioner, if the expenses are: (i) Directly attributable to the health care practitioner and accrued within the three years prior to separation, unless separation is caused by dismissal of the health care practitioner. (ii) Related to relocation, training and establishment of a patient base. (iii) Amortized over a period of up to five years from the date of separation by the health care practitioner.

See Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act, Act of July 17, 2024, P.L. 846, No. 74, § 4(c)(1) (Pa.).

Primary source · Primary lawD.6
Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act § 4(a)

Section 4(a) of Act 74 of 2024 makes a health care practitioner noncompete covenant entered into after the subsection's effective date void and unenforceable, except as subsection (b) provides.

(a) Applicability.--Except as provided under subsection (b), a noncompete covenant entered into after the effective date of this subsection is deemed contrary to the public policy and is void and unenforceable by an employer.

See Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act, Act of July 17, 2024, P.L. 846, No. 74, § 4(a) (Pa.).

Primary source · Primary lawD.7
Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act § 4(b)

Section 4(b) of Act 74 of 2024 lets an employer enforce a health care practitioner noncompete covenant of no more than one year if the practitioner was not dismissed.

(b) Exception.--An employer may enforce a noncompete covenant if the length of the noncompete covenant is no more than one year, provided that the health care practitioner was not dismissed by the employer.

See Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act, Act of July 17, 2024, P.L. 846, No. 74, § 4(b) (Pa.).

Primary source · Primary lawD.8
Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act § 3

Section 3 of Act 74 of 2024 defines a noncompete covenant as an agreement between an employer and a health care practitioner in Pennsylvania that has the effect of impeding the practitioner's ability to continue treating or accepting patients after the term of employment.

"Noncompete covenant." An agreement that is entered into between an employer and a health care practitioner in this Commonwealth which has the effect of impeding the ability of the health care practitioner to continue treating patients or accepting new patients, either practicing independently or in the employment of a competing employer after the term of employment.

See Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act, Act of July 17, 2024, P.L. 846, No. 74, § 3 (Pa.).

Primary source · Primary lawD.9
H.B. 421, Printer's No. 395 (Pa. 2025)

H.B. 421, as introduced, would bar an employer from requiring a training repayment agreement as a condition of employment and would make such an agreement void.

(a) Prohibition.--An employer may not require, as a condition of employment, an employee or prospective employee to enter into a training repayment agreement. (b) Effect.--A training repayment agreement involving an employee is void, and the employee shall not be obligated to make any payment under the training repayment agreement.

See H.B. 421, Printer's No. 395, 2025-2026 Reg. Sess. § 3 (Pa. 2025).

Primary source · Primary lawD.10
H.B. 421 bill information, 2025-2026 Regular Session

The General Assembly's bill record shows H.B. 421's last action as referral to the House Labor and Industry Committee on January 30, 2025, with no votes or committee meetings recorded.

Last Action: Referred to Labor & Industry, Jan. 30, 2025 House H S | 0395 | Referred to Labor & Industry, Jan. 30, 2025 | Printers Numbers Votes There are no votes available. Committee Meetings There are no committee meetings available. Statute References There are no statute references for this bill.

See H.B. 421, 2025-2026 Reg. Sess., bill history (Pa.).

How are Pennsylvania repayment and wage-deduction rules enforced?

An employee whose wages were withheld for a repayment can sue under the Wage Payment and Collection Law, which lets any employee or other party to whom wages are payable bring an action . The court must award reasonable attorneys' fees against the defendant in addition to any judgment for the plaintiff . The employer's own repayment claim is an ordinary contract claim, enforceable only to the extent the term is not a penalty .

When wages remain unpaid for 30 days beyond the regular payday, the employee may also claim liquidated damages of 25 percent of the wages due or $500, whichever is greater, unless a good-faith contest, dispute or assertion of a set-off or counterclaim accounts for the nonpayment . Liquidated damages are tied to a claim for unpaid wages: in Aita v. NCB Management Services, Inc., where the employer had paid late retention bonuses before the employee sued, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that the employee had no claim for unpaid wages and so could not bring a standalone claim for liquidated damages . A Wage Payment and Collection Law claim must be brought within three years after the wages were due . A deduction that takes pay below the minimum wage also supports a Minimum Wage Act action for the shortfall with costs and attorney's fees, and an agreement to work for less is no defense .

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Primary lawE.1
43 P.S. § 260.9a(a)

43 P.S. § 260.9a(a) lets any employee or other party to whom wages are payable bring actions under the Wage Payment and Collection Law.

