On this pageWhich assets does the buyer acquire, and which liabilities stay with the seller?
Asset Purchase Practice Guide

Small-Business Asset Purchase Agreements: What Transfers

Which assets the buyer acquires and which liabilities stay with the seller, how specific the schedules should be, liens, ownership of code and content, work still owned by contributors, customer data, security representations and contractor licenses held by the selling owner.

Authorities relied on18Primary sources7Market benchmarks7Secondary sources
About this guide
Editor
  • Lawyer
  • Harvard Law '18 (J.D.)
  • MIT '13 (S.B.)
  • Former Ropes & Gray (6 yrs)
  • Admitted in NY
License
CC BY 4.0

Which assets does the buyer acquire, and which liabilities stay with the seller?

Commentary recommends that an asset purchase agreement make very clear which assets are included and which are excluded, and the agreement assigns responsibility between the parties for the seller's obligations, which one filed agreement does by listing the liabilities the buyer assumes and leaving every other liability with the seller. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group.

The four defined categories below take their definitions from one filed asset purchase agreement for a supplement business, as examples of negotiated drafting rather than required wording:

CategoryDefinition
Purchased assetsThe assets the buyer acquires. The filed agreement defines its acquired assets as all of the seller's assets other than the excluded assets.
Excluded assetsThe assets the seller keeps. The filed agreement excludes the assets listed on a schedule and states that the excluded assets include the seller's cash.
Assumed liabilitiesThe seller's liabilities that the buyer agrees to take on. The filed agreement limits them to the liabilities listed on a schedule.
Retained liabilitiesEvery other liability of the seller. The filed agreement leaves them with the seller whether they arise before, on or after closing and whether or not they were disclosed.

An assumed obligation can be identified by its contract type and the period it covers: one filed agreement for an online publishing business made the buyer responsible for fulfilling job listings and subscriptions sold before closing, listed those obligations on a schedule, and included refunds to subscribers who cancel.

The following synthetic example illustrates choices for the purchase of a small software-as-a-service business, not observed terms or a mandatory allocation:

ItemDecision the parties need to express
Cash and receivablesWhether the seller keeps bank balances, pre-closing receivables and payouts still pending with the payment processor, or the buyer acquires specified amounts.
Code and repositoriesWhich repositories and deployment configurations transfer, and whether any code belongs to a contractor or is licensed from a third party (contractor-owned code, website or app migration).
DomainsWhich domain names transfer and from which registrar account (domain transfer).
App-store registrationsWhich app listings transfer and whether the buyer's developer account can receive them (app transfer).
Hosting, SaaS and provider accountsWhich accounts transfer whole, which are shared with the seller's other businesses and need separating, and which the buyer replaces (account migration, shared accounts, handover check).
Prepaid subscriptions and refundsWhether the buyer serves annual plans paid before closing and who bears refunds and chargebacks (customer obligations).
Customer data and recordsWhich customer records transfer, subject to privacy-policy and data-use restrictions (customer data).
Supplier and customer contractsWhich agreements are included and which need a counterparty's consent to assignment (contract consents).

A general grant of the seller's assets can miss an asset the business uses but the seller does not hold, such as intellectual property held by an owner or an affiliate; one filed agreement addresses that gap with a representation that no affiliate of the seller has an interest in intellectual property used in or necessary for the business, other than as scheduled. The schedules question addresses how specific each list needs to be, lien review addresses encumbered assets, and contract consents addresses assets that cannot move without a third party.

For an app or other online software business, Selling an App Business and Buying an App Business follow these assets through a marketplace sale, escrow and the transfer of each account.

A contractual allocation between buyer and seller does not by itself answer what rights a third party has, because the seller's creditors are not parties to the asset purchase agreement and, outside sales governed by bankruptcy-court orders and other judicial sales, are not bound by it. Third-party exposure is a separate review; this guide does not determine successor liability in any particular state, industry or transaction, and the successor-liability question describes the general rule and its recognized exceptions.

Sources for this answer
Secondary source · Law-firm commentary · 2022-07-25A.1
Imke Ratschko: The Basics of an Asset Purchase Agreement (Ratschko PLLC)

Imke Ratschko supports clearly describing which assets are included and which are excluded.

So I recommend that the description makes it very clear which assets are included, and which are excluded.

See Imke Ratschko, The Basics of an Asset Purchase Agreement, Ratschko PLLC (July 25, 2022; updated July 28, 2022).

Secondary source · Law-firm commentary · 2020-06-26A.2
Samuel D. Hodson: Successor Liability Risks in Asset Purchase Agreements (Taft)

Samuel D. Hodson supports that an APA assigns responsibility between the parties for the seller’s obligations.

The asset purchase agreement assigns responsibility between the parties for the seller’s obligations.

See Samuel D. Hodson, Successor Liability Risks in Asset Purchase Agreements, Taft Law Bulletins (June 26, 2020).

Internet resource · 2021-08-01A.5
Grove–VitaMedica asset purchase agreement (2021), excluded assets

The Grove agreement excluded the assets listed on its Schedule 2.1(b) and stated that the excluded assets include the seller's cash.

Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, the Acquired Assets shall not include the assets, properties and rights of Seller set forth on Schedule 2.1(b) hereto (collectively, the “Excluded Assets”). The term Excluded Assets includes without limitation cash of Seller.

See §2.1(b)

Internet resource · 2021-08-01A.6
Grove–VitaMedica asset purchase agreement (2021), assumed liabilities

The Grove agreement limited its assumed liabilities to the seller liabilities listed on Schedule 2.2(a).

“Assumed Liabilities” means only those Liabilities of Seller set forth on Schedule 2.2(a), which includes a list of the assumed accounts payable of Seller.

See §2.2(a)

Internet resource · 2021-08-01A.3
Grove–VitaMedica asset purchase agreement (2021), retained liabilities

The Grove agreement left every seller liability other than the assumed liabilities with the seller, whenever it arose and whether or not it was disclosed.

With the sole exception of the Assumed Liabilities, the Seller shall retain, and the Buyer shall not be obligated to pay, perform or otherwise discharge, any other Liabilities of Seller, whether arising prior to, on or after the Closing Date, whether or not related to the Business and whether or not disclosed to the Buyer (“Retained Liabilities”).

See §2.2(b)(i)

Internet resource · 2023-09-29A.7
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), fulfillment liability

The Salem agreement made the buyer responsible for fulfilling job listings and subscriptions sold before closing, listed on Schedule 1.3(a), including refunds to subscribers who cancel.

The Assumed Liabilities include the liability to fulfill contracts for all job listings and subscriptions to products and services on the Websites sold by Seller prior to the Closing Date, all of which liabilities are set forth on Schedule 1.3(a) (such liabilities, the “Fulfillment Liability”), including the liability to pay refunds to any subscribers who cancel (for whatever reason) their subscriptions to any of the Website’s products and services sold by Seller.

See §1.3(a)

Internet resource · 2018-10-15A.8
Luna–Micron asset purchase agreement (2018), affiliate intellectual property

The Luna agreement included a representation that no seller affiliate, other than as scheduled, has an interest in intellectual property used in or necessary for the business.

