Are repayment terms enforceable in North Dakota?
North Dakota voids a contract term that fixes damages for a breach in advance, except that the parties may agree on an amount presumed to be the damage when it would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix the actual damage . Penalties imposed by contract for nonperformance are also void . In our review we found no North Dakota statute that bans or limits stay-or-pay, training-repayment or sign-on bonus repayment terms in private employment, so the conservative inference is that a court would test a fixed repayment amount under these two sections.
The employer bears the burden. In City of Fargo v. Case Development Co., the North Dakota Supreme Court held that a party seeking to enforce a clause stipulating the damages recoverable upon breach must prove that the clause is valid as an exception to section 9-08-04, and listed three foundational questions: whether the damages were very difficult to estimate when the contract was made, whether the parties made a reasonable endeavor to fix compensation, and whether the amount bears a reasonable relationship to the damages reasonably to be anticipated. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
The court has applied that test to employees who left early. In Bowbells Public School District No. 14 v. Walker, it upheld a graduated amount a teacher owed for breaking her contract, reasoning that the law requires only that the clause's purpose be primarily to predetermine damages rather than to impose a penalty. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group. In Bottineau Public School District No. 1 v. Zimmer, it upheld a $500 replacement-cost charge against a teacher released from his contract, and held that a valid stipulation binds the parties regardless of the actual damages incurred. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
A repayment triggered by going to work for a competitor faces a separate and stricter limit. Section 9-08-06 voids a contract restraining anyone from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business, to that extent, outside the sale-of-goodwill and owner exceptions , and the North Dakota Supreme Court has read it to invalidate employment terms that impose a penalty on an employee who works for a competitor after employment . In our review we found no North Dakota appellate decision applying section 9-08-06 to a repayment triggered by leaving for any reason rather than by competing.
A flat repayment amount that the employer cannot tie to any estimate of the cost of the employee's early departure risks being held void .
Sources for this answer
N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-04 voids a contract term fixing damages for breach in advance, except an amount presumed to be the damage where actual damage would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix.
Every contract by which the amount of damages to be paid, or other compensation to be made, for a breach of an obligation is determined in anticipation thereof is to that extent void, except that the parties may agree therein upon an amount presumed to be the damage sustained by a breach in cases in which it would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix the actual damage.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-04
N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-03 voids penalties imposed by contract for nonperformance.
Penalties imposed by contract for any nonperformance thereof are void.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-03
In *City of Fargo v. Case Development Co.*, the North Dakota Supreme Court placed on the party enforcing a stipulated-damages clause the burden of proving it valid as an exception to section 9-08-04.
A party seeking to enforce a contract provision which stipulates the amount of damages recoverable upon breach bears the burden of proving that the clause is valid as an exception to the general prohibition of Section 9-08-04.
See City of Fargo v. Case Dev. Co., 401 N.W.2d 529 (N.D. 1987)
In *City of Fargo*, the court identified three foundational facts for a valid liquidated damages clause: difficulty of estimating damages, a reasonable endeavor to fix compensation, and a reasonable relationship to anticipated damages.
In a series of cases decided by this court, three “foundational facts” have emerged as critical to the inquiry whether a particular provision is a valid liquidated damages clause or a void penalty: 1) Were the damages upon breach very difficult to estimate at the time the contract was entered?; 2) Was there a reasonable endeavor by the parties to fix compensation?; and, 3) Does the amount stipulated bear a reasonable relationship to the damages reasonably to be anticipated upon breach?
See City of Fargo v. Case Dev. Co., 401 N.W.2d 529 (N.D. 1987)
In *Bowbells Public School District No. 14 v. Walker*, the teacher's liquidated damages provision was graduated, with progressively larger payments as the school term approached.
In this regard, it is to be noted that the liquidated-damages provision under consideration is graduated, i. e., it provides for progressively larger payments for breach of the contract as the time for commencing the school term approaches.
See Bowbells Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 14 v. Walker, 231 N.W.2d 173 (N.D. 1975)
In *Bowbells*, the North Dakota Supreme Court required only that a liquidated damages clause's purpose be primarily to predetermine damages rather than to penalize breach.
