Are repayment terms enforceable in Ohio?
Ohio courts generally enforce a stay-or-pay repayment promise as a contract , but a fixed amount stipulated as damages for leaving early is enforced only if it is liquidated damages, not a penalty, under the Samson Sales test . Under that test the damages must be uncertain and difficult to prove, the contract as a whole must not be so unconscionable, unreasonable and disproportionate that it fails to express the parties' true intention, and the parties must have intended the stated amount to follow a breach . Ohio has no statute in force that bans or limits stay-or-pay, training-repayment or sign-on bonus repayment terms in private employment.
A stipulated amount is enforced if it was reasonable when the contract was formed and bears a reasonable, though not necessarily exact, relation to actual damages . A penalty, by contrast, is designed to coerce performance by punishing nonperformance , and courts ordinarily treat a manifestly inequitable and unrealistic amount as a penalty .
Ohio appellate courts have enforced training repayment, and they have limited recovery to the cost of the training actually given when the agreed figure exceeded it. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. In NetJets, Inc. v. Binning, the Tenth District affirmed a $14,914 judgment against a former employee because a valid contract existed and his voluntary resignation triggered his obligation to reimburse training costs . In United Assn. Local 168 v. Robinson, the Fourth District held that a $40,000 repayment term for a five-year apprenticeship was a penalty, in part because the figure bore no reasonable relationship to the cost of the less than two years of training actually provided, but it held that the training fund could still recover its actual damages for the training given. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. In GROB Systems, Inc. v. McDermott, the Third District upheld an award of $739.11 to an employer under an apprenticeship repayment agreement, calculated by prorating its training costs by the days remaining in the commitment, after the trial court treated the reimbursement clause as not a liquidated damages provision. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group. A covenant accompanying a repayment term that restrains the employee from competing with the former employer is tested under Raimonde v. Van Vlerah, which asks whether it is no greater than the employer needs, imposes no undue hardship on the employee and does not injure the public .
Senate Bill 11 of the 136th General Assembly is a pending bill, not law: it was referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee on January 29, 2025, and its legislative status page showed no later action when we checked it on November 19, 2026 . As introduced, it would prohibit an agreement requiring a departing worker to reimburse training costs, and agreements imposing liquidated damages or a retraining fee for leaving, and it would void only agreements entered into, modified or extended after it took effect. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group.
A flat repayment amount that stays the same however much of the commitment the employee served risks being held a penalty, leaving the employer to prove its actual or prorated training cost. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Sources for this answer
In *NetJets, Inc. v. Binning*, the Tenth District affirmed a $14,914 breach-of-contract judgment for an employer because a valid contract existed and the employee's voluntary resignation triggered his obligation to reimburse training costs.
Defendant-appellant, Michael Binning, appeals from a judgment of the Franklin County Municipal Court awarding plaintiff-appellee, NetJets, Inc. ("NetJets"), damages in the amount of $14,914 on NetJets' breach of contract claim against defendant. Because a valid contract existed between defendant and NetJets, and because defendant voluntarily resigned his employment, triggering his obligation to reimburse NetJets for training costs, we affirm.
See NetJets, Inc. v. Binning, 2005-Ohio-3934 (10th Dist.)
In *Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney*, the Supreme Court of Ohio applied the *Samson Sales* test: an agreed amount is liquidated damages, not a penalty, if the damages would be uncertain and difficult to prove, the contract as a whole is not so unconscionable, unreasonable and disproportionate that it does not express the parties' true intention, and the parties intended the stated amount to follow a breach.
Where the parties have agreed on the amount of damages, ascertained by estimation and adjustment, and have expressed this agreement in clear and unambiguous terms, the amount so fixed should be treated as liquidated damages and not as a penalty, if the damages would be (1) uncertain as to amount and difficult of proof, and if (2) the contract as a whole is not so manifestly unconscionable, unreasonable, and disproportionate in amount as to justify the conclusion that it does not express the true intention of the parties, and if (3) the contract is consistent with the conclusion that it was the intention of the parties that damages in the amount stated should follow the breach thereof.
See Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney, 66 Ohio St.3d 376 (1993)
*Lake Ridge Academy* holds that a stipulated damages provision is enforced if it was reasonable when the contract was formed and bears a reasonable, though not necessarily exact, relation to actual damages.
If the provision was reasonable at the time of formation and it bears a reasonable (not necessarily exact) relation to actual damages, the provision will be enforced.
See Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney, 66 Ohio St.3d 376 (1993)
*Lake Ridge Academy* explains that a penalty is designed to coerce performance by punishing nonperformance rather than to compensate the nonbreaching party's losses.
A penalty is designed to coerce performance by punishing nonperformance; its principal object is not compensation for the losses suffered by the nonbreaching party.
See Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney, 66 Ohio St.3d 376 (1993)
In *Samson Sales, Inc. v. Honeywell, Inc.*, the Supreme Court of Ohio stated that reasonable compensation for actual damages is the legitimate objective of a liquidated damages provision and that courts ordinarily treat a manifestly inequitable and unrealistic amount as a penalty.
However, reasonable compensation for actual damages is the legitimate objective of such liquidated damage provisions and where the amount specified is manifestly inequitable and unrealistic, courts will ordinarily regard it as a penalty.
See Samson Sales, Inc. v. Honeywell, Inc., 12 Ohio St.3d 27 (1984)
*Robinson* held that, although the repayment term was a penalty, the training fund was entitled to recover its actual damages for training and educating the apprentice during the time he actually spent in the program.
However, the trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of Robinson on the issue of damages because JATC was entitled to recoup its actual damages for training and educating Robinson during the actual time he spent in the apprenticeship program.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
In *United Assn. Local 168 v. Robinson*, the Fourth District held a $40,000 repayment term for a five-year apprenticeship to be a penalty in part because the figure bore no reasonable relationship to the damages from providing less than two years of training.
As stated above, we reach this decision, in part, because the figure of $40,000 bears no reasonable relationship to the damages JATC would have actually sustained in providing less than two-year’s worth of training and education to Robinson, as opposed to five.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
In *GROB Systems, Inc. v. McDermott*, the Third District upheld an award of $739.11 to an employer under an apprenticeship repayment agreement, holding that the trial court did not err by using a prorated amount of damages.
As we have found that the trial court’s determination to award GROB $739.11 is not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and that the trial court did not err by utilizing a prorated amount of damages, GROB’s first and second assignments of error are overruled.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
*GROB* describes the trial court's valuation as dividing the employer's training costs over the contract by the number of days remaining in the apprentice's commitment.
The trial court thus employed its own valuation, breaking the contract down by number of days remaining out of the total contract amount versus dollars incurred for training over the course of the contract.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
*GROB* reviewed a judgment that treated the apprenticeship reimbursement clause as not a liquidated damages provision and declined to award the employer its total incurred costs because the apprentice had nearly fulfilled the contract.