No Seller Affiliate (other than as identified on Schedule 3.25(a)) owns, directly or indirectly, or has any interest (including but not limited to license-based interests) in any Intellectual Property Asset or other Intellectual Property that relates to, is used or held for use in, or is necessary for the Business.

See §3.25

Secondary source · Law-firm commentary · 2020-06-26A.9
Samuel D. Hodson: creditors are not bound by the asset purchase agreement (Taft)

Samuel D. Hodson states that a seller’s creditors are not parties to, or bound by, the asset purchase agreement, noting that bankruptcy-court-ordered and other judicial sales may be an exception.

A seller’s creditors are not parties to the asset purchase agreement and are not bound by it. (Sales governed by bankruptcy court orders pursuant to 11 U.S.C. 363 and other judicial sales may be an exception to this rule.)

See Samuel D. Hodson, Successor Liability Risks in Asset Purchase Agreements, Taft Law Bulletins (June 26, 2020).

Which schedules do we need, and how specific should they be?

Commentary recommends making very clear which assets are included and which are excluded, and schedules can do that work, as in one filed agreement whose acquired assets include those set forth on a schedule and whose assumed liabilities are only those listed on another schedule. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group. Another filed agreement lists every intellectual-property agreement by date, title and parties.

Beyond the perimeter, schedules record the facts of the particular transaction: one filed agreement qualifies the seller's representation that no notice or consent is needed for the sale by the consents listed on a schedule. An online publishing agreement lists on a schedule the permitted liens other than those to be released at or before closing, and lists on another schedule the subscriptions and job listings sold before closing that the buyer must fulfill. Handover steps can be scheduled too: one agreement requires the seller to give the buyer administrative-level access to the software and application items listed on a schedule, and an internet-services agreement set out its transition terms in a schedule, starting with a list of the user names and passwords to servers and software.

Essential assets are identified item by item: for an online business, the identifiers start with the websites, domain names and social-media accounts, which one filed agreement lists on a schedule together with the website content and software code it transfers. Accounts can be listed by institution and account number, as one agreement does for every bank account and the persons authorized to draw on it, and software can be listed product by product, while app identifiers and code repositories are covered in the app transfer and website migration questions. Replaceable items can be described by category: the same online publishing agreement transfers its office equipment, computers and inventory as a category that includes, but is not limited to, the items on a schedule.

Disclosure schedules have a separate job, and Tyler Conway and Tracy Belton identify two kinds of schedule information, lists and exceptions. Exception schedules record the seller's exceptions to its representations, such as a known dispute, an unassigned contractor contribution or a lien that will be paid at closing, and an exception properly scheduled is not a breach of the representation it qualifies. One filed agreement ties each exception to the representation it qualifies: its intellectual-property representations are each made except as set forth in a numbered part of its schedule.

The Online Business Asset Purchase Agreement puts the purchased assets, excluded assets and assumed liabilities on Schedules A to C and identifies each disclosure exception on Schedule F by the representation or obligation it qualifies.

Sources for this answer
Internet resource · 2018-10-15B.4
Luna–Micron asset purchase agreement (2018)

The Luna agreement supports identifying IP agreements by date, title and parties in its disclosure schedule.

Schedule 3.25(b) contains a correct, current and complete list of all Intellectual Property Agreements, specifying for each the date, title and parties thereto.

See §3.25(b)

Secondary source · Law-firm commentary · 2022-07-25B.1
Imke Ratschko: The Basics of an Asset Purchase Agreement (Ratschko PLLC)

Imke Ratschko supports clearly describing which assets are included and which are excluded.

So I recommend that the description makes it very clear which assets are included, and which are excluded.

See Imke Ratschko, The Basics of an Asset Purchase Agreement, Ratschko PLLC (July 25, 2022; updated July 28, 2022).

Internet resource · 2023-09-29B.6
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), permitted liens schedule

The Salem agreement lists on Schedule 5.4 the permitted liens other than those to be released at or before closing.

To Seller’s knowledge, all Permitted Liens other than those that will be released at or before Closing are set forth on Schedule 5.4.

See §5.4

Internet resource · 2023-09-29B.7
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), fulfillment liability schedule

The Salem agreement lists on Schedule 1.3(a) the job listings and subscriptions sold before closing that the buyer must fulfill.

The Assumed Liabilities include the liability to fulfill contracts for all job listings and subscriptions to products and services on the Websites sold by Seller prior to the Closing Date, all of which liabilities are set forth on Schedule 1.3(a) (such liabilities, the “Fulfillment Liability”), including the liability to pay refunds to any subscribers who cancel (for whatever reason) their subscriptions to any of the Website’s products and services sold by Seller.

See §1.3(a)

Internet resource · 2024-08-30B.8
Innovative Gourmet–iGourmet asset purchase agreement (2024), administrative access

The iGourmet agreement required the seller to give the buyer administrative-level access to the software and application items listed in its disclosure schedules.

Promptly following the execution of this Agreement, Seller shall provide Buyer with administrative level access to the software/application items listed on Section 5.01 of the Disclosure Schedules.

See §5.01

Internet resource · 2007-02-28B.9
OW Holdings–Sitestar asset purchase agreement (2007), transition schedule

The Sitestar agreement set its transition terms in Schedule 2.4, beginning with the seller's list of user names and passwords to servers and software.

The Parties agree to the following transition related terms at Closing; 1. Seller agrees to provide Buyer with a list of all necessary user names and passwords to servers and software on or immediately after the Transfer Date.

See Schedule 2.4

Internet resource · 2023-09-29B.10
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), websites, domains and software

The Salem agreement transfers the websites, internet domains and social-media accounts listed on Schedule 1.1(d), together with the website content and software code.

(d) Internet Domains, Social Media Accounts. All websites, Internet domains, social media accounts, and their related Uniform Resource Locators (“URLs”) used in the operation of the Business (“Websites”, “Domain Names” and “Social Media Accounts”, respectively) listed on Schedule 1.1(d); (e) Content and Software. All content on the Websites (including all rights and interests of Seller to content created by third parties which is not owned by Seller), including e-mail addresses of registered users, technology, and any master media files in Seller’s possession, as well as all functionality of the Websites, including content management systems, and software codes and enhancements, other than the Shared Code (defined in Section 8.9);

See §1.1(d)–(e)

Internet resource · 2016-05-05B.11
Bankrate asset purchase agreement (2016), bank accounts schedule

The Bankrate agreement's Schedule 4.23 lists each of the seller's bank accounts by institution and number, with the persons authorized to draw on them.

Schedule 4.23 is a complete and correct list of each bank or financial institution in which Seller has an account, safe deposit box or lockbox, or maintains a banking, custodial, trading or similar relationship, the number of each such account or box, and the names of all persons authorized to draw thereon or to having signatory power or access thereto.

See §4.23

Internet resource · 2016-05-05B.12
Bankrate asset purchase agreement (2016), proprietary products schedule

The Bankrate agreement's Schedule 4.10(c) lists each proprietary product or service of the seller, including its proprietary software.

Schedule 4.10(c) sets forth a true, correct and complete list of each proprietary product or service developed, licensed, manufactured, marketed or sold by Seller, including the Seller Proprietary Software.