The law requires only that the purpose of the clause be primarily to predetermine damages, as opposed to imposing a penalty for breach.
See Bowbells Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 14 v. Walker, 231 N.W.2d 173 (N.D. 1975)
In *Bowbells*, the North Dakota Supreme Court held that the school district sustained its burden of proving the teacher's liquidated damages clause valid.
We hold that the school district has sustained its burden of proof.
See Bowbells Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 14 v. Walker, 231 N.W.2d 173 (N.D. 1975)
In *Bottineau Public School District No. 1 v. Zimmer*, the North Dakota Supreme Court held that a $500 charge assessed against a teacher under the board policy was not unreasonable.
We do not find the $500 assessed pursuant to the board policy in this case to be unreasonable, especially in light of Mr. Zimmer’s status as one of approximately 40 certified teachers in the field of distributive education in the State of North Dakota.
See Bottineau Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. Zimmer, 231 N.W.2d 178 (N.D. 1975)
In *Bottineau*, the court held that parties to a valid stipulation of damages are bound by it regardless of the actual damages incurred.
When parties make a valid stipulation of damages, they are bound by it, regardless of the amount of actual damages incurred.
See Bottineau Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. Zimmer, 231 N.W.2d 178 (N.D. 1975)
N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-06 voids, to that extent, a contract restraining anyone from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business, subject to the sale-of-goodwill and owner exceptions.
A contract by which anyone is restrained from exercising a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void, except: 1. A person that sells the goodwill of a business and the person's partners, members, or shareholders may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable length of time, if the buyer or any person deriving title to the goodwill from the buyer carries on a like business in that area. 2. Partners, members, or shareholders, upon or in anticipation of a dissolution of a partnership, limited liability company, or corporation; upon or in anticipation of a dissociation of a partner or member; or as part of an agreement addressing the dissociation or sale of a partner, member, or shareholder's ownership interest, may agree that all or any number of them will not carry on a similar business within a reasonable geographic area where the partnership, limited liability company, or corporation business has been transacted, or within a specified part of the area.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-06
In *Earthworks, Inc. v. Sehn*, the North Dakota Supreme Court read section 9-08-06 to invalidate employment terms barring work for a competitor after employment or imposing a penalty for doing so.
The statute represents one of the oldest and most continuous applications of public policy in contract law, and it invalidates provisions in employment contracts prohibiting an employee from working for a competitor after completion of his employment or imposing a penalty if he does so.
See Earthworks, Inc. v. Sehn, 553 N.W.2d 490 (N.D. 1996)
*City of Fargo* asks whether the stipulated amount bears a reasonable relationship to the damages reasonably to be anticipated.
The third foundational inquiry is whether the damages stipulated bear a reasonable relationship to the anticipated actual damages upon breach.
See City of Fargo v. Case Dev. Co., 401 N.W.2d 529 (N.D. 1987)
Can a North Dakota employer claw back pay already received?
The North Dakota Supreme Court has enforced an employment agreement that made an associate's shortfall in billed hours a debt owed at termination. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. In Larson Latham Huettl LLP v. Iversen, the employment agreement provided that any shortfall between billed and required hours would be a debt the associate owed at the end of the calendar year or at the termination of employment , and the North Dakota Supreme Court affirmed summary judgment for the firm, holding that the agreement was not substantively unconscionable. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
The parties may also agree on when compensation becomes due. In Johnson v. Peterbilt of Fargo, Inc., the court held that a contract denying a salesman commissions on units delivered after his employment ended, whether voluntarily or otherwise, was not against any stated public policy. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
An employer may not, however, condition money otherwise due on the employee's not competing . In Werlinger v. Mutual Service Casualty Insurance Co., the court held void under section 9-08-06 a clause forfeiting money an agent would otherwise be paid if he competed, explaining that the important feature was the restraint on competition imposed to avoid the forfeiture. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
In our review we found no North Dakota appellate decision on recovering a cash sign-on or retention bonus, so the conservative course is to assume a court will test a fixed repayment amount under section 9-08-04 . Collecting the repayment separately is also safer than withholding wages, because section 34-14-04.1 limits withholding, apart from legally required or court-ordered amounts, to advances other than undocumented cash and deductions authorized in writing or, for damage or shortage, at the time of the deduction .
