Should the business be bought through an asset purchase or a stock purchase?
An asset purchase gives the buyer more protection from the seller's liabilities than a stock purchase, subject to successor-liability exceptions, while a stock purchase transfers the company with all of its liabilities but generally leaves its contracts in place, so the choice turns on liability, tax and third-party consents. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group.
Liabilities. In a stock purchase, the buyer acquires the company as an entity, and the company keeps all of its liabilities, so the buyer bears them as the new owner. In an asset purchase, the buyer generally does not take on the seller's debts, but in some cases an asset buyer can be held liable for certain liabilities of the seller; the successor liability question covers those exceptions.
Tax. In an asset sale, each asset is classified and its gain or loss is figured separately, so the seller's result depends on the mix of assets; for example, the sale of inventory produces ordinary income or loss. The buyer's basis in purchased property is generally its cost, which the price allocation spreads across the assets.
In a stock sale, the owner sells shares instead of assets and usually realizes capital gain or loss. The buyer's basis in the shares it buys is generally their cost; because the company itself sells nothing, its basis in its own assets does not change unless the parties make one of the elections described next.
Both at once. A stock purchase can receive asset-sale tax treatment through an election under 26 U.S.C. § 338(h)(10), which treats the target corporation as if it sold all of its assets in a single transaction. The regulations make that election available when the buyer acquires the stock from a selling consolidated group, a selling affiliate or the shareholders of an S corporation, but only in a qualified stock purchase, which the statute limits to stock acquired by another corporation. Section 336(e) supplies a similar election when a corporation sells all of the stock of a subsidiary that meets the statute's ownership test. The regulations extend that election to dispositions by the shareholders of an S corporation, and they state that its results should generally coincide with those of a § 338(h)(10) election.
An election is not a unilateral buyer decision: a § 338(h)(10) election is made jointly by the buyer and the sellers, and S corporation shareholders who do not sell must also consent, so a stock purchase agreement that depends on an election addresses it expressly.
Consents. Transferring contracts in an asset purchase typically triggers any anti-assignment clause and may require the counterparty's consent, while a stock purchase generally does not, because the company continues to own its contracts after closing. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. A stock purchase can still trigger a change-of-control clause, which may require notice or consent or give the other party a termination right; the consent question covers what happens when a consent is not obtained. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Approvals. A Delaware corporation may sell all or substantially all of its property and assets through its board of directors when authorized by a resolution of the holders of a majority of its outstanding voting stock, adopted at a meeting called on at least 20 days' notice. In a stock purchase, the buyer instead buys the owners' shares in the corporation or limited liability company, so each selling owner signs for its own shares, while the signing question covers who signs for the seller in an asset purchase.
Buyers often prefer an asset purchase, which the rest of this guide assumes, while a stock purchase may suit a business whose key contracts cannot be assigned without consent, because the company keeps those contracts.
Sources for this answer
Kahn, Dees, Donovan & Kahn explains that a stock buyer acquires the company as an entity and so assumes its liabilities, which the company retains as a matter of law, and that an asset purchase gives the buyer much greater protection against the company's obligations.
In a stock purchase, the buyer purchases the target company as an entity, and therefore assumes the seller’s liabilities, since the company being acquired retains all of its liabilities as a matter of law. By restructuring the transaction as an asset purchase rather than a stock purchase, a buyer is provided with a much greater level of protection against liability for the target company’s obligations.
See Jeffrey K. Helfrich, Successor Liability in the Purchase of a Business: Express or Implied Assumption of Obligations (Part 1 of 8), Kahn, Dees, Donovan & Kahn, LLP (May 5, 2015).
Kahn, Dees, Donovan & Kahn explains that the traditional rule protects an asset buyer from the seller's debts but that, in some cases, an asset purchaser may be held liable for certain liabilities of the seller.
The law in most jurisdictions has traditionally held that when one company sells all of its assets to another, the buyer does not become liable for the debts and liabilities of the selling company. This is still true to a large extent, and we frequently recommend structuring a transaction as an asset purchase in order to protect the buyer from the liabilities of the business being acquired. However, over the past several years, the theory of successor liability has evolved and expanded as a result of a series of clashes between the policy in favor of allowing a company to sell its assets in an unrestricted manner, balanced against other policies, such as providing a source of relief for injured parties or other claimants. As a result, in some cases, a purchaser of assets may be held liable for certain liabilities of the seller.
See Jeffrey K. Helfrich, Successor Liability in the Purchase of a Business: Express or Implied Assumption of Obligations (Part 1 of 8), Kahn, Dees, Donovan & Kahn, LLP (May 5, 2015).
Kahn, Dees, Donovan & Kahn reports that buyers often prefer an asset purchase to a stock purchase.
When purchasing a business, buyers often prefer that the transaction be structured as an asset purchase rather than a stock purchase.
See Jeffrey K. Helfrich, Successor Liability in the Purchase of a Business: Express or Implied Assumption of Obligations (Part 1 of 8), Kahn, Dees, Donovan & Kahn, LLP (May 5, 2015).
The IRS states that the gain or loss on each business asset is figured separately, with capital assets producing capital gain or loss, long-held business real or depreciable property producing section 1231 gain or loss, and inventory producing ordinary income or loss.
The gain or loss on each asset is figured separately. The sale of capital assets results in capital gain or loss. The sale of real property or depreciable property used in the business and held longer than 1 year results in gain or loss from a section 1231 transaction. The sale of inventory results in ordinary income or loss.
See Internal Revenue Service, Sale of a business (accessed Sept. 29, 2026).
Section 1012 provides that the basis of property is its cost, except as otherwise provided in the listed subchapters.
The basis of property shall be the cost of such property, except as otherwise provided in this subchapter and subchapters C (relating to corporate distributions and adjustments), K (relating to partners and partnerships), and P (relating to capital gains and losses).
See 26 U.S.C. § 1012(a).
The IRS states that an interest in a corporation is represented by stock and that a seller of the stock usually realizes capital gain or loss.
Your interest in a corporation is represented by stock certificates. When you sell these certificates, you usually realize capital gain or loss.
See Internal Revenue Service, Sale of a business, Corporation interests (accessed Sept. 29, 2026).
Section 338(h)(10) authorizes an election under which a target corporation that was a member of the selling consolidated group recognizes gain or loss as if it sold all of its assets in a single transaction, and, to the extent the regulations provide, the group recognizes no gain or loss on the stock sold.
Under regulations prescribed by the