See §4.10(c)

Internet resource · 2023-09-29B.13
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), tangible personal property

The Salem agreement transfers its office equipment, computers, inventory and other tangible personal property as a category that includes, but is not limited to, the items on Schedule 3.6.

(a) Tangible Personal Property. All office equipment, computers, monitors, servers, modems, desk, chairs, software, parts, supplies, furniture, furnishings, tools, fixtures, leasehold improvements, inventory, and other tangible personal property used in the conduct of the Business including but not limited to the items set forth on Schedule 3.6 (collectively, “Tangible Personal Property”); (b) Licenses and Permits. All rights associated with the “Licenses” (as that term is defined in Section 3.17) necessary to operate the Business as it is currently operated except for the Excluded Licenses;

See §1.1(a)–(b)

Internet resource · 2018-10-15B.16
Luna–Micron asset purchase agreement (2018), intellectual-property exceptions

The Luna agreement made an intellectual-property representation except as set forth in Schedule 3.25(c).

Except as set forth in Schedule 3.25(c), none of the Intellectual Property Assets will be subject to any Encumbrance as a result of any written agreement or other facts or circumstances existing before the date hereof.

See §3.25(c)

What should the agreement say about who owns the code and content?

The agreement can include a representation that the seller owns the intellectual property being sold, as one filed asset purchase agreement did by representing sole and exclusive ownership of its intellectual-property assets, free and clear of encumbrances, while expressly not representing that those rights are enforceable.

The schedules show what the ownership representation covers and where the business depends on someone else's rights: the same agreement required a schedule listing all of its intellectual-property agreements, specifying each agreement's date, title and parties. It also represented that the seller had contracts with its current and former employees and with each contributing contractor under which the contractor acknowledged the seller's ownership, presently assigned any ownership interest and waived moral rights to the extent the law permits. A disclosure schedule can record exceptions to those representations, as the same agreement did by making one of its intellectual-property representations except as set forth in a numbered part of its schedule; where a contributor still owns U.S. copyright, the signed-writing rule is addressed under contributor-owned code.

Where the business depends on intellectual property the seller keeps, the agreement can grant an express post-closing use right: one filed asset purchase agreement kept code shared with the seller's other websites as an excluded asset that remained the seller's property after closing. It gave the buyer a royalty-free, perpetual, noncancellable worldwide license to use that shared code for the websites and the business.

Sources for this answer
Internet resource · 2018-10-15C.1
Luna–Micron asset purchase agreement (2018), IP ownership

The Luna agreement represented that the seller was the sole and exclusive legal and beneficial owner of its IP registrations and IP assets, free and clear of encumbrances, without representing their enforceability.

Seller is the sole and exclusive legal and beneficial owner of all right, title, and interest in and to the Intellectual Property Registrations and Intellectual Property Assets, free and clear of Encumbrances (it being understood and acknowledged that the foregoing representation and warranty does not constitute a representation and warranty of enforceability of any such Intellectual Property Registrations and Intellectual Property Assets).

See §3.25(c)

Internet resource · 2018-10-15C.2
Luna–Micron asset purchase agreement (2018)

The Luna agreement supports identifying IP agreements by date, title and parties in its disclosure schedule.

Schedule 3.25(b) contains a correct, current and complete list of all Intellectual Property Agreements, specifying for each the date, title and parties thereto.

See §3.25(b)

Internet resource · 2018-10-15C.3
Luna–Micron asset purchase agreement (2018), employee and contractor IP contracts

The Luna agreement represented that the seller had contracts with current and former employees and with contributing contractors under which each contractor acknowledged the seller's ownership, presently assigned any ownership interest and waived moral rights to the extent permitted by law.

Seller (and its predecessor-in-interest) have entered into Contracts with each current and former employee in the form attached to Schedule 3.25(c) and has entered into Contracts with each current and former independent contractor who is or was involved in or has contributed to the invention, creation, or development of any Intellectual Property during the course of engagement with or for the benefit of Seller whereby such independent contractor (i) acknowledges Seller’s exclusive ownership of all Intellectual Property Assets invented, created or developed by such independent contractor within the scope of his or her engagement with such Seller; (ii) grants to such Seller a present, irrevocable assignment of any ownership interest such independent contractor may have in or to such Intellectual Property; and (iii) irrevocably waives any right or interest, including any moral rights, regarding such Intellectual Property, to the extent permitted by applicable Legal Requirement.

See §3.25(c)

Internet resource · 2023-09-29C.5
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), shared code retained by seller

The Salem agreement treated code shared with the seller's other websites as an excluded asset that remained the seller's property after closing.

Seller and Buyer acknowledge that there has been shared use of certain assets, including certain shared code, design and functionality of the Websites, and the software code, design, and functionality of other of Seller’s websites (the “Shared Code”), which is an Excluded Asset and which ownership shall remain with Seller following the Closing Date.

See §8.9

Internet resource · 2023-09-29C.6
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), license to shared code

The Salem agreement gave the buyer a royalty-free, perpetual, noncancellable worldwide license to use the shared code for the websites and the business.

Buyer shall have the royalty-free, perpetual, noncancellable worldwide license to use the Shared Code with respect to the Websites and the Business.

See §8.9

Internet resource · 2018-10-15C.4
Luna–Micron asset purchase agreement (2018), scheduled IP exception

The Luna agreement represents that, except as set forth in Schedule 3.25(c), none of the intellectual-property assets will be subject to an encumbrance arising from pre-signing agreements or circumstances.

Except as set forth in Schedule 3.25(c), none of the Intellectual Property Assets will be subject to any Encumbrance as a result of any written agreement or other facts or circumstances existing before the date hereof.

See §3.25

Can the customer data move with the business?

Privacy promises made to customers can constrain a transfer of their data: in the Facebook–WhatsApp acquisition, the FTC stated that WhatsApp must continue to honor its promises to consumers regardless of the acquisition.

For a business covered by California's consumer privacy law, transferring a consumer's personal information as an asset in a merger, acquisition or other transaction in which the recipient assumes control of all or part of the business is not a sale, provided that the information is used or shared consistently with that law. If the recipient later materially alters how it uses or shares that information in a manner materially inconsistent with the promises made at collection, it must give consumers prior notice of the new or changed practice.

The seller's privacy policy is the starting point, as a 2015 letter about a proposed bankruptcy sale of customer data shows, in which FTC consumer-protection staff read RadioShack's privacy policies as clearly and expressly representing that customer information would not be rented or sold to third parties. The letter warned that a sale of that information would contravene RadioShack's express promise not to sell or rent it and could be a deceptive or unfair practice under Section 5 of the FTC Act. The same letter described the Toysmart settlement, which allowed a transfer only if the buyer agreed not to sell the customer information as a standalone asset, was in the same line of business, agreed to treat the information under Toysmart's privacy policy and agreed to seek affirmative consent before changing that policy for information gathered under it.

A data schedule can identify each dataset and the copies the seller keeps, as in one filed asset purchase agreement that transferred the originals, or true and complete copies, of the customer records, customer lists and databases set forth on a schedule, while letting the seller keep a copy for internal recordkeeping and other legal and accounting purposes. The same agreement required the seller to cooperate in moving purchased files and content from the seller's servers to servers the buyer selected as soon as reasonably practicable after closing. A buyer that does not want the seller to keep a copy can require deletion, as one filed agreement for an online survey panel did by requiring the seller to permanently delete overlapping panel members within five days of closing and to certify the deletion in writing.