Sources for this answer
In *Larson Latham Huettl LLP v. Iversen*, the employment agreement made a shortfall in billed hours a debt the associate owed at year end or at termination.
Any discrepancy where the actual hours billed is less than the base hours required will be considered to be a debt owed by Associate to LLH at the end of the calendar year or at the termination of employment.
See Larson Latham Huettl LLP v. Iversen, 2023 ND 16
In *Larson Latham Huettl*, the North Dakota Supreme Court held that the district court did not err in granting the firm summary judgment.
We conclude, however, the court did not err in granting LLH’s motion for summary judgment.
See Larson Latham Huettl LLP v. Iversen, 2023 ND 16
In *Larson Latham Huettl*, the court upheld the conclusion that the employment agreement was not substantively unconscionable.
We conclude the court did not err in concluding the employment agreement was not substantively unconscionable.
See Larson Latham Huettl LLP v. Iversen, 2023 ND 16
In *Johnson v. Peterbilt of Fargo, Inc.*, the salesman challenged a clause denying commissions on units delivered after his employment ended, whether he quit or not.
On appeal, Johnson argues that “[a] contractual provision which states that no commission will be paid to a salesman on sales where the item is delivered after the termination of the salesman’s employment whether such termination is voluntary or otherwise is void as a matter of public policy.”
See Johnson v. Peterbilt of Fargo, Inc., 438 N.W.2d 162 (N.D. 1989)
In *Johnson*, the North Dakota Supreme Court held the commission provision not against any stated public policy.
The contract provision at issue in this case is not against any stated public policy.
See Johnson v. Peterbilt of Fargo, Inc., 438 N.W.2d 162 (N.D. 1989)
In *Werlinger v. Mutual Service Casualty Insurance Co.*, the court treated as decisive the restraint on competition imposed to avoid forfeiting money the agent would otherwise be paid.
The important feature of the contracts involved in this case and in Geiss was not the basis upon which either company’s terminated agent was to be paid, but the restraint on competition that the companies imposed upon their agents to avoid the forfeiture of money they would otherwise be paid.
See Werlinger v. Mut. Serv. Cas. Ins. Co., 496 N.W.2d 26 (N.D. 1993)
In *Werlinger*, the North Dakota Supreme Court held the forfeiture-for-competition clause, Paragraph 12(D), an unlawful restraint of trade, void under section 9-08-06.
In light of the common-law history of noncompetition clauses in restraint of trade, Section 9-08-06, N.D.C.C., Olson v. Swendiman, supra; Spectrum Emergency Care, Inc. v. St. Joseph’s Hospital & Health Center, supra; and California decisions, such as Buskuhl v. Family Life Ins. Co., supra, construing the same Field Code provision as § 9-08-06, N.D.C.C., we conclude that Paragraph 12(D) of the parties’ contract constitutes an unlawful restraint of trade and is void under § 9-08-06, N.D.C.C.
See Werlinger v. Mut. Serv. Cas. Ins. Co., 496 N.W.2d 26 (N.D. 1993)
N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-04 voids an advance fixing of damages except where actual damage would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix.
Every contract by which the amount of damages to be paid, or other compensation to be made, for a breach of an obligation is determined in anticipation thereof is to that extent void, except that the parties may agree therein upon an amount presumed to be the damage sustained by a breach in cases in which it would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix the actual damage.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-04
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04.1 limits an employer's withholdings, apart from legally required or court-ordered amounts, to advances, written recurring deductions, written nonrecurring deductions citing their source and contemporaneously authorized damage or shortage deductions.
Except for those amounts that are required under state or federal law to be withheld from employee compensation or where a court has ordered the employer to withhold compensation, an employer only may withhold from the compensation due employees: 1. Advances paid to employees, other than undocumented cash. 2. A recurring deduction authorized in writing. 3. A nonrecurring deduction authorized in writing, when the source of the deduction is cited specifically. 4. A nonrecurring deduction for damage, breakage, shortage, or negligence must be authorized by the employee at the time of the deduction.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04.1
Can repayment come out of a North Dakota final paycheck?