The trial court did not award GROB its total incurred costs because it determined that paragraph 14 was not meant to be a liquidated damages provision, and because the $15,202.09 figure was not actually reflective of damages incurred by GROB since McDermott had so nearly fulfilled the terms of the contract.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
In *Raimonde v. Van Vlerah*, the Supreme Court of Ohio held that a covenant restraining a former employee from competing is reasonable if it is no greater than required to protect the employer, does not impose undue hardship on the employee, and does not injure the public.
A covenant restraining an employee from competing with his former employer upon termination of employment is reasonable if it is no greater than is required for the protection of the employer, does not impose undue hardship on the employee, and is not injurious to the public.
See Raimonde v. Van Vlerah, 42 Ohio St.2d 21 (1975)
The Ohio Legislature's status page for Senate Bill 11 lists its introduction on January 22, 2025 and its referral to the Senate Judiciary Committee on January 29, 2025, with no later action.
| Date | Chamber | Action | Committee | |---|---|---|---| | 1-29-2025 | Senate | Referred to committee | Judiciary | | 1-22-2025 | Senate | Introduced | Learn More : Glossary of Terms | The Legislative Process The online versions of legislation provided on this website are not official. Enrolled bills are the final version passed by the Ohio General Assembly and presented to the Governor for signature. The official version of acts signed by the Governor are available from the Secretary of State's Office at 180 S. Civic Center Dr., Columbus, OH 43215.
See Ohio Legislature, S.B. 11 status (136th Gen. Assemb.)
Senate Bill 11 of the 136th General Assembly, a pending bill, lists among the agreements it would prohibit one requiring a departing worker to reimburse the employer for training, orientation, evaluation or other skills services provided during the relationship.
(4) An agreement that requires a worker who terminates the work relationship to reimburse the employer for an expense incurred by the employer during the relationship for training, orientation, evaluation, or other service intended to provide the worker with skills to perform the work or to improve performance.
See S.B. 11, 136th Gen. Assemb. (Ohio 2025)
Senate Bill 11, a pending bill, would also prohibit agreements requiring a departing worker to pay lost profits, lost goodwill or liquidated damages, or imposing a fee or cost for leaving, such as a replacement hire fee or retraining fee.
(2) An agreement that requires the worker to pay for lost profits, lost goodwill, or liquidated damages because the worker terminates the work relationship; (3) An agreement that imposes a fee or cost on a worker for terminating the work relationship, including a replacement hire fee, a retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, or bondage fee; (4) An agreement that requires a worker who terminates the work relationship to reimburse the employer for an expense incurred by the employer during the relationship for training, orientation, evaluation, or other service intended to provide the worker with skills to perform the work or to improve performance.
See S.B. 11, 136th Gen. Assemb. (Ohio 2025)
Senate Bill 11 would void only prohibited agreements entered into, modified or extended on or after its effective date.
An agreement, or part of an agreement, between an employer and worker entered into, modified, or extended on or after the effective date of this section that is prohibited under division (A) of this section is void.
See S.B. 11, 136th Gen. Assemb. (Ohio 2025)
In *United Assn. Local 168 v. Robinson*, the Fourth District held a $40,000 repayment term for a five-year apprenticeship to be a penalty in part because the figure bore no reasonable relationship to the damages from providing less than two years of training.
As stated above, we reach this decision, in part, because the figure of $40,000 bears no reasonable relationship to the damages JATC would have actually sustained in providing less than two-year’s worth of training and education to Robinson, as opposed to five.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
In *GROB Systems, Inc. v. McDermott*, the Third District upheld an award of $739.11 to an employer under an apprenticeship repayment agreement, holding that the trial court did not err by using a prorated amount of damages.
As we have found that the trial court’s determination to award GROB $739.11 is not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and that the trial court did not err by utilizing a prorated amount of damages, GROB’s first and second assignments of error are overruled.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
Can an Ohio employer claw back pay already received?
An Ohio employer can recover a bonus paid in advance when the employee leaves before meeting the agreed conditions On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group., but a bonus the employee has already earned must be paid . In CommuteAir, L.L.C. v. Bremer, the agreement required a pilot trainee to repay a $22,100 new-hire incentive bonus if he left the program, did not complete the required training or was terminated for cause, and the Eighth District affirmed judgment for the employer, holding that the payment was a bonus and not a wage. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 4 sources in this group. In Wall v. Pizza Outlet, L.P., by contrast, the Fifth District held that a manager who had met every condition of a profit-share bonus except continued employment had earned it before his termination, so the employer had to pay it, and it treated a bonus whose timing alone the employer controlled as more in the nature of a commission. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
No Ohio statute addresses clawing back a sign-on, retention or relocation payment, so recovery turns on the contract: Ohio courts have enforced repayment promises , allowed recovery of actual damages where a fixed figure failed , and ordinarily treat a manifestly inequitable and unrealistic stipulated amount as a penalty . Earned wages are protected by the minimum wage, which every covered employer must pay , and federal law treats wages kicked back to the employer, directly or indirectly, as unpaid .
Taking a bonus repayment out of later pay is limited separately. Ohio's wage-payment statute counts repayment of a loan or other obligation among employee authorized deductions , and a payroll deduction plan survives the ban on assigning future wages only if the employee can revoke it at any time before payment . Senate Bill 11, a bill referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee on January 29, 2025, with no later action on its status page as of November 19, 2026 , states as introduced that it would not prevent paying or forgiving a debt, or providing other benefits, after a person completes a specified period of employment .
Sources for this answer
*CommuteAir* found that the pilot trainee was required by the contract to repay his $22,100 bonus if he left the training program.
Additionally, Bremer was required by the contract to repay his bonus if he left the program.
See CommuteAir, L.L.C. v. Bremer, 2025-Ohio-4843 (8th Dist.)
*CommuteAir* affirmed the trial court's judgment for the employer on breach-of-contract liability and an award of attorney fees.
Defendant-appellant Karl Bremer (“Bremer”) appeals the trial court’s judgment in favor of plaintiff-appellee CommuteAir LLC as Successor in Interest to Champlain Enterprises LLC dba CommuteAir (“CommuteAir”) for breach of contract liability and an award of attorney fees. Bremer asks this court to remand for a new trial. We affirm.
See CommuteAir, L.L.C. v. Bremer, 2025-Ohio-4843 (8th Dist.)
In *Wall v. Pizza Outlet, L.P.*, the Fifth District held that a manager who met every condition of a profit-share bonus except continued employment had earned it before his termination, so the employer was required to pay it.