The RadioShack letter was a staff letter about one bankruptcy sale, and it stated that its views did not necessarily reflect those of the Commission or any individual Commissioner. Some categories of data carry their own federal rules: the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act, for example, makes it unlawful for an operator of a website or online service directed to children, or one with actual knowledge that it is collecting personal information from a child, to collect that information in a manner that violates the FTC's regulations.

Sources for this answer
Secondary source · Agency guidanceD.1
FTC statement concerning the Facebook–WhatsApp acquisition

The FTC statement supports continuing to honor the identified WhatsApp privacy promises despite the acquisition.

We want to make clear that, regardless of the acquisition, WhatsApp must continue to honor these promises to consumers.

See April 10, 2014, quoting the Bureau Director’s letter

Primary source · Primary lawD.2
Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.140(ad)(2)(C), transfer in a merger or acquisition

Under the CCPA, a business does not sell personal information when it transfers it as an asset in a merger, acquisition, bankruptcy or other transaction in which the third party assumes control of all or part of the business, provided the information is used or shared consistently with the CCPA.

(C) The business transfers to a third party the personal information of a consumer as an asset that is part of a merger, acquisition, bankruptcy, or other transaction in which the third party assumes control of all or part of the business, provided that information is used or shared consistently with this title.

See Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.140(ad)(2)(C).

Primary source · Primary lawD.3
Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.140(ad)(2)(C), notice of changed practices after a transfer

A third party that materially alters its use or sharing of transferred personal information in a manner materially inconsistent with the promises made at collection must give the consumer prior notice of the new or changed practice.

If a third party materially alters how it uses or shares the personal information of a consumer in a manner that is materially inconsistent with the promises made at the time of collection, it shall provide prior notice of the new or changed practice to the consumer.

See Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.140(ad)(2)(C).

Secondary source · Agency guidance · 2015-05-16D.4
FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection letter concerning RadioShack customer data (2015), privacy promisesPDF

FTC staff read RadioShack's privacy policies as clearly and expressly representing that customer information would not be rented or sold to third parties.

For the period covered by these privacy policies, RadioShack thus clearly and expressly represented that customer information would not be rented or sold to third parties.

See Letter from Jessica L. Rich, Director, FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection, to Elise Frejka, Consumer Privacy Ombudsman, In re RadioShack Corp., No. 15-10197 (Bankr. D. Del.) (May 16, 2015), at 3.

Secondary source · Agency guidance · 2015-05-16D.6
FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection letter concerning RadioShack customer data (2015), Toysmart conditionsPDF

FTC staff described the Toysmart settlement, which allowed a transfer of customer information only if the buyer agreed not to sell it as a standalone asset, was in the same line of business, agreed to treat it under Toysmart's privacy policy and agreed to seek affirmative consent before changing that policy.

There, the Commission entered into a settlement with the company allowing the transfer of customer information under certain limited circumstances: 1) the buyer had to agree not to sell customer information as a standalone asset, but instead to sell it as part of a larger group of assets, including trademarks and online content; 2) the buyer had to be an entity that concentrated its business in the family commerce market, involving the areas of education, toys, learning, home and/or instruction (i.e., the same line of business that Toysmart had been in); 3) the buyer had to agree to treat the personal information in accordance with the terms of Toysmart’s privacy policy; and 4) the buyer had to agree to seek affirmative consent before making any changes to the policy that affected information gathered under the Toysmart policy.

See Letter from Jessica L. Rich, Director, FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection, to Elise Frejka, Consumer Privacy Ombudsman, In re RadioShack Corp., No. 15-10197 (Bankr. D. Del.) (May 16, 2015), at 5.

Internet resource · 2023-09-29D.7
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), customer records and seller copy

The Salem agreement transferred originals or true and complete copies of its customer records, lists and databases, while allowing the seller to keep a copy for internal recordkeeping and other legal and accounting purposes.

(g) Records. The originals (where available) or true and complete copies (if originals are not available) of all of the email subscriber/customer records, customer lists, customer contact information, registered user lists, databases, access codes, books, records, files, videos, logs and ledgers pertaining to the Sale Assets or used in the operation of the Business as set forth on Schedule 1.1(g) (collectively, “Records”); provided, that Seller may keep a copy of the Records for its internal recordkeeping and other legal and accounting purposes;

See §1.1(g)

Internet resource · 2023-09-29D.8
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), migration of content to buyer's servers

The Salem agreement required the seller to cooperate in moving purchased files and content from the seller's servers to servers the buyer selected as soon as reasonably practicable after closing.

Seller will cooperate with Buyer to transfer title to all of Seller’s files and content purchased by Buyer and stored at Closing on Seller’s servers from those servers to servers selected by Buyer as soon as reasonably practicable following the Closing.

See §8.8

Secondary source · Agency guidance · 2015-05-16D.5
FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection letter concerning RadioShack customer data (2015), Section 5 concernPDF

FTC staff stated concern that a sale of RadioShack's customer information would contravene its express promise not to sell or rent that information and could be a deceptive or unfair practice under Section 5 of the FTC Act.

We are concerned, however, that a sale or transfer of the personal information of RadioShack’s customers would contravene RadioShack’s express promise not to sell or rent such information and could constitute a deceptive or unfair practice under Section 5 of the FTC Act.

See Letter from Jessica L. Rich, Director, FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection, to Elise Frejka, Consumer Privacy Ombudsman, In re RadioShack Corp., No. 15-10197 (Bankr. D. Del.) (May 16, 2015), at 4.

Internet resource · 2004-08-18D.9
Greenfield Online–Dohring asset purchase agreement (2004), deletion of overlapping panel members

The Greenfield Online agreement required the seller to stop emailing overlapping panel members at closing, permanently delete them from its other panel within five days of closing and have an officer certify that in writing.

Seller agrees that on the Closing Date it will stop sending, and will stop authorizing any other Person to send, any email messages via the YIO domain or otherwise to members of the YIO Panel that are also members of the Panel, and that within five days of the Closing Seller will permanently delete from the YIO panel all members that are also members of the Panel, and an officer of Seller shall so certify in writing to the Buyer.

See §5.5

Secondary source · Agency guidance · 2015-05-16D.10
FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection letter concerning RadioShack customer data (2015), staff viewsPDF

The RadioShack letter states that its views do not necessarily reflect the views of the Commission or any individual Commissioner.

Please note that the views expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of the Federal Trade Commission or any individual Commissioner.

See Letter from Jessica L. Rich, Director, FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection, to Elise Frejka, Consumer Privacy Ombudsman, In re RadioShack Corp., No. 15-10197 (Bankr. D. Del.) (May 16, 2015), at 1 n.1.

Primary source · Primary lawD.11
15 U.S.C. § 6502(a)(1), children's online privacy

COPPA makes it unlawful for an operator of a website or online service directed to children, or an operator with actual knowledge that it is collecting personal information from a child, to collect personal information from a child in a manner that violates the FTC's regulations.