A North Dakota employer may take a repayment out of wages, including final wages, only within the withholding categories of section 34-14-04.1, subject to its documentation and authorization requirements . Section 34-14-04.1 limits withholdings to advances other than undocumented cash, a recurring deduction authorized in writing, and a nonrecurring deduction authorized in writing when the source of the deduction is cited specifically; a nonrecurring deduction for damage, breakage, shortage or negligence must be authorized by the employee at the time of the deduction .
When an employee is discharged or quits, unpaid wages become due at the regular paydays established in advance for the periods worked . In a dispute over wages, the employer must give written notice of the amount, less whatever the employee owes the employer, that the employee concedes to be due, and pay that amount without condition .
A deduction that recovers a cost of the employer's own business, such as training the employer requires for its work, can also run into federal wage law. Under the federal rule, wage requirements are not met when the employee kicks back the wage, directly or indirectly, to the employer or for the employer's benefit, and an employer-required cost borne by the employee violates the Fair Labor Standards Act in any workweek in which it cuts into the minimum or overtime wages required. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Netting a one-time training or bonus repayment that is not an advance or another permitted withholding against the last paycheck, without a written authorization that cites the deduction specifically, risks a wage claim on which the employee may recover the unpaid wages with interest. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Sources for this answer
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04.1 limits an employer's withholdings, apart from legally required or court-ordered amounts, to advances, written recurring deductions, written nonrecurring deductions citing their source and contemporaneously authorized damage or shortage deductions.
Except for those amounts that are required under state or federal law to be withheld from employee compensation or where a court has ordered the employer to withhold compensation, an employer only may withhold from the compensation due employees: 1. Advances paid to employees, other than undocumented cash. 2. A recurring deduction authorized in writing. 3. A nonrecurring deduction authorized in writing, when the source of the deduction is cited specifically. 4. A nonrecurring deduction for damage, breakage, shortage, or negligence must be authorized by the employee at the time of the deduction.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04.1
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-03 makes a separated employee's unpaid wages due at the regular paydays established in advance for the periods worked.
Whenever an employee is discharged or terminated from employment by an employer, separates from employment voluntarily, or is suspended from work as the result of an industrial dispute, the employee's unpaid wages or compensation becomes due and payable at the regular paydays established in advance by the employer for the periods worked by the employee.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-03
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04 requires an employer, in a wage dispute, to give written notice of and pay without condition the amount the employee concedes to be due, less what the employee owes the employer.
In case of a dispute over wages, the employer shall give written notice to the employee of the amount of wages less whatever the employee owes the employer which the employee concedes to be due and shall pay such amount without condition within the time set by this chapter, provided that acceptance by the employee of any payment made hereunder does not constitute a release as to the balance of the claim.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 provides that Fair Labor Standards Act wage requirements are not met where the employee kicks back wages to the employer or for the employer's benefit.
The wage requirements of the Act will not be met where the employee “kicks-back” directly or indirectly to the employer or to another person for the employer's benefit the whole or part of the wage delivered to the employee.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 treats an employer-required cost borne by the employee as violating the Fair Labor Standards Act in any workweek in which it cuts into required minimum or overtime wages.
For example, if it is a requirement of the employer that the employee must provide tools of the trade which will be used in or are specifically required for the performance of the employer's particular work, there would be a violation of the Act in any workweek when the cost of such tools purchased by the employee cuts into the minimum or overtime wages required to be paid him under the Act.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04.1(3) permits a nonrecurring deduction only if authorized in writing and the source of the deduction is cited specifically.
3. A nonrecurring deduction authorized in writing, when the source of the deduction is cited specifically.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04.1(3)
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-09.1(1) entitles an employee, in addition to unpaid wages, to interest from the date the wages are due.