Because the trial court found the parties entered into a contract for 25% of profits, and because all conditions precedent (but for continued employment) were met, we find appellant earned the bonus/commission prior to his termination. Accordingly appellee was required to pay the bonus.
See Wall v. Pizza Outlet, L.P., 2002-Ohio-3483 (5th Dist.)
*CommuteAir* found that the agreement also made the trainee responsible for repaying the bonus if he did not complete the required training or was terminated for cause.
Additionally, if Bremer did not complete the required training or if he was terminated for cause, he was responsible for repaying the bonus.
See CommuteAir, L.L.C. v. Bremer, 2025-Ohio-4843 (8th Dist.)
In *CommuteAir, L.L.C. v. Bremer*, the Eighth District held that a $22,100 bonus paid to a pilot trainee under a new-hire incentive program was a bonus, not a wage.
As a participant in the RTP, Bremer was not earning a wage, because he was not being compensated for his labor. He was in training to become a pilot, and the bonus payment to him was a part of CommuteAir’s new hire pilot incentive program. The money was in addition to the compensation he would earn as a pilot with CommuteAir. Thus, the $22,100 was a bonus payment and not a wage.
See CommuteAir, L.L.C. v. Bremer, 2025-Ohio-4843 (8th Dist.)
*Wall* treated a bonus as more in the nature of a commission where the employer controlled only when, not whether, it would be paid.
When an employer retains the ability to choose when it will pay a bonus, as opposed to whether any bonus is due, we find the bonus, in actuality, more in the nature of a commission than a bonus.
See Wall v. Pizza Outlet, L.P., 2002-Ohio-3483 (5th Dist.)
In *NetJets, Inc. v. Binning*, the Tenth District affirmed a $14,914 breach-of-contract judgment for an employer because a valid contract existed and the employee's voluntary resignation triggered his obligation to reimburse training costs.
Defendant-appellant, Michael Binning, appeals from a judgment of the Franklin County Municipal Court awarding plaintiff-appellee, NetJets, Inc. ("NetJets"), damages in the amount of $14,914 on NetJets' breach of contract claim against defendant. Because a valid contract existed between defendant and NetJets, and because defendant voluntarily resigned his employment, triggering his obligation to reimburse NetJets for training costs, we affirm.
See NetJets, Inc. v. Binning, 2005-Ohio-3934 (10th Dist.)
*Robinson* held that, although the repayment term was a penalty, the training fund was entitled to recover its actual damages for training and educating the apprentice during the time he actually spent in the program.
However, the trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of Robinson on the issue of damages because JATC was entitled to recoup its actual damages for training and educating Robinson during the actual time he spent in the apprenticeship program.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
In *Samson Sales, Inc. v. Honeywell, Inc.*, the Supreme Court of Ohio stated that reasonable compensation for actual damages is the legitimate objective of a liquidated damages provision and that courts ordinarily treat a manifestly inequitable and unrealistic amount as a penalty.
However, reasonable compensation for actual damages is the legitimate objective of such liquidated damage provisions and where the amount specified is manifestly inequitable and unrealistic, courts will ordinarily regard it as a penalty.
See Samson Sales, Inc. v. Honeywell, Inc., 12 Ohio St.3d 27 (1984)
Ohio Rev. Code § 4111.02 requires every employer, as defined in Article II, section 34a of the Ohio Constitution, to pay each employee at least the constitutional minimum wage rate.
Every employer, as defined in Section 34a of Article II, Ohio Constitution, shall pay each of the employer's employees at a wage rate of not less than the wage rate specified in Section 34a of Article II, Ohio Constitution.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4111.02
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 provides that FLSA wage requirements are not met where the employee kicks back part of the wage to the employer, directly or indirectly.
The wage requirements of the Act will not be met where the employee “kicks-back” directly or indirectly to the employer or to another person for the employer's benefit the whole or part of the wage delivered to the employee.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(D)(3) lists deductions for repayment of a loan or other obligation among employee authorized deductions.
(3) "Employee authorized deduction" includes but is not limited to deductions for the purpose of any of the following:(a) Purchase of United States savings bonds or corporate stocks or bonds ;(b) A charitable contribution ;(c) Credit union savings or other regular savings program ;(d) Repayment of a loan or other obligation.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(D)(3)
Ohio Rev. Code § 1321.32 invalidates wage assignments other than those for court-ordered support of an employee's spouse or minor child, does not affect agreed checkoffs on wages between employers and employees, and it preserves deductions under a payroll deduction plan agreed between employer and employee only if the employee can revoke the plan at any time, on notice to the employer, up to the time of payment.
Notwithstanding section 1321.31 of the Revised Code, no assignment of, or order for wages or salary is valid unless the wages assigned or ordered are to be paid for the support of the employee's spouse or minor child in complying with an order of a court of record for the support of the employee's spouse or minor child. This section does not affect or invalidate any contract or agreement between employers and their employees, or as between employers, employees, and any labor union as to any checkoff on the wages of such employees as may be agreed upon. This section and section 4113.16 of the Revised Code shall not affect or invalidate any deduction from the wages or salary made in accordance with a payroll deduction plan agreed upon between the employer and employee provided that the same be revocable at any time by the employee upon notice to the employer up to the time of payment thereof.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 1321.32
The Ohio Legislature's status page for Senate Bill 11 lists its introduction on January 22, 2025 and its referral to the Senate Judiciary Committee on January 29, 2025, with no later action.
| Date | Chamber | Action | Committee | |---|---|---|---| | 1-29-2025 | Senate | Referred to committee | Judiciary | | 1-22-2025 | Senate | Introduced | Learn More : Glossary of Terms | The Legislative Process The online versions of legislation provided on this website are not official. Enrolled bills are the final version passed by the Ohio General Assembly and presented to the Governor for signature. The official version of acts signed by the Governor are available from the Secretary of State's Office at 180 S. Civic Center Dr., Columbus, OH 43215.
See Ohio Legislature, S.B. 11 status (136th Gen. Assemb.)
Senate Bill 11 states that it would not prevent paying or forgiving a debt, or providing other benefits, after a person completes a specified period of employment.
(C) This section does not do either of the following: (1) Prevent a person or federal, state, or local government agency from paying or forgiving a debt or from providing other benefits to a person after the person completes a specified time period of employment or work relationship with an employer or other entity; (2) Limit or prohibit any loan repayment assistance program or loan forgiveness program provided by a federal, state, or local government agency.
See S.B. 11, 136th Gen. Assemb. (Ohio 2025)
Can repayment come out of an Ohio final paycheck?