It is unlawful for an operator of a website or online service directed to children, or any operator that has actual knowledge that it is collecting personal information from a child, to collect personal information from a child in a manner that violates the regulations prescribed under subsection (b).

See 15 U.S.C. § 6502(a)(1).

How does the buyer make sure the assets are free of liens?

Under the Uniform Commercial Code as Delaware enacts it, a lien can survive the sale of an asset, because a security interest generally continues in collateral after a sale unless the secured party authorized the sale free of it.

Margaret M. Salinas recommends ordering UCC, litigation and tax lien searches on the seller at the outset of every transaction, and making payoff of existing liens, with evidence of their release, a condition to closing. The UCC search runs in the seller's state of organization, because under Delaware's UCC the law of the jurisdiction where the debtor is located generally governs perfection and a registered organization organized under a state's law is located in that state. It runs against the seller's exact legal name, because a financing statement with a defective debtor name still counts if a search under the debtor's correct name, using the filing office's standard search logic, would disclose it. A single filing can reach the whole business, because a financing statement sufficiently indicates its collateral by stating that it covers all assets or all personal property.

Payoff letters tie each release to the closing payment: one filed agreement required payoff letters from each person holding a lien on the acquired assets, stating the secured amount that the seller would pay at closing, followed by filed UCC-3 termination statements after closing.

After payment, the release is completed with a termination statement: under Delaware's UCC, for collateral other than the consumer goods covered by a separate rule, a secured party must send or file a termination statement within 20 days after it receives the debtor's signed demand when one of the listed conditions is met, such as no secured obligation or commitment remaining. Except as otherwise provided in section 9-510, which governs whether a filed record is effective, the financing statement stops being effective once the termination statement is filed. Because the statutory 20-day duty runs from the debtor's signed demand, a payoff letter can instead commit the lender to file the termination on receipt of the payoff amount.

The seller's title representation addresses a lien the search missed: one filed agreement for an online publishing business represented that the seller had good, valid and marketable title to all of the sale assets, free and clear of any liens except permitted liens, and listed on a schedule the permitted liens other than those to be released at or before closing. Vehicles need a separate check: under Delaware's UCC, filing a financing statement is not necessary or effective to perfect a security interest in property subject to the certificate-of-title rules for motor vehicles, among other listed statutes. The legal due diligence guide places lien review within a wider liability review.

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Primary lawE.1
Delaware Uniform Commercial Code, continuation of a security interest after disposition

Under Delaware's UCC, a security interest generally continues in collateral after disposition unless the secured party authorized a disposition free of it.

Except as otherwise provided in this Article and in Section 2-403(2): (1) a security interest or agricultural lien continues in collateral notwithstanding sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition thereof unless the secured party authorized the disposition free of the security interest or agricultural lien; and (2) a security interest attaches to any identifiable proceeds of collateral.

See 6 Del. C. § 9-315(a).

Primary source · Primary lawE.9
Delaware Uniform Commercial Code § 9-513(c), termination statement on demand

For non-consumer collateral, a secured party must send or file a termination statement within 20 days after the debtor's signed demand once no secured obligation or commitment remains.

(c) Other collateral. — In cases not governed by subsection (a), within 20 days after a secured party receives a signed demand from a debtor, the secured party shall cause the secured party of record for a financing statement to send to the debtor a termination statement for the financing statement or file the termination statement in the filing office if: (1) except in the case of a financing statement covering accounts or chattel paper that has been sold or goods that are the subject of a consignment, there is no obligation secured by the collateral covered by the financing statement and no commitment to make an advance, incur an obligation, or otherwise give value; (2) the financing statement covers accounts or chattel paper that has been sold but as to which the account debtor or other person obligated has discharged its obligation; (3) the financing statement covers goods that were the subject of a consignment to the debtor but are not in the debtor’s possession; or (4) the debtor did not authorize the filing of the initial financing statement.

See 6 Del. C. § 9-513(c).

Primary source · Primary lawE.10
Delaware Uniform Commercial Code § 9-513(d), effect of termination

Filing a termination statement makes the related financing statement ineffective.

(d) Effect of filing termination statement. — Except as otherwise provided in Section 9-510, upon the filing of a termination statement with the filing office, the financing statement to which the termination statement relates ceases to be effective.

See 6 Del. C. § 9-513(d).

Secondary source · Law-firm commentary · 2024-04-18E.2
Margaret M. Salinas: Five issues to address when acquiring a business (Chuhak & Tecson)

Margaret M. Salinas recommends ordering UCC, litigation and tax lien searches on the seller at the outset of every transaction.

Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), litigation and tax lien searches should be ordered on the seller(s) at the onset of every transaction.

See Margaret M. Salinas, Five Issues to Address When Acquiring a Business, Chuhak & Tecson (Apr. 18, 2024).

Secondary source · Law-firm commentary · 2024-04-18E.3
Margaret M. Salinas: Five issues to address when acquiring a business, lien payoff

Margaret M. Salinas recommends making payoff of existing liens and evidence of their release a condition precedent to closing.

If the seller(s) have existing liens, it should be a condition precedent to closing that those liens are paid off and evidence of the release of such liens is provided to the purchaser.

See Margaret M. Salinas, Five Issues to Address When Acquiring a Business, Chuhak & Tecson (Apr. 18, 2024).

Primary source · Primary lawE.4
Delaware Uniform Commercial Code § 9-301(1), law governing perfection

Except as otherwise provided in the section, while a debtor is located in a jurisdiction, that jurisdiction’s law governs perfection and priority of a security interest in collateral.

(1) Except as otherwise provided in this section, while a debtor is located in a jurisdiction, the local law of that jurisdiction governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and the priority of a security interest in collateral.

See 6 Del. C. § 9-301(1).

Primary source · Primary lawE.6
Delaware Uniform Commercial Code § 9-506(c), search under the debtor’s correct name

A debtor-name error does not make a financing statement seriously misleading if a search under the debtor’s correct name, using the filing office’s standard search logic, would disclose it.

(c) Financing statement not seriously misleading. — If a search of the records of the filing office under the debtor’s correct name, using the filing office’s standard search logic, if any, would disclose a financing statement that fails sufficiently to provide the name of the debtor in accordance with Section 9-503(a), the name provided does not make the financing statement seriously misleading.

See 6 Del. C. § 9-506(c).

Primary source · Primary lawE.7
Delaware Uniform Commercial Code § 9-504, indication of collateral

A financing statement sufficiently indicates its collateral by a description under section 9-108 or by stating that it covers all assets or all personal property.

A financing statement sufficiently indicates the collateral that it covers if the financing statement provides: (1) a description of the collateral pursuant to Section 9-108; or (2) an indication that the financing statement covers all assets or all personal property.

See 6 Del. C. § 9-504.

Internet resource · 2021-08-01E.8
Grove–VitaMedica asset purchase agreement (2021), payoff letters and UCC-3 terminations

The Grove agreement required payoff letters from each lienholder stating the secured amount, to be paid by the seller at closing, and filed UCC-3 termination statements after closing.