In addition to the employee's right to recover unpaid wages as provided in this chapter, every employee is entitled to recover from the employee's employer: 1. Interest on the unpaid wages from the date the wages are due until payment is made in full at the rate as established by section 47-14-09; and 2. An amount equal to: a. Double the employee's unpaid wages, if, within one year preceding the date such wages are due, the employer has, on separate occasions, been subject to, and found liable for, two previous wage claims under the provisions of this chapter; or b. Treble the employee's unpaid wages, if, within one year preceding the date such wages are due, the employer has, on separate occasions, been subject to, and found liable for, three or more previous wage claims under the provisions of this chapter.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-09.1
Are North Dakota training or tuition repayment terms treated differently?
No North Dakota statute or appellate decision located for this guide treats training, tuition or relocation repayment in private employment differently from other repayment terms. The conservative inference is that the same section 9-08-04 test applies, under which an agreed amount is void unless actual damage would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix . The employer enforcing the amount bears the burden of proving the clause valid , including that the amount bears a reasonable relationship to the damages reasonably to be anticipated .
A separate statute matters when the training is required for the job. Section 34-02-01 requires an employer, except as section 34-02-02 provides, to indemnify an employee for all that the employee necessarily expends or loses in direct consequence of discharging the employee's duties or obeying the employer's directions . The duty does not cover losses from the ordinary risks of the business , or tools or equipment the employee also uses outside the scope of employment . In our review we found no North Dakota decision applying section 34-02-01 to a training-repayment term, so the conservative inference is that a repayment recovering the cost of training the employer directed the employee to take for the employee's current duties carries more risk than one recovering the cost of optional education.
Two features of the teacher cases offer a drafting model. The Bowbells clause scaled the payment to the timing of the breach , and the court did not treat use of a standard clause in many contracts as incompatible with a reasonable endeavor to estimate damages .
A training repayment that becomes due only if the employee goes to work for a competitor, rather than on any early departure, risks being void under section 9-08-06, which the North Dakota Supreme Court has read to invalidate employment terms imposing a penalty on an employee who works for a competitor after employment , and which voided a clause that made an agent purchase the freedom to compete by forfeiting money otherwise due. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group.
Sources for this answer
N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-04 permits an agreed damages amount only where actual damage would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix.
Every contract by which the amount of damages to be paid, or other compensation to be made, for a breach of an obligation is determined in anticipation thereof is to that extent void, except that the parties may agree therein upon an amount presumed to be the damage sustained by a breach in cases in which it would be impracticable or extremely difficult to fix the actual damage.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 9-08-04
*City of Fargo* places the burden of proving a stipulated-damages clause valid on the party enforcing it.
A party seeking to enforce a contract provision which stipulates the amount of damages recoverable upon breach bears the burden of proving that the clause is valid as an exception to the general prohibition of Section 9-08-04.
See City of Fargo v. Case Dev. Co., 401 N.W.2d 529 (N.D. 1987)
In *City of Fargo*, the court identified three foundational facts for a valid liquidated damages clause: difficulty of estimating damages, a reasonable endeavor to fix compensation, and a reasonable relationship to anticipated damages.
In a series of cases decided by this court, three “foundational facts” have emerged as critical to the inquiry whether a particular provision is a valid liquidated damages clause or a void penalty: 1) Were the damages upon breach very difficult to estimate at the time the contract was entered?; 2) Was there a reasonable endeavor by the parties to fix compensation?; and, 3) Does the amount stipulated bear a reasonable relationship to the damages reasonably to be anticipated upon breach?
See City of Fargo v. Case Dev. Co., 401 N.W.2d 529 (N.D. 1987)
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-02-01 requires an employer, except as section 34-02-02 provides, to indemnify an employee for what the employee necessarily expends or loses in direct consequence of discharging the employee's duties or obeying the employer's directions.
An employer shall indemnify the employer's employee, except as prescribed in section 34-02-02, for all that the employee necessarily expends or loses in direct consequence of the discharge of the employee's duties as such or of the employee's obedience to the directions of the employer even though such directions were unlawful, unless the employee at the time of obeying such directions believed them to be unlawful.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-02-01
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-02-02 relieves an employer of the duty to indemnify losses from the ordinary risks of the business, among other exceptions.