The statutory safe route for taking a repayment out of Ohio wages, including final wages, is a payroll deduction plan the employee has agreed to and can revoke at any time before payment, with pay kept at or above the minimum wage and any required overtime pay. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group. Ohio law makes assignments of future wages invalid except as R.C. 1321.32 provides; apart from court-ordered support, that section leaves agreed wage checkoffs between employers and employees unaffected and preserves deductions under an agreed payroll deduction plan that the employee may revoke, on notice to the employer, up to the time of payment. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. The wage-payment statute defines the wage due as the net amount after taxes, written-agreement fringe-benefit deductions and employee authorized deductions, and it lists repayment of a loan or other obligation as one. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. R.C. 4113.16 also bars an employer from contracting out of the wage-payment statute, so if the deduction depends solely on the revocable-plan exception, an employee's timely revocation means the employer must collect the balance separately. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. In our review we found no Ohio appellate decision on whether an irrevocable repayment deduction counts as an agreed checkoff, so the conservative course is to use a revocable plan.
Ohio has no separate final-paycheck deadline in that statute; by default, wages earned in the first half of a month are due by the first day of the next month, and wages earned in the second half by the fifteenth . The statute also allows daily or weekly pay and refers to a longer interval customary to a trade or occupation, or a different interval set by written contract or by law . If wages stay unpaid thirty days past the regular payday and no dispute or counterclaim accounts for the nonpayment, the employer also owes liquidated damages of six percent of the undisputed amount or $200, whichever is greater .
Every covered employer must pay at least the minimum wage , and the conservative course is to keep pay at or above it after any repayment deduction. The Ohio minimum wage for non-tipped employees is $11.00 an hour in 2026 and is scheduled to rise to $11.40 an hour in 2027; employees under 16, and employees of employers grossing less than $405,000 in 2026 or $419,000 in 2027, are owed the federal $7.25 rate instead. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. Federal law separately treats a payment kicked back to the employer as unpaid wages, and the regulation's example treats the cost of employer-required tools of the trade as a violation in any workweek when it cuts into the minimum or overtime wages. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. That a deduction is allowed does not make the underlying repayment debt enforceable; the employer must still have a valid claim under the contract, which for a fixed figure that fails the penalty rule is limited to actual damages . In our review we found no Ohio appellate decision on deducting a training or bonus repayment from final wages.
Withholding a repayment from final pay without an arrangement R.C. 1321.32 preserves, such as a revocable payroll deduction plan the employee has not revoked, risks leaving the deducted amount unpaid ; if it stays unpaid thirty days past the regular payday with no genuine dispute or counterclaim accounting for it, the employer owes the statutory six-percent or $200 liquidated damages . A deduction that cuts pay below the minimum wage separately exposes the employer to the constitutional remedy of back wages plus damages of twice that amount .
Sources for this answer
Ohio Rev. Code § 1321.32 invalidates wage assignments other than those for court-ordered support of an employee's spouse or minor child, does not affect agreed checkoffs on wages between employers and employees, and it preserves deductions under a payroll deduction plan agreed between employer and employee only if the employee can revoke the plan at any time, on notice to the employer, up to the time of payment.
Notwithstanding section 1321.31 of the Revised Code, no assignment of, or order for wages or salary is valid unless the wages assigned or ordered are to be paid for the support of the employee's spouse or minor child in complying with an order of a court of record for the support of the employee's spouse or minor child. This section does not affect or invalidate any contract or agreement between employers and their employees, or as between employers, employees, and any labor union as to any checkoff on the wages of such employees as may be agreed upon. This section and section 4113.16 of the Revised Code shall not affect or invalidate any deduction from the wages or salary made in accordance with a payroll deduction plan agreed upon between the employer and employee provided that the same be revocable at any time by the employee upon notice to the employer up to the time of payment thereof.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 1321.32
Ohio Rev. Code § 4111.02 requires every employer, as defined in Article II, section 34a of the Ohio Constitution, to pay each employee at least the constitutional minimum wage rate.
Every employer, as defined in Section 34a of Article II, Ohio Constitution, shall pay each of the employer's employees at a wage rate of not less than the wage rate specified in Section 34a of Article II, Ohio Constitution.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4111.02
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 treats employer-required tool costs as a violation in any workweek when they cut into the required minimum or overtime wages.
For example, if it is a requirement of the employer that the employee must provide tools of the trade which will be used in or are specifically required for the performance of the employer's particular work, there would be a violation of the Act in any workweek when the cost of such tools purchased by the employee cuts into the minimum or overtime wages required to be paid him under the Act.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.16 bars an employer from contracting out of the wage-payment statute and makes assignments of future wages invalid except as provided in § 1321.32.
No employer subject to section 4113.15 of the Revised Code shall, by a special contract with an employee or by other means, exempt the employer from this section and section 4113.15 of the Revised Code, and no assignments of future wages, payable semimonthly under such sections are valid except as provided in section 1321.32 of the Revised Code.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.16
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(D)(1) defines a wage, for the pay-timing statute, as the net amount payable to an employee less taxes withheld, written-agreement fringe-benefit deductions and any employee authorized deduction.
(1) "Wage" means the net amount of money payable to an employee, including any guaranteed pay or reimbursement for expenses, less any federal, state, or local taxes withheld; any deductions made pursuant to a written agreement for the purpose of providing the employee with any fringe benefits; and any employee authorized deduction.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(D)(1)
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(D)(3) lists deductions for repayment of a loan or other obligation among employee authorized deductions.
(3) "Employee authorized deduction" includes but is not limited to deductions for the purpose of any of the following:(a) Purchase of United States savings bonds or corporate stocks or bonds ;(b) A charitable contribution ;(c) Credit union savings or other regular savings program ;(d) Repayment of a loan or other obligation.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(D)(3)
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(A) requires an employer doing business in Ohio to pay wages earned in the first half of a month by the first day of the next month, and wages earned in the second half by the fifteenth day of the next month.
(A) Every employer doing business in this state shall, on or before the first day of each month, pay all its employees the wages earned by them during the first half of the preceding month ending with the fifteenth day thereof, and shall, on or before the fifteenth day of each month, pay such employees the wages earned by them during the last half of the preceding calendar month.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(A)
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(A) does not prohibit daily or weekly payment of wages and refers to a longer time lapse customary to a trade, profession or occupation, or a different time lapse established by written contract or by operation of law.
This section does not prohibit the daily or weekly payment of wages. The use of a longer time lapse that is customary to a given trade, profession or occupation, or establishment of a different time lapse by written contract or by operation of law.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(A)
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(B) makes an employer liable for liquidated damages of six percent of the undisputed unpaid claim or $200, whichever is greater, when wages remain unpaid thirty days after the regular payday and no contest, court order or dispute, including a counterclaim, accounts for the nonpayment.