(xi) Payoff letters from each Person who has any Lien on or affecting any or all of the Acquired Assets, which letters shall state the outstanding amount of the obligation secured by the Lien (which amount shall be paid by Seller at Closing to such Person) and, after Closing, Seller shall provide copies of executed and filed UCC-3 termination statements and/or similar or other instruments evidencing the satisfaction of such indebtedness or other obligation in each jurisdiction where evidence of such obligation is necessary to perfect such satisfaction;

See §2.5(xi)

Internet resource · 2023-09-29E.11
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), title to sale assets

The Salem agreement represented that the seller had good, valid and marketable title to all of the sale assets, free and clear of any liens except permitted liens.

Seller has good, valid and marketable title to all of the Sale Assets, free and clear of any Liens except for Permitted Liens.

See §3.5(a)

Internet resource · 2023-09-29E.12
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), permitted liens schedule (title)

The Salem agreement lists on Schedule 5.4, to the seller’s knowledge, the permitted liens other than those to be released at or before closing.

To Seller’s knowledge, all Permitted Liens other than those that will be released at or before Closing are set forth on Schedule 5.4.

See §5.4

Primary source · Primary lawE.13
Delaware Uniform Commercial Code § 9-311(a), property subject to certificate-of-title rules

Except as provided in subsection (d), filing a financing statement is not necessary or effective to perfect a security interest in property subject to listed federal law, Delaware’s motor-vehicle certificate-of-title lien provisions, or another jurisdiction’s certificate-of-title statute.

(a) Security interest subject to other law. — Except as otherwise provided in subsection (d), the filing of a financing statement is not necessary or effective to perfect a security interest in property subject to: (1) a statute, regulation, or treaty of the United States whose requirements for a security interest’s obtaining priority over the rights of a lien creditor with respect to the property preempt Section 9-310(a); (2) Subchapter II of Chapter 23 of Title 21, relating to the notation of liens and encumbrances on certificates of title for motor vehicles; or (3) a statute of another jurisdiction which provides for a security interest to be indicated on a certificate of title as a condition or result of the security interest’s obtaining priority over the rights of a lien creditor with respect to the property.

See 6 Del. C. § 9-311(a).

What if a contractor or founder still owns part of the code?

A contractor or founder who still owns U.S. copyright in part of the business's code or content must sign the transfer, or have an authorized agent sign it, because 17 U.S.C. § 204(a) requires the rights owner's signed writing for a copyright ownership transfer outside operation of law.

Because the writing must be signed by the owner of the rights conveyed or that owner's authorized agent, a signature from the selling company alone does not establish a missing contributor assignment. Who owns the rights depends on who created the work and how: copyright vests initially in the author, and for a work made for hire the employer or other person for whom the work was prepared is considered the author and, absent a signed written agreement otherwise, owns all of the rights. Existing licenses also survive the files' arrival: a nonexclusive license evidenced by a writing signed by the rights owner prevails over a conflicting transfer of ownership if it was taken before the transfer was executed, or in good faith before the transfer was recorded and without notice of it.

The asset schedule identifies the relevant code, content and other works, and a separate copyright assignment can supply the conveyance, as in one filed agreement that called for an assignment of copyrights at closing alongside the assignment and bill of sale. When a contributor assignment is missing, the parties can make its delivery a closing condition or exclude the affected work with a price change; to accept the risk instead, the seller can give a specific representation, as one filed agreement did by representing that each contributing contractor had presently assigned any ownership interest to the seller. Third-party dependencies are addressed through the ownership representation and its schedules.

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Primary lawF.2
Initial ownership of copyright

Section 201(a) vests copyright initially in the author or authors of the work.

Copyright in a work protected under this title vests initially in the author or authors of the work.

See 17 U.S.C. §201(a)

Primary source · Primary lawF.3
Works made for hire

Section 201(b) treats the employer or other person for whom a work made for hire was prepared as its author and, absent a signed written agreement otherwise, as owner of all the rights.

In the case of a work made for hire, the employer or other person for whom the work was prepared is considered the author for purposes of this title, and, unless the parties have expressly agreed otherwise in a written instrument signed by them, owns all of the rights comprised in the copyright.

See 17 U.S.C. §201(b)

Primary source · Primary lawF.4
Copyright: priority of a nonexclusive license over a later transfer

Section 205(e) gives a signed written nonexclusive license priority over a conflicting transfer of ownership if taken before the transfer was executed, or in good faith before its recordation and without notice.

A nonexclusive license, whether recorded or not, prevails over a conflicting transfer of copyright ownership if the license is evidenced by a written instrument signed by the owner of the rights licensed or such owner's duly authorized agent, and if- (1) the license was taken before execution of the transfer; or (2) the license was taken in good faith before recordation of the transfer and without notice of it.

See 17 U.S.C. § 205(e)

Internet resource · 2018-10-15F.6
Luna–Micron asset purchase agreement (2018), contractor assignment representation

The Luna agreement represented that the seller had contracts with current and former employees and with contributing contractors under which each contractor acknowledged the seller's ownership, presently assigned any ownership interest and waived moral rights to the extent permitted by law.

Seller (and its predecessor-in-interest) have entered into Contracts with each current and former employee in the form attached to Schedule 3.25(c) and has entered into Contracts with each current and former independent contractor who is or was involved in or has contributed to the invention, creation, or development of any Intellectual Property during the course of engagement with or for the benefit of Seller whereby such independent contractor (i) acknowledges Seller’s exclusive ownership of all Intellectual Property Assets invented, created or developed by such independent contractor within the scope of his or her engagement with such Seller; (ii) grants to such Seller a present, irrevocable assignment of any ownership interest such independent contractor may have in or to such Intellectual Property; and (iii) irrevocably waives any right or interest, including any moral rights, regarding such Intellectual Property, to the extent permitted by applicable Legal Requirement.

See §3.25(c)

What should the agreement's security representations cover?

An agreement can address current safeguards and past security incidents in separate representations, as one filed asset purchase agreement did: one that the seller had implemented reasonable safeguards, and another, qualified by the seller's knowledge, about security incidents in the past five years involving third-party processors' systems or data. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.

A known incident belongs on the disclosure schedule as an exception, because a representation is made except as disclosed, so an exception properly scheduled is not a breach at all. The lookback period and any knowledge qualification are negotiated terms that the agreement states expressly, as that agreement's five-year period and knowledge qualifier show.

Sources for this answer
Internet resource · 2023-09-29G.1
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023)

The Salem agreement supports a seller assurance concerning the specified safeguards for business data and systems.

Seller has implemented reasonable and appropriate administrative, physical and technical safeguards to protect the privacy, security, confidentiality, availability, and integrity of all Business Data and Business Systems, in material compliance with all applicable Data Protection Requirements.

See §3.15(e)

Internet resource · 2023-09-29G.2
Salem asset purchase agreement (2023), security incidents

The Salem agreement included a knowledge-qualified representation that there had been no security incident involving third-party processors during the past five years.

To Seller’s knowledge during the past five years there has been no Security Incident involving any Business System operated or controlled by any Third Party Processor or any Business Data under the custody or control of any Third Party Processor.

See §3.15(e)

What if the selling owner holds the company's contractor license?