Except as otherwise provided by law, an employer is not bound to indemnify the employer's employee for losses suffered by the latter in consequence of the ordinary risks of the business in which the employee is employed, nor in consequence of the negligence of another person employed by the same employer in the same general business, unless the employer has neglected to use ordinary care in the selection of the culpable employee.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-02-02
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-02-01 excludes from the indemnity duty tools of a trade and other equipment the employee also uses outside the scope of employment.
The obligation to indemnify does not include expenses incurred to purchase or rent tools of a trade or any other equipment that is also used by the employee outside the scope of employment.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-02-01
The *Bowbells* clause provided progressively larger payments as the school term approached.
In this regard, it is to be noted that the liquidated-damages provision under consideration is graduated, i. e., it provides for progressively larger payments for breach of the contract as the time for commencing the school term approaches.
See Bowbells Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 14 v. Walker, 231 N.W.2d 173 (N.D. 1975)
In *Bowbells*, the court held that using a standard liquidated damages clause in more than one contract is not necessarily incompatible with a reasonable endeavor to estimate damages.
We do not find that the inclusion of a standard liquidated-damages clause in more than one contract is necessarily incompatible with a reasonable endeavor to pre-determine compensatory damages.
See Bowbells Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 14 v. Walker, 231 N.W.2d 173 (N.D. 1975)
In *Earthworks, Inc. v. Sehn*, the North Dakota Supreme Court read section 9-08-06 to invalidate employment terms barring work for a competitor after employment or imposing a penalty for doing so.
The statute represents one of the oldest and most continuous applications of public policy in contract law, and it invalidates provisions in employment contracts prohibiting an employee from working for a competitor after completion of his employment or imposing a penalty if he does so.
See Earthworks, Inc. v. Sehn, 553 N.W.2d 490 (N.D. 1996)
In *Werlinger*, the North Dakota Supreme Court held the forfeiture-for-competition clause, Paragraph 12(D), an unlawful restraint of trade, void under section 9-08-06.
In light of the common-law history of noncompetition clauses in restraint of trade, Section 9-08-06, N.D.C.C., Olson v. Swendiman, supra; Spectrum Emergency Care, Inc. v. St. Joseph’s Hospital & Health Center, supra; and California decisions, such as Buskuhl v. Family Life Ins. Co., supra, construing the same Field Code provision as § 9-08-06, N.D.C.C., we conclude that Paragraph 12(D) of the parties’ contract constitutes an unlawful restraint of trade and is void under § 9-08-06, N.D.C.C.
See Werlinger v. Mut. Serv. Cas. Ins. Co., 496 N.W.2d 26 (N.D. 1993)
In *Werlinger v. Mutual Service Casualty Insurance Co.*, the court treated as decisive the restraint on competition imposed to avoid forfeiting money the agent would otherwise be paid.
The important feature of the contracts involved in this case and in Geiss was not the basis upon which either company’s terminated agent was to be paid, but the restraint on competition that the companies imposed upon their agents to avoid the forfeiture of money they would otherwise be paid.
See Werlinger v. Mut. Serv. Cas. Ins. Co., 496 N.W.2d 26 (N.D. 1993)
*Werlinger* quoted with approval the rule that requiring a professional to pay $2,000 to practice in a city is not freedom to practice there.
Surely this was not freedom to practice his profession in Grand Forks, since he would have to purchase the freedom with $2,000, and there is no merit to this contention.
See Werlinger v. Mut. Serv. Cas. Ins. Co., 496 N.W.2d 26 (N.D. 1993)
What happens to a North Dakota employer that over-collects a repayment from pay?
A North Dakota employee may file a claim with the Department of Labor and Human Rights for wages due under chapter 34-14 within two years from the date the wages are due, if the amount claimed is at least $125 and no more than $15,000 . The labor commissioner must ensure compliance with the chapter and may hold hearings on the merits of a claim , and may consider any offset, deduction or counterclaim the employer asserts, which the employer must disclose .
On recovery, the employee is entitled to interest on the unpaid wages, and to double or treble the unpaid wages if, within the year preceding the date the unpaid wages were due, the employer was found liable on two, or three or more, previous wage claims . When an employer that discharged the employee fails to pay wages on time, the employee may collect the agreed daily wage for each day of default, for up to thirty days . An employer that willfully refuses to pay wages due when demanded is guilty of an infraction .