(B) Where wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the regularly scheduled payday or, in the case where no regularly scheduled payday is applicable, for sixty days beyond the filing by the employee of a claim or for sixty days beyond the date of the agreement, award, or other act making wages payable and no contest court order or dispute of any wage claim including the assertion of a counterclaim exists accounting for nonpayment, the employer, in addition, as liquidated damages, is liable to the employee in an amount equal to six per cent of the amount of the claim still unpaid and not in contest or disputed or two hundred dollars, whichever is greater.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(B)
The Ohio Department of Commerce's 2026 minimum-wage poster sets the 2026 minimum wage for non-tipped employees at $11.00 an hour, with the federal $7.25 rate for employers grossing less than $405,000 and for employees under 16.
NON-TIPPED EMPLOYEES A Minimum Wage of $11.00 per hour “Non-Tipped Employees” includes any employee who does not engage in an occupation in which he/she customarily and regularly receives more than thirty dollars ($30.00) per month in tips. “Employers” who gross less than $405,000 shall pay their employees no less than the current federal minimum wage rate. “Employees” under the age of 16 shall be paid no less than the current federal minimum wage rate. “Current Federal Minimum Wage” is $7.25 per hour.
See Ohio Department of Commerce, 2026 Minimum Wage
The Ohio Department of Commerce's 2027 minimum-wage poster sets the 2027 minimum wage for non-tipped employees at $11.40 an hour, with the federal $7.25 rate for employers grossing less than $419,000 and for employees under 16.
NON-TIPPED EMPLOYEES A Minimum Wage of $11.40 per hour “Non-Tipped Employees” includes any employee who does not engage in an occupation in which he/she customarily and regularly receives more than thirty dollars ($30.00) per month in tips. “Employers” who gross less than $419,000 shall pay their employees no less than the current federal minimum wage rate. “Employees” under the age of 16 shall be paid no less than the current federal minimum wage rate. “Current Federal Minimum Wage” is $7.25 per hour.
See Ohio Department of Commerce, 2027 Minimum Wage
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 provides that FLSA wage requirements are not met where the employee kicks back part of the wage to the employer, directly or indirectly.
The wage requirements of the Act will not be met where the employee “kicks-back” directly or indirectly to the employer or to another person for the employer's benefit the whole or part of the wage delivered to the employee.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
*Robinson* held that, although the repayment term was a penalty, the training fund was entitled to recover its actual damages for training and educating the apprentice during the time he actually spent in the program.
However, the trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of Robinson on the issue of damages because JATC was entitled to recoup its actual damages for training and educating Robinson during the actual time he spent in the apprenticeship program.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
Ohio Rev. Code § 1321.32 invalidates wage assignments other than those for court-ordered support of an employee's spouse or minor child, does not affect agreed checkoffs on wages between employers and employees, and it preserves deductions under a payroll deduction plan agreed between employer and employee only if the employee can revoke the plan at any time, on notice to the employer, up to the time of payment.
Notwithstanding section 1321.31 of the Revised Code, no assignment of, or order for wages or salary is valid unless the wages assigned or ordered are to be paid for the support of the employee's spouse or minor child in complying with an order of a court of record for the support of the employee's spouse or minor child. This section does not affect or invalidate any contract or agreement between employers and their employees, or as between employers, employees, and any labor union as to any checkoff on the wages of such employees as may be agreed upon. This section and section 4113.16 of the Revised Code shall not affect or invalidate any deduction from the wages or salary made in accordance with a payroll deduction plan agreed upon between the employer and employee provided that the same be revocable at any time by the employee upon notice to the employer up to the time of payment thereof.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 1321.32
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(B) makes an employer liable for liquidated damages of six percent of the undisputed unpaid claim or $200, whichever is greater, when wages remain unpaid thirty days after the regular payday and no contest, court order or dispute, including a counterclaim, accounts for the nonpayment.
(B) Where wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the regularly scheduled payday or, in the case where no regularly scheduled payday is applicable, for sixty days beyond the filing by the employee of a claim or for sixty days beyond the date of the agreement, award, or other act making wages payable and no contest court order or dispute of any wage claim including the assertion of a counterclaim exists accounting for nonpayment, the employer, in addition, as liquidated damages, is liable to the employee in an amount equal to six per cent of the amount of the claim still unpaid and not in contest or disputed or two hundred dollars, whichever is greater.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(B)
Ohio Rev. Code § 4111.02 requires every employer, as defined in Article II, section 34a of the Ohio Constitution, to pay each employee at least the constitutional minimum wage rate.
Every employer, as defined in Section 34a of Article II, Ohio Constitution, shall pay each of the employer's employees at a wage rate of not less than the wage rate specified in Section 34a of Article II, Ohio Constitution.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4111.02
Article II, section 34a of the Ohio Constitution requires an employer found to have violated the minimum-wage section to pay back wages, damages of an additional two times the back wages, and the employee's costs and reasonable attorney fees within thirty days of the finding.
Where an employer is found by the state or a court to have violated any provision of this section, the employer shall within thirty days of the finding pay the employee back wages, damages, and the employee's costs and reasonable attorney's fees. Damages shall be calculated as an additional two times the amount of the back wages and in the case of a violation of an anti-retaliation provision an amount set by the state or court sufficient to compensate the employee and deter future violations, but not less than one hundred fifty dollars for each day that the violation continued.
See Ohio Const. art. II, § 34a
Are Ohio training or tuition repayments treated differently?
No Ohio statute in force specifically regulates training, tuition or relocation repayment agreements in private employment. Ohio courts enforce a training-repayment promise as a contract , and they test a fixed amount stipulated as damages for leaving under the same liquidated-damages rule as any other agreed amount . Ohio appellate courts have enforced training repayment, and when the agreed figure outran the cost of the training actually given, they have limited recovery to that cost. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
In NetJets, the Tenth District enforced an employee's promise to reimburse training costs after he resigned voluntarily . In Robinson, the Fourth District treated an apprenticeship repayment term as a work-or-pay provision that let the training fund recoup its education and training costs, not as a non-competition agreement . It held the $40,000 flat figure a penalty because it bore no reasonable relationship to the cost of the training actually provided, and allowed recovery of actual damages for the training given. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. The court also concluded that the apprentice and the training fund were not in an employer-employee relationship , so its reasoning applies to an employer's own training program by analogy. In GROB, an employer's apprenticeship agreement, the Third District upheld a damages award that prorated the employer's training costs by the days remaining in the commitment, after the trial court treated the reimbursement clause as not a liquidated damages provision. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 4 sources in this group.