A contracting business in a licensed trade such as HVAC or plumbing can depend on one person's license. Florida, for example, requires a contracting business organization to have a licensed qualifying agent, or qualifier, and lets it operate only in the license category its qualifier holds. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 4 sources in this group. When the selling owner is the qualifier, the license can leave with them. If the departing qualifier is the company's only licensed contractor, the company has 60 days to employ a new qualifying agent, but it may not contract at all until it does: the 60 days are not a grace period. The only exception is a temporary certificate, granted by the licensing board's executive director or chair, that lets it finish jobs it already had. The buyer checklist below sets out what a buyer checks before signing.

This question applies to any business sold by asset purchase, including trades businesses such as HVAC and plumbing companies, not only the online and software businesses the rest of this guide uses as examples. Florida is the worked example.

Buyer checklist

What the buyer checksWhy it matters
1. Who the qualifier isThe Department of Business and Professional Regulation's licensee search shows the licenses tied to the company and its qualifier. The company can operate only in the category in which its qualifier is certified or registered, so the qualifier's license category and status set what the company may do.
2. Whether anyone else at the company holds a contractor licenseThe 60-day rule applies when the departing qualifier is the only certified or registered contractor affiliated with the company. A selling owner who is the only licensed contractor is the case where the license leaves with the seller.
3. A replacement qualifier lined up before signingA replacement needs a license in the category the company works in, and approval of each business organization is discretionary with the board. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. Chapter 489 sets no deadline for the board to act. The general rule for Florida license applications gives the agency 30 days to flag errors or request more information and 90 days after a complete application to approve or deny it. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
4. The qualifier's cooperation as a covenant or closing conditionA covenant that the seller stays on as qualifier for an agreed transition period, supports the qualification application and leaves on an agreed date, or a closing condition that a replacement qualifier is in place, addresses the risk that the business cannot contract once the seller leaves. Illustrative wording follows the checklist.
5. The contracts open when the qualifier leavesIf the qualifier leaves before a replacement is employed, the temporary certificate covers only contracts awarded to or entered into by the company before the qualifier left and contracts it had won as low bidder that are awarded later, and only while held by the financially responsible officer, the president, a partner or the general partner.

The following wording is illustrative only, written for this guide rather than taken from a filed agreement, and needs adapting to the deal structure and the license category:

ClauseIllustrative wording
Transition covenantFrom the Closing until the earlier of [90] days after the Closing and the date on which a replacement qualifying agent for [the Company] is approved, [Seller Principal] shall remain the qualifying agent of [the Company], shall not end that affiliation without at least [30] days' prior written notice to Buyer, and shall sign and deliver the applications, affidavits and other documents Buyer reasonably requests to qualify [the Company] through a replacement qualifying agent.
Closing condition[The Company] shall have been qualified by the Construction Industry Licensing Board to engage in contracting in the [plumbing] category through a qualifying agent reasonably acceptable to Buyer, and that qualification shall be in effect at the Closing.

Asset purchase or stock purchase

StructureWhat happens to the license in Florida
Asset purchaseThe buyer's company is a different business organization, and a business organization contracts through a qualifying agent who applies to qualify it. Nothing in § 489.119 moves the seller company's qualification to the buyer with the assets, so the buyer's company needs its own qualifying agent and its own approval, and approval of each business organization is discretionary with the board. If the seller's qualifier proposes to contract in affiliation with the buyer's company, the qualifier must inform the department in writing, and either the qualifier or the new company must supply the information required of applicants.
Stock or membership-interest purchaseThe company that holds the qualification does not change, and § 489.119 does not list a change of owners as an event that ends its qualification. But the rule turns on the qualifier, not the owners: if the selling owner is the only licensed contractor and leaves at closing, the 60-day rule applies to the company the buyer now owns.

The Florida rule in one table

Air-conditioning and plumbing contractors are among the construction contractors licensed under part I of chapter 489, On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. and the rule for them is in Fla. Stat. § 489.119(3)(a):

PointWhat § 489.119(3)(a) says
When it appliesThe qualifying agent stops being affiliated with the company and was the only certified or registered contractor affiliated with it.
NoticeThe qualifier must inform the Department of Business and Professional Regulation, and the company must notify the department that the qualifier's affiliation ended.
Deadline60 days from the end of the qualifier's affiliation to employ another qualifying agent.
Contracting in the meantimeNone. The company may not engage in contracting until a new qualifying agent is employed.
Temporary certificateThe board's executive director or chair may grant a temporary, nonrenewable certificate or registration to the company's financially responsible officer, president, a partner or, for a limited partnership, the general partner, who takes on all responsibilities of a primary qualifying agent.
What the temporary certificate coversOnly incomplete contracts: contracts awarded to or entered into by the company before the qualifier left, and contracts it had won as low bidder that are awarded later, whether or not work has started.
License categoryThe company can operate only in the category of contracting in which its qualifying agent is certified or registered, so a replacement needs a license in the category the company works in.

Section 489.119(3)(a) does not say what happens on day 61. Unlike the electrical rule below, it does not provide that the business stops being qualified when the 60 days run out; it says only that the business may not engage in contracting until a qualifying agent is employed. Separately, a business organization without a primary or secondary qualifying agent for the scope of the work is unlicensed for purposes of § 489.128, and a contract it enters into while unlicensed is unenforceable by it, with no lien or bond claim in its favor for that work. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.

The qualifier is more than a name on the application. As a general rule, all primary qualifying agents are jointly and equally responsible for supervising all of the company's operations, all field work at all sites and its financial matters. Where the board has approved a financially responsible officer, that officer is responsible for the company's financial side and the primary qualifying agent for all of its construction activities. The application to qualify a company includes the qualifier's affidavit of final approval authority for all of the company's construction work and, unless the board has approved a financially responsible officer, on its business matters, including contracts and payments. A seller who is the qualifier is therefore hard to replace quickly.

Electrical and alarm system contractors

Florida's electrical and alarm system contractors are licensed under a separate part of chapter 489 with a parallel rule. If the only individual who qualifies the business leaves, the business has 60 days to qualify another person, failing which the board determines that it is no longer qualified to engage in contracting. That section does not contain the temporary certificate for incomplete contracts that § 489.119(3)(a) provides.

This answer uses Florida as an example and is not a survey of other states, each of which has its own licensing law. It also does not cover the board's rules, local licensing, building permits already pulled under the seller's license, or the case where a qualifier is designated by joint agreement among several qualifying agents.

Sources for this answer
Primary source · Primary lawH.2
Fla. Stat. § 489.119(3)(a)

A business organization operates only in its qualifying agent's category; when its only certified or registered contractor leaves, it has 60 days to employ another qualifying agent and may not contract meanwhile, except incomplete contracts under a temporary nonrenewable certificate.