Sources for this answer
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-09(1) allows an employee to file a wage claim with the department within two years, for at least $125 and no more than $15,000.
1. An employee may file with the department a claim for wages due under this chapter or under chapter 34-06 if the filing is made within two years from the date the wages are due and the amount of the wages claimed due is at least one hundred twenty-five dollars but not more than fifteen thousand dollars.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-09(1)
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-05(1)–(2) directs the labor commissioner to ensure compliance with chapter 34-14 and permits hearings on the merits of claims.
1. The labor commissioner or the commissioner's deputy shall ensure compliance with this chapter, investigate alleged violations of this chapter, and institute or cause to be instituted actions for penalties and forfeitures related to violation of this chapter. 2. The commissioner or the commissioner's deputy may hold hearings on the merits of any claim and shall cooperate with any employee in the enforcement of a claim against the employee's employer in any case if, in the commissioner's opinion, the claim is valid.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-05(1)–(2)
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-05(4) lets the commissioner consider an employer's offsets, deductions or counterclaims and requires the employer to disclose them.
4. The commissioner may consider any offsets, deductions, or counterclaims asserted by an employer during the commissioner's investigation and determination of the validity, enforceability, and amount of any claim for wages. An employer shall disclose the basis for and the amount of any claimed offset, deduction, or counterclaim to the commissioner within the time the commissioner directs.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-05(4)
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-09.1 entitles an employee to interest on unpaid wages and to double or treble wages where the employer was found liable on prior wage claims within a year.
In addition to the employee's right to recover unpaid wages as provided in this chapter, every employee is entitled to recover from the employee's employer: 1. Interest on the unpaid wages from the date the wages are due until payment is made in full at the rate as established by section 47-14-09; and 2. An amount equal to: a. Double the employee's unpaid wages, if, within one year preceding the date such wages are due, the employer has, on separate occasions, been subject to, and found liable for, two previous wage claims under the provisions of this chapter; or b. Treble the employee's unpaid wages, if, within one year preceding the date such wages are due, the employer has, on separate occasions, been subject to, and found liable for, three or more previous wage claims under the provisions of this chapter.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-09.1
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-03 lets a discharged employee whose wages are not timely paid collect the agreed daily wage for each day of default, for up to thirty days.
If the employer fails to pay the wages within the stated time, the employee may charge and collect wages in the sum agreed upon in the contract of employment for each day the employer is in default until the employer has paid in full, without rendering any service therefor, except the employee shall cease to draw wages or salary thirty days after such default.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-03
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-07 makes an employer that willfully refuses to pay wages due when demanded guilty of an infraction.
Any employer who willfully refuses to pay the wages due and payable when demanded as in this chapter, or who falsely denies the amount thereof, or that the same is due with intent to secure for the employer or any other person any discount upon such indebtedness, or with intent to annoy, harass, or oppress, or hinder, or delay, or defraud the person to whom such indebtedness is due, is guilty of an infraction.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-07
What repayment structure is safest under North Dakota law?
The safest North Dakota repayment term sets an amount the employer can show was a reasonable estimate of damages that were very difficult to estimate when the contract was made, because the employer bears the burden of proving the clause valid under those foundational facts. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. Limiting the repayment to optional education or training, rather than training the employer directs the employee to take for current duties, reduces the risk that the cost is one section 34-02-01 requires the employer to bear . A schedule that scales the amount to the timing of the departure follows the graduated clause upheld in Bowbells. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
A repayment triggered by going to work for a competitor risks being void, because section 9-08-06 invalidates employment terms that impose a penalty on an employee who competes after employment . As an inference from that rule, a trigger tied to the employee's own early resignation, regardless of where the employee works next, is less exposed to section 9-08-06, though it still has to satisfy section 9-08-04.