An Ohio employer can secure a training repayment with a cognovit note: in Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein, the Eighth District held that a cognovit note executed for an agreed $10,000 training cost, arising out of an employment contract, was not a consumer transaction. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. The employee's remaining challenges, including whether the amount owed adequately represented the employer's training costs, were held not to be meritorious defenses to the judgment. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Federal law adds a floor: wages are not paid where the employee kicks back part of the wage to the employer, and the regulation's example treats employer-required tool costs as a violation in any workweek when they cut into the minimum or overtime wages. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. Senate Bill 11, referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee on January 29, 2025, with no later action on its status page as of November 19, 2026 , would, if enacted as introduced, void a new agreement requiring a departing worker to reimburse training, orientation or evaluation costs, but only for agreements entered into, modified or extended after it took effect. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Sources for this answer
In *NetJets, Inc. v. Binning*, the Tenth District affirmed a $14,914 breach-of-contract judgment for an employer because a valid contract existed and the employee's voluntary resignation triggered his obligation to reimburse training costs.
Defendant-appellant, Michael Binning, appeals from a judgment of the Franklin County Municipal Court awarding plaintiff-appellee, NetJets, Inc. ("NetJets"), damages in the amount of $14,914 on NetJets' breach of contract claim against defendant. Because a valid contract existed between defendant and NetJets, and because defendant voluntarily resigned his employment, triggering his obligation to reimburse NetJets for training costs, we affirm.
See NetJets, Inc. v. Binning, 2005-Ohio-3934 (10th Dist.)
In *Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney*, the Supreme Court of Ohio applied the *Samson Sales* test: an agreed amount is liquidated damages, not a penalty, if the damages would be uncertain and difficult to prove, the contract as a whole is not so unconscionable, unreasonable and disproportionate that it does not express the parties' true intention, and the parties intended the stated amount to follow a breach.
Where the parties have agreed on the amount of damages, ascertained by estimation and adjustment, and have expressed this agreement in clear and unambiguous terms, the amount so fixed should be treated as liquidated damages and not as a penalty, if the damages would be (1) uncertain as to amount and difficult of proof, and if (2) the contract as a whole is not so manifestly unconscionable, unreasonable, and disproportionate in amount as to justify the conclusion that it does not express the true intention of the parties, and if (3) the contract is consistent with the conclusion that it was the intention of the parties that damages in the amount stated should follow the breach thereof.
See Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney, 66 Ohio St.3d 376 (1993)
*Robinson* held that, although the repayment term was a penalty, the training fund was entitled to recover its actual damages for training and educating the apprentice during the time he actually spent in the program.
However, the trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of Robinson on the issue of damages because JATC was entitled to recoup its actual damages for training and educating Robinson during the actual time he spent in the apprenticeship program.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
*Robinson* characterized the apprenticeship repayment term as a work-or-pay provision allowing the training fund to recoup its cost of education and training, rather than as a non-competition agreement.
Instead, the provision at issue here can also be characterized as a work-or-pay provision that allows JATC to recoup its cost in providing education and training to its apprentices, whether they breach the terms of their apprenticeship or whether they complete their apprenticeship.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
In *United Assn. Local 168 v. Robinson*, the Fourth District held a $40,000 repayment term for a five-year apprenticeship to be a penalty in part because the figure bore no reasonable relationship to the damages from providing less than two years of training.
As stated above, we reach this decision, in part, because the figure of $40,000 bears no reasonable relationship to the damages JATC would have actually sustained in providing less than two-year’s worth of training and education to Robinson, as opposed to five.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
*Robinson* concluded that the relationship between the apprentice and the training fund was not an employer-employee relationship and that the repayment provision was not a non-competition agreement.
As such, we cannot conclude the relationship between the parties here constituted an employer- employee relationship or that the repayment provision at issue here constituted a non-competition agreement.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
In *GROB Systems, Inc. v. McDermott*, the Third District upheld an award of $739.11 to an employer under an apprenticeship repayment agreement, holding that the trial court did not err by using a prorated amount of damages.
As we have found that the trial court’s determination to award GROB $739.11 is not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and that the trial court did not err by utilizing a prorated amount of damages, GROB’s first and second assignments of error are overruled.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
*GROB* describes the trial court's valuation as dividing the employer's training costs over the contract by the number of days remaining in the apprentice's commitment.
The trial court thus employed its own valuation, breaking the contract down by number of days remaining out of the total contract amount versus dollars incurred for training over the course of the contract.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
*GROB* found nothing illogical in the trial court's valuation, which prorated the employer's training costs by the days remaining in the apprentice's commitment.
After reviewing the record, we find nothing illogical about the trial court’s valuation here.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
*GROB* reviewed a judgment that treated the apprenticeship reimbursement clause as not a liquidated damages provision and declined to award the employer its total incurred costs because the apprentice had nearly fulfilled the contract.
The trial court did not award GROB its total incurred costs because it determined that paragraph 14 was not meant to be a liquidated damages provision, and because the $15,202.09 figure was not actually reflective of damages incurred by GROB since McDermott had so nearly fulfilled the terms of the contract.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
*Overdrive Espresso* states that the cognovit note was executed for the agreed training cost of $10,000.
The note was executed for the agreed- upon training cost of $10,000.
See Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein, 2025-Ohio-5226 (8th Dist.)
In *Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein*, the Eighth District held that a cognovit note for $10,000 in training costs, signed with an employment agreement, did not arise from a consumer transaction under R.C. 2323.13(E).
Thus, we cannot say that this transaction, arising out of employment contract, was a consumer transaction as defined under R.C. 2323.13(E).
See Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein, 2025-Ohio-5226 (8th Dist.)
*Overdrive Espresso* identifies the employee's remaining challenges, including whether the amount owed on the note adequately represented the employer's training costs.
Finein’s remaining claims challenge the enforceability of the cognovit note under New York law and federal law. Finein also challenges whether the amount owed on the note adequately represents the training costs incurred by Overdrive.
See Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein, 2025-Ohio-5226 (8th Dist.)
*Overdrive Espresso* held that the employee's challenges, including that the note's amount did not represent the employer's training costs, were not meritorious defenses to the cognovit judgment.
Since none of Finein’s remaining claims amount to a meritorious defense to a cognovit note, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in rejecting these claims.
See Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein, 2025-Ohio-5226 (8th Dist.)
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 provides that FLSA wage requirements are not met where the employee kicks back part of the wage to the employer, directly or indirectly.
The wage requirements of the Act will not be met where the employee “kicks-back” directly or indirectly to the employer or to another person for the employer's benefit the whole or part of the wage delivered to the employee.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 treats employer-required tool costs as a violation in any workweek when they cut into the required minimum or overtime wages.