A qualifying agent must be certified or registered under this part in order for the business organization to operate in the category of contracting in which the qualifying agent is certified or registered. If any qualifying agent ceases to be affiliated with a business organization, he or she shall inform the department. In addition, if the qualifying agent is the only certified or registered contractor affiliated with the business organization, the business organization shall notify the department of the termination of the qualifying agent and shall have 60 days from the termination of the qualifying agent’s affiliation with the business organization in which to employ another qualifying agent. The business organization may not engage in contracting until a qualifying agent is employed, unless the executive director or chair of the board has granted a temporary nonrenewable certificate or registration to the financially responsible officer, the president, a partner, or, in the case of a limited partnership, the general partner, who assumes all responsibilities of a primary qualifying agent for the business organization. This temporary certificate or registration shall only allow the business organization to proceed with incomplete contracts. For the purposes of this paragraph, an incomplete contract is one which has been awarded to, or entered into by, the business organization prior to the cessation of affiliation of the qualifying agent with the business organization or one on which the business organization was the low bidder and the contract is subsequently awarded, regardless of whether any actual work has commenced under the contract prior to the qualifying agent ceasing to be affiliated with the business organization.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.119(3)(a) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.1
Fla. Stat. § 489.119(2)

A business organization that proposes to engage in contracting does so through an applicant who applies for registration or certification as its qualifying agent.

If the applicant proposes to engage in contracting as a business organization, including any partnership, corporation, business trust, or other legal entity, or in any name other than the applicant’s legal name or a fictitious name where the applicant is doing business as a sole proprietorship, the applicant must apply for registration or certification as the qualifying agent of the business organization.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.119(2) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.13
Fla. Stat. § 489.119(2)(b)1.

The application to qualify a business organization includes the applicant's affidavit of final approval authority for its construction work and business matters, unless a financially responsible officer is approved.

An application for registration or certification to qualify a business organization must include an affidavit on a form provided by the board attesting that the applicant has final approval authority for all construction work performed by the business organization and that the applicant has final approval authority on all business matters, including contracts, specifications, checks, drafts, or payments, regardless of the form of payment, made by the business organization, except where a financially responsible officer is approved.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.119(2)(b)1. (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.8
Fla. Stat. § 489.119(3)(b)

A qualifying agent who proposes to contract in affiliation with another business organization must inform the department, and the agent or new organization must supply applicant information.

The qualifying agent shall inform the department in writing when he or she proposes to engage in contracting in his or her own name or in affiliation with another business organization, and he or she or such new business organization shall supply the same information to the department as required of applicants under this part.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.119(3)(b) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.5
Fla. Stat. § 489.119(6)

A qualifying agent pays a fee to qualify a new business organization, and approval of each business organization is discretionary with the board.

Each qualifying agent shall pay the department an amount equal to the original fee for registration or certification to qualify a new business organization. If the qualifying agent for a business organization desires to qualify additional business organizations, the board shall require the qualifying agent to present evidence of his or her ability to supervise the construction activities of each such organization. Approval of each business organization is discretionary with the board.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.119(6) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.11
Fla. Stat. § 489.1195(1)(a)

Primary qualifying agents are jointly and equally responsible for supervising the business organization's operations, field work and financial matters.

All primary qualifying agents for a business organization are jointly and equally responsible for supervision of all operations of the business organization; for all field work at all sites; and for financial matters, both for the organization in general and for each specific job.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.1195(1)(a) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.12
Fla. Stat. § 489.1195(1)(b)–(c)

With board approval, a business may designate a financially responsible officer who is responsible for its financial aspects, and the primary qualifying agent is then responsible for all of its construction activities.

Upon approval by the board, a business entity may designate a financially responsible officer for purposes of certification or registration. A financially responsible officer shall be responsible for all financial aspects of the business organization and may not be designated as the primary qualifying agent. The designated financially responsible officer shall furnish evidence of the financial responsibility, credit, and business reputation of either himself or herself, or the business organization he or she desires to qualify, as determined appropriate by the board. (c) Where a business organization has a certified or registered financially responsible officer, the primary qualifying agent shall be responsible for all construction activities of the business organization, both in general and for each specific job.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.1195(1)(b)–(c) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.3
Fla. Stat. § 489.105(3)(m)

Plumbing contractors are one of the contractor categories defined in part I of chapter 489.

“Plumbing contractor” means a contractor whose services are unlimited in the plumbing trade and includes contracting business consisting of the execution of contracts requiring the experience, financial means, knowledge, and skill to install, maintain, repair, alter, extend, or, if not prohibited by law, design plumbing.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.105(3)(m) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.4
Fla. Stat. § 489.105(3)(f)

Air-conditioning contractors, whose work covers central air-conditioning, refrigeration, heating and ventilating systems, are one of the contractor categories defined in part I of chapter 489.

“Class A air-conditioning contractor” means a contractor whose services are unlimited in the execution of contracts requiring the experience, knowledge, and skill to install, maintain, repair, fabricate, alter, extend, or design, if not prohibited by law, central air-conditioning, refrigeration, heating, and ventilating systems, including duct work in connection with a complete system if such duct work is performed by the contractor as necessary to complete an air-distribution system, boiler and unfired pressure vessel systems, and all appurtenances, apparatus, or equipment used in connection therewith

See Fla. Stat. § 489.105(3)(f) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.14
Fla. Stat. § 489.521(5)

For electrical and alarm system contracting, when the only individual who qualifies a business organization leaves, it has 60 days to qualify another person, failing which the board determines it is no longer qualified to engage in contracting.

In addition, if the individual is the only individual who qualifies the business organization, the business organization shall notify the board and the department of the individual’s termination, and it shall have a period of 60 days from the termination of the individual to qualify another person under the provision of this act, failing which, the board shall determine that the business organization is no longer qualified to engage in contracting.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.521(5) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.9
Fla. Stat. § 489.128(1)

Contracts entered into by an unlicensed contractor are unenforceable by it, and a business organization without a primary or secondary qualifying agent for the scope of the work is unlicensed.

As a matter of public policy, contracts entered into on or after October 1, 1990, by an unlicensed contractor shall be unenforceable in law or in equity by the unlicensed contractor. (a) For purposes of this section, an individual is unlicensed if the individual does not have a license required by this part concerning the scope of the work to be performed under the contract. A business organization is unlicensed if the business organization does not have a primary or secondary qualifying agent in accordance with this part concerning the scope of the work to be performed under the contract.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.128(1) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.10
Fla. Stat. § 489.128(2)

When a contract is unenforceable under § 489.128, the unlicensed contractor has no lien or bond claim for the labor, services or materials provided under it.

Notwithstanding any other provision of law to the contrary, if a contract is rendered unenforceable under this section, no lien or bond claim shall exist in favor of the unlicensed contractor for any labor, services, or materials provided under the contract or any amendment thereto.

See Fla. Stat. § 489.128(2) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.6
Fla. Stat. § 120.60(1)

An agency must flag errors or omissions in a license application within 30 days and approve or deny a completed application within 90 days, unless a shorter period is provided by law.

Upon receipt of a license application, an agency shall examine the application and, within 30 days after such receipt, notify the applicant of any apparent errors or omissions and request any additional information the agency is permitted by law to require. An agency may not deny a license for failure to correct an error or omission or to supply additional information unless the agency timely notified the applicant within this 30-day period.

See Fla. Stat. § 120.60(1) (2026).

Primary source · Primary lawH.7
Fla. Stat. § 120.60(1), 90-day period

An application for a license must be approved or denied within 90 days after receipt of a completed application unless a shorter period is provided by law.

An application for a license must be approved or denied within 90 days after receipt of a completed application unless a shorter period of time for agency action is provided by law.

See Fla. Stat. § 120.60(1) (2026).