Collecting the balance by separate demand is safer than withholding pay, because, apart from advances and legally required or court-ordered withholding, section 34-14-04.1 permits a one-time deduction under a written authorization that cites the source of the deduction specifically , and a deduction that recovers a cost of the employer's own business should not cut into required minimum or overtime wages. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Sources for this answer
In *City of Fargo v. Case Development Co.*, the North Dakota Supreme Court placed on the party enforcing a stipulated-damages clause the burden of proving it valid as an exception to section 9-08-04.
A party seeking to enforce a contract provision which stipulates the amount of damages recoverable upon breach bears the burden of proving that the clause is valid as an exception to the general prohibition of Section 9-08-04.
See City of Fargo v. Case Dev. Co., 401 N.W.2d 529 (N.D. 1987)
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-02-01 requires an employer to indemnify an employee for what the employee necessarily expends in direct consequence of discharging duties or obeying the employer's directions.
An employer shall indemnify the employer's employee, except as prescribed in section 34-02-02, for all that the employee necessarily expends or loses in direct consequence of the discharge of the employee's duties as such or of the employee's obedience to the directions of the employer even though such directions were unlawful, unless the employee at the time of obeying such directions believed them to be unlawful.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-02-01
*City of Fargo* identifies three foundational facts for a valid liquidated damages clause.
In a series of cases decided by this court, three “foundational facts” have emerged as critical to the inquiry whether a particular provision is a valid liquidated damages clause or a void penalty: 1) Were the damages upon breach very difficult to estimate at the time the contract was entered?; 2) Was there a reasonable endeavor by the parties to fix compensation?; and, 3) Does the amount stipulated bear a reasonable relationship to the damages reasonably to be anticipated upon breach?
See City of Fargo v. Case Dev. Co., 401 N.W.2d 529 (N.D. 1987)
The clause upheld in *Bowbells* was graduated to the timing of the breach.
In this regard, it is to be noted that the liquidated-damages provision under consideration is graduated, i. e., it provides for progressively larger payments for breach of the contract as the time for commencing the school term approaches.
See Bowbells Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 14 v. Walker, 231 N.W.2d 173 (N.D. 1975)
In *Bowbells*, the North Dakota Supreme Court held that the school district sustained its burden of proving the teacher's liquidated damages clause valid.
We hold that the school district has sustained its burden of proof.
See Bowbells Pub. Sch. Dist. No. 14 v. Walker, 231 N.W.2d 173 (N.D. 1975)
*Earthworks* reads section 9-08-06 to invalidate employment terms penalizing an employee for working for a competitor after employment.
The statute represents one of the oldest and most continuous applications of public policy in contract law, and it invalidates provisions in employment contracts prohibiting an employee from working for a competitor after completion of his employment or imposing a penalty if he does so.
See Earthworks, Inc. v. Sehn, 553 N.W.2d 490 (N.D. 1996)
N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04.1 limits withholdings, apart from legally required or court-ordered amounts, to advances and listed written or contemporaneous authorizations, including a written nonrecurring deduction citing its source.
Except for those amounts that are required under state or federal law to be withheld from employee compensation or where a court has ordered the employer to withhold compensation, an employer only may withhold from the compensation due employees: 1. Advances paid to employees, other than undocumented cash. 2. A recurring deduction authorized in writing. 3. A nonrecurring deduction authorized in writing, when the source of the deduction is cited specifically. 4. A nonrecurring deduction for damage, breakage, shortage, or negligence must be authorized by the employee at the time of the deduction.
See N.D. Cent. Code § 34-14-04.1
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 treats a kickback of wages to the employer as failing Fair Labor Standards Act wage requirements.
The wage requirements of the Act will not be met where the employee “kicks-back” directly or indirectly to the employer or to another person for the employer's benefit the whole or part of the wage delivered to the employee.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35
29 C.F.R. § 531.35 treats an employer-required cost borne by the employee as violating the Fair Labor Standards Act in any workweek in which it cuts into required minimum or overtime wages.
For example, if it is a requirement of the employer that the employee must provide tools of the trade which will be used in or are specifically required for the performance of the employer's particular work, there would be a violation of the Act in any workweek when the cost of such tools purchased by the employee cuts into the minimum or overtime wages required to be paid him under the Act.
See 29 C.F.R. § 531.35