For example, if it is a requirement of the employer that the employee must provide tools of the trade which will be used in or are specifically required for the performance of the employer's particular work, there would be a violation of the Act in any workweek when the cost of such tools purchased by the employee cuts into the minimum or overtime wages required to be paid him under the Act.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
The Ohio Legislature's status page for Senate Bill 11 lists its introduction on January 22, 2025 and its referral to the Senate Judiciary Committee on January 29, 2025, with no later action.
| Date | Chamber | Action | Committee | |---|---|---|---| | 1-29-2025 | Senate | Referred to committee | Judiciary | | 1-22-2025 | Senate | Introduced | Learn More : Glossary of Terms | The Legislative Process The online versions of legislation provided on this website are not official. Enrolled bills are the final version passed by the Ohio General Assembly and presented to the Governor for signature. The official version of acts signed by the Governor are available from the Secretary of State's Office at 180 S. Civic Center Dr., Columbus, OH 43215.
See Ohio Legislature, S.B. 11 status (136th Gen. Assemb.)
Senate Bill 11 of the 136th General Assembly, a pending bill, lists among the agreements it would prohibit one requiring a departing worker to reimburse the employer for training, orientation, evaluation or other skills services provided during the relationship.
(4) An agreement that requires a worker who terminates the work relationship to reimburse the employer for an expense incurred by the employer during the relationship for training, orientation, evaluation, or other service intended to provide the worker with skills to perform the work or to improve performance.
See S.B. 11, 136th Gen. Assemb. (Ohio 2025)
Senate Bill 11 would void only prohibited agreements entered into, modified or extended on or after its effective date.
An agreement, or part of an agreement, between an employer and worker entered into, modified, or extended on or after the effective date of this section that is prohibited under division (A) of this section is void.
See S.B. 11, 136th Gen. Assemb. (Ohio 2025)
What happens to an Ohio employer that over-collects a repayment from pay?
An Ohio employer that withholds pay below the minimum wage must, within thirty days of a finding by the state or a court, pay back wages, damages of an additional two times the back wages, and the employee's costs and reasonable attorney fees . An employee or the attorney general may sue within three years of the violation, or of when a continuing violation ceased, or within one year after the employee is notified of the state's final disposition of a complaint, whichever is later .
Wages left unpaid thirty days past the regular payday, with no dispute or counterclaim accounting for the nonpayment, also carry liquidated damages of six percent of the undisputed amount or $200, whichever is greater .
An employer suing to collect a written repayment promise has six years after the claim accrues to bring the action . In Overdrive Espresso, the Eighth District upheld a judgment confessed on a cognovit note executed for an agreed $10,000 training cost, holding that the note arose out of an employment contract rather than a consumer transaction and that the employee raised no meritorious defense. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group.
Sources for this answer
Article II, section 34a of the Ohio Constitution requires an employer found to have violated the minimum-wage section to pay back wages, damages of an additional two times the back wages, and the employee's costs and reasonable attorney fees within thirty days of the finding.
Where an employer is found by the state or a court to have violated any provision of this section, the employer shall within thirty days of the finding pay the employee back wages, damages, and the employee's costs and reasonable attorney's fees. Damages shall be calculated as an additional two times the amount of the back wages and in the case of a violation of an anti-retaliation provision an amount set by the state or court sufficient to compensate the employee and deter future violations, but not less than one hundred fifty dollars for each day that the violation continued.
See Ohio Const. art. II, § 34a
Article II, section 34a of the Ohio Constitution allows an employee or the attorney general to sue for a minimum-wage violation within three years of the violation, or of when a continuing violation ceased, or within one year after the state's final disposition of a complaint, whichever is later.
An action for equitable and monetary relief may be brought against an employer by the attorney general and/or an employee or person acting on behalf of an employee or all similarly situated employees in any court of competent jurisdiction, including the common pleas court of an employee's county of residence, for any violation of this section or any law or regulation implementing its provisions within three years of the violation or of when the violation ceased if it was of a continuing nature, or within one year after notification to the employee of final disposition by the state of a complaint for the same violation, whichever is later.
See Ohio Const. art. II, § 34a
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(B) makes an employer liable for liquidated damages of six percent of the undisputed unpaid claim or $200, whichever is greater, when wages remain unpaid thirty days after the regular payday and no contest, court order or dispute, including a counterclaim, accounts for the nonpayment.
(B) Where wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the regularly scheduled payday or, in the case where no regularly scheduled payday is applicable, for sixty days beyond the filing by the employee of a claim or for sixty days beyond the date of the agreement, award, or other act making wages payable and no contest court order or dispute of any wage claim including the assertion of a counterclaim exists accounting for nonpayment, the employer, in addition, as liquidated damages, is liable to the employee in an amount equal to six per cent of the amount of the claim still unpaid and not in contest or disputed or two hundred dollars, whichever is greater.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(B)
Ohio Rev. Code § 2305.06 requires an action on a written agreement, contract or promise to be brought within six years after the cause of action accrues, subject to listed exceptions.
Except as provided in sections 126.301, 1302.98, 1303.16, 1345.10, and 2305.04 and division (B) of section 2305.041 of the Revised Code, an action upon a specialty or an agreement, contract, or promise in writing shall be brought within six years after the cause of action accrued.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 2305.06
*Overdrive Espresso* states that the cognovit note was executed for the agreed training cost of $10,000.
The note was executed for the agreed- upon training cost of $10,000.
See Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein, 2025-Ohio-5226 (8th Dist.)
In *Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein*, the Eighth District held that a cognovit note for $10,000 in training costs, signed with an employment agreement, did not arise from a consumer transaction under R.C. 2323.13(E).
Thus, we cannot say that this transaction, arising out of employment contract, was a consumer transaction as defined under R.C. 2323.13(E).
See Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein, 2025-Ohio-5226 (8th Dist.)
*Overdrive Espresso* held that the employee's challenges, including that the note's amount did not represent the employer's training costs, were not meritorious defenses to the cognovit judgment.
Since none of Finein’s remaining claims amount to a meritorious defense to a cognovit note, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in rejecting these claims.
See Overdrive Espresso, L.L.C. v. Finein, 2025-Ohio-5226 (8th Dist.)
What repayment structure is safest under Ohio law?
The safest Ohio repayment term is a clear contractual promise, which Ohio courts enforce , with an amount that is reasonable when signed and bears a reasonable relation to the employer's likely loss, because that is what Ohio courts require to enforce an agreed amount. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. As a drafting inference, that means tying the amount to documented training or hiring costs and reducing it as the employee serves the commitment: the Fourth District refused a flat figure that ignored how much training had been provided, and the Third District approved damages that prorated training costs by the days remaining. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group.
If the employer wants to deduct a balance from pay, the deduction should run through a payroll deduction plan the employee agrees to and may revoke at any time before payment, because that is the arrangement R.C. 1321.32 expressly preserves from the ban on assigning future wages On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group., and it should leave at least the minimum wage and any required overtime pay On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.; the wage-payment statute counts repayment of a loan or other obligation as an employee authorized deduction . Final wages remain due on the regular pay schedule, which by default is semimonthly unless a customary, contractual or legal interval applies On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group., so the conservative course is to pay them in full and collect any disputed balance separately.