(a) Any employe or group of employes, labor organization or party to whom any type of wages is payable may institute actions provided under this act.

See 43 P.S. § 260.9a(a)

Primary source · Primary lawE.2
43 P.S. § 260.9a(f)

43 P.S. § 260.9a(f) requires the court in a Wage Payment and Collection Law action to award reasonable attorneys' fees against the defendant in addition to any judgment for the plaintiff.

The court in any action brought under this section shall, in addition to any judgment awarded to the plaintiff or plaintiffs, allow costs for reasonable attorneys' fees of any nature to be paid by the defendant.

See 43 P.S. § 260.9a(f)

Primary source · Case law · 2002-06-19E.3
Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., 798 A.2d 1277 (Pa. 2002)

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court stated that a penalty is fixed not as a pre-estimate of probable actual damages but as a punishment designed to prevent the breach.

A penalty, by contrast, is fixed, “not as a pre-estimate of probable actual damages, but as a punishment, the threat of which is designed to prevent the breach.”

See Pantuso Motors, Inc. v. Corestates Bank, N.A., 568 Pa. 601, 798 A.2d 1277 (2002).

Primary source · Primary lawE.4
43 P.S. § 260.10

43 P.S. § 260.10 entitles an employee to liquidated damages of 25 percent of the wages due or $500, whichever is greater, when wages remain unpaid for 30 days beyond the regular payday and no good-faith contest, dispute or assertion of a set-off or counterclaim accounts for the nonpayment.

Where wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the regularly scheduled payday, or, in the case where no regularly scheduled payday is applicable, for sixty days beyond the filing by the employe of a proper claim or for sixty days beyond the date of the agreement, award or other act making wages payable, or where shortages in the wage payments made exceed five percent (5%) of the gross wages payable on any two regularly scheduled paydays in the same calendar quarter, and no good faith contest or dispute of any wage claim including the good faith assertion of a right of set-off or counter-claim exists accounting for such non-payment, the employe shall be entitled to claim, in addition, as liquidated damages an amount equal to twenty-five percent (25%) of the total amount of wages due, or five hundred dollars ($500), whichever is greater.

See 43 P.S. § 260.10

Primary source · Case law · 2026-10-29E.5
Aita v. NCB Management Services, Inc., No. 25 MAP 2025 (Pa. Oct. 29, 2026)PDF

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that an employee whose late-paid wages had been paid in full before he filed suit had no claim for unpaid wages, so his standalone claim for Wage Payment and Collection Law liquidated damages was not permitted.

Therefore, at the time Aita filed his WPCL action, he had no claim for unpaid wages. As Section 260.9a(b) authorizes actions “to recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages,” and does not contain any provisions entitling a plaintiff to pursue liquidated damages in the absence of a claim for unpaid wages, we hold Aita’s standalone claim for liquidated damages was not permitted as a matter of law.

See Aita v. NCB Management Services, Inc., No. 25 MAP 2025 (Pa. Oct. 29, 2026).

Primary source · Primary lawE.6
43 P.S. § 260.9a(g)

43 P.S. § 260.9a(g) bars a Wage Payment and Collection Law proceeding for unpaid wages or liquidated damages brought more than three years after the wages were due.

No administrative proceedings or legal action shall be instituted under the provisions of this act for the collection of unpaid wages or liquidated damages more than three years after the day on which such wages were due and payable as provided in sections 3 and 5.

See 43 P.S. § 260.9a(g)

Primary source · Primary lawE.7
43 P.S. § 333.113

43 P.S. § 333.113 lets an employee paid less than the minimum wage recover the shortfall with costs and attorney's fees, and makes an agreement to work for less than the minimum wage no defense.

If any employe is paid by his or her employer less than the minimum wages provided by section 4 of this act or by any regulation issued thereunder, such worker may recover in a civil action the full amount of such minimum wage less any amount actually paid to the worker by the employer, together with costs and such reasonable attorney's fees as may be allowed by the court, and any agreement between the employer and the worker to work for less than such minimum wage shall be no defense to such action.

See 43 P.S. § 333.113

What repayment structure is safest under Pennsylvania law?

A Pennsylvania employee repayment provision presents less penalty risk when its amount estimates the employer's foreseeable loss from an early departure rather than deterring departure . It documents the advance as a bona fide loan with the employee's written authorization to deduct repayment given when the loan is made or afterward . Any deduction should leave pay at or above the minimum wage , and a repayment that is not a listed deduction should be collected by demand rather than from wages .

For a covered health care practitioner, the expense-recovery provision should be limited to reasonable expenses that are directly attributable to the practitioner, accrued within three years before separation, related to relocation, training and establishment of a patient base, and amortized over up to five years from separation . A repayment that applies only if the employee goes to work for a competitor should also meet the requirements for a restrictive covenant: ancillary to employment, supported by adequate consideration, reasonably limited in duration and geography, and designed to protect a legitimate interest .

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Case law · 1991-05-23F.1
Holt's Cigar Co. v. 222 Liberty Associates, 591 A.2d 743 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1991)

The Superior Court reaffirmed Pennsylvania's policy of holding unenforceable liquidated damages clauses intended as a penalty rather than as a measure of foreseeable business losses.

In sum, today we reaffirm this jurisdiction’s policy of holding unenforceable those liquidated damages clauses intended as a penalty rather than as a measure of foreseeable business losses.

See Holt's Cigar Co. v. 222 Liberty Associates, 404 Pa. Super. 578, 591 A.2d 743 (1991).

Primary source · RegulationF.2
34 Pa. Code § 9.1(10)PDF

34 Pa. Code § 9.1(10) authorizes deductions to repay bona fide loans from the employer if the employee authorizes them in writing when the loan is made or afterward.

(10) Deductions for repayment to the employer of bona fide loans provided the employe authorizes such deductions in writing either at the time the loan is given him or subsequent to such loan.

See 34 Pa. Code § 9.1(10)

Primary source · RegulationF.3
34 Pa. Code § 9.2PDF

34 Pa. Code § 9.2 provides that nothing in the deduction rules authorizes a deduction below the Minimum Wage Act minimum for an expense or charge the employer requires or authorizes in connection with the employee's assigned duties.

Nothing in this subchapter authorizes a deduction below the minimum wage applicable under The Minimum Wage Act of 1968 (43 P. S. §§ 333.101— 333.115) for an expense or charge which is required or authorized by the employer in connection with the employe’s performance of the duties assigned by the employer.

See 34 Pa. Code § 9.2

Primary source · Case law · 1985-01-18F.4
Ressler v. Jones Motor Co., 487 A.2d 424 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1985)

The Superior Court held that a wage deduction of the kind before it, not listed in 34 Pa. Code § 9.1, is unlawful absent a showing of both Department of Labor and Industry approval and the employees' written authorizations.

We therefore hold that a deduction from wages as herein described in the case before us is unlawful absent a showing of Department of Labor and Industry approval and written authorizations by employees.

See Ressler v. Jones Motor Co., 337 Pa. Super. 602, 487 A.2d 424 (1985).

Primary source · Primary lawF.5
Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act § 4(c)(1)

Section 4(c)(1) of Act 74 of 2024 provides that the noncompete section does not prohibit enforcing a contract provision letting an employer recover reasonable expenses from a health care practitioner that are directly attributable to the practitioner and accrued within three years before separation unless separation is caused by dismissal, related to relocation, training and establishment of a patient base, and amortized over up to five years from separation.

(c) Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be construed to: (1) Prohibit the enforcement of a contract provision that allows an employer to recover reasonable expenses from a health care practitioner, if the expenses are: (i) Directly attributable to the health care practitioner and accrued within the three years prior to separation, unless separation is caused by dismissal of the health care practitioner. (ii) Related to relocation, training and establishment of a patient base. (iii) Amortized over a period of up to five years from the date of separation by the health care practitioner.

See Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act, Act of July 17, 2024, P.L. 846, No. 74, § 4(c)(1) (Pa.).

Primary source · Case law · 2015-11-18F.6
Socko v. Mid-Atlantic Systems of CPA, Inc., 126 A.3d 1266 (Pa. 2015)

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that restrictive covenants are enforceable only if ancillary to employment, supported by adequate consideration, reasonably limited in duration and geographic extent, and designed to protect the employer's legitimate interests.

Consistent with this legal background, currently in Pennsylvania, restrictive covenants are enforceable only if they are: (1) ancillary to an employment relationship between an employee and an employer; (2) supported by adequate consideration; (3) the restrictions are reasonably limited in duration and geographic extent; and (4) the restrictions are designed to protect the legitimate interests of the employer.

See Socko v. Mid-Atlantic Systems of CPA, Inc., 126 A.3d 1266 (Pa. 2015).

Also for Pennsylvania

Was this guide useful?

Give feedback

Researching a different jurisdiction? This survey covers all 19 U.S. jurisdictions →