Sources for this answer
In *NetJets, Inc. v. Binning*, the Tenth District affirmed a $14,914 breach-of-contract judgment for an employer because a valid contract existed and the employee's voluntary resignation triggered his obligation to reimburse training costs.
Defendant-appellant, Michael Binning, appeals from a judgment of the Franklin County Municipal Court awarding plaintiff-appellee, NetJets, Inc. ("NetJets"), damages in the amount of $14,914 on NetJets' breach of contract claim against defendant. Because a valid contract existed between defendant and NetJets, and because defendant voluntarily resigned his employment, triggering his obligation to reimburse NetJets for training costs, we affirm.
See NetJets, Inc. v. Binning, 2005-Ohio-3934 (10th Dist.)
*Lake Ridge Academy* holds that a stipulated damages provision is enforced if it was reasonable when the contract was formed and bears a reasonable, though not necessarily exact, relation to actual damages.
If the provision was reasonable at the time of formation and it bears a reasonable (not necessarily exact) relation to actual damages, the provision will be enforced.
See Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney, 66 Ohio St.3d 376 (1993)
In *Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney*, the Supreme Court of Ohio applied the *Samson Sales* test: an agreed amount is liquidated damages, not a penalty, if the damages would be uncertain and difficult to prove, the contract as a whole is not so unconscionable, unreasonable and disproportionate that it does not express the parties' true intention, and the parties intended the stated amount to follow a breach.
Where the parties have agreed on the amount of damages, ascertained by estimation and adjustment, and have expressed this agreement in clear and unambiguous terms, the amount so fixed should be treated as liquidated damages and not as a penalty, if the damages would be (1) uncertain as to amount and difficult of proof, and if (2) the contract as a whole is not so manifestly unconscionable, unreasonable, and disproportionate in amount as to justify the conclusion that it does not express the true intention of the parties, and if (3) the contract is consistent with the conclusion that it was the intention of the parties that damages in the amount stated should follow the breach thereof.
See Lake Ridge Academy v. Carney, 66 Ohio St.3d 376 (1993)
In *United Assn. Local 168 v. Robinson*, the Fourth District held a $40,000 repayment term for a five-year apprenticeship to be a penalty in part because the figure bore no reasonable relationship to the damages from providing less than two years of training.
As stated above, we reach this decision, in part, because the figure of $40,000 bears no reasonable relationship to the damages JATC would have actually sustained in providing less than two-year’s worth of training and education to Robinson, as opposed to five.
See United Assn. Local 168, Apprentice Educational Fund v. Robinson, 2025-Ohio-2421 (4th Dist.)
In *GROB Systems, Inc. v. McDermott*, the Third District upheld an award of $739.11 to an employer under an apprenticeship repayment agreement, holding that the trial court did not err by using a prorated amount of damages.
As we have found that the trial court’s determination to award GROB $739.11 is not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and that the trial court did not err by utilizing a prorated amount of damages, GROB’s first and second assignments of error are overruled.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
*GROB* describes the trial court's valuation as dividing the employer's training costs over the contract by the number of days remaining in the apprentice's commitment.
The trial court thus employed its own valuation, breaking the contract down by number of days remaining out of the total contract amount versus dollars incurred for training over the course of the contract.
See GROB Sys., Inc. v. McDermott, 2024-Ohio-1734 (3d Dist.)
Ohio Rev. Code § 1321.32 invalidates wage assignments other than those for court-ordered support of an employee's spouse or minor child, does not affect agreed checkoffs on wages between employers and employees, and it preserves deductions under a payroll deduction plan agreed between employer and employee only if the employee can revoke the plan at any time, on notice to the employer, up to the time of payment.
Notwithstanding section 1321.31 of the Revised Code, no assignment of, or order for wages or salary is valid unless the wages assigned or ordered are to be paid for the support of the employee's spouse or minor child in complying with an order of a court of record for the support of the employee's spouse or minor child. This section does not affect or invalidate any contract or agreement between employers and their employees, or as between employers, employees, and any labor union as to any checkoff on the wages of such employees as may be agreed upon. This section and section 4113.16 of the Revised Code shall not affect or invalidate any deduction from the wages or salary made in accordance with a payroll deduction plan agreed upon between the employer and employee provided that the same be revocable at any time by the employee upon notice to the employer up to the time of payment thereof.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 1321.32
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.16 bars an employer from contracting out of the wage-payment statute and makes assignments of future wages invalid except as provided in § 1321.32.
No employer subject to section 4113.15 of the Revised Code shall, by a special contract with an employee or by other means, exempt the employer from this section and section 4113.15 of the Revised Code, and no assignments of future wages, payable semimonthly under such sections are valid except as provided in section 1321.32 of the Revised Code.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.16
Ohio Rev. Code § 4111.02 requires every employer, as defined in Article II, section 34a of the Ohio Constitution, to pay each employee at least the constitutional minimum wage rate.
Every employer, as defined in Section 34a of Article II, Ohio Constitution, shall pay each of the employer's employees at a wage rate of not less than the wage rate specified in Section 34a of Article II, Ohio Constitution.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4111.02
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 treats employer-required tool costs as a violation in any workweek when they cut into the required minimum or overtime wages.
For example, if it is a requirement of the employer that the employee must provide tools of the trade which will be used in or are specifically required for the performance of the employer's particular work, there would be a violation of the Act in any workweek when the cost of such tools purchased by the employee cuts into the minimum or overtime wages required to be paid him under the Act.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(D)(3) lists deductions for repayment of a loan or other obligation among employee authorized deductions.
(3) "Employee authorized deduction" includes but is not limited to deductions for the purpose of any of the following:(a) Purchase of United States savings bonds or corporate stocks or bonds ;(b) A charitable contribution ;(c) Credit union savings or other regular savings program ;(d) Repayment of a loan or other obligation.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(D)(3)
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(A) requires an employer doing business in Ohio to pay wages earned in the first half of a month by the first day of the next month, and wages earned in the second half by the fifteenth day of the next month.
(A) Every employer doing business in this state shall, on or before the first day of each month, pay all its employees the wages earned by them during the first half of the preceding month ending with the fifteenth day thereof, and shall, on or before the fifteenth day of each month, pay such employees the wages earned by them during the last half of the preceding calendar month.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(A)
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(A) does not prohibit daily or weekly payment of wages and refers to a longer time lapse customary to a trade, profession or occupation, or a different time lapse established by written contract or by operation of law.
This section does not prohibit the daily or weekly payment of wages. The use of a longer time lapse that is customary to a given trade, profession or occupation, or establishment of a different time lapse by written contract or by operation of law.
See Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.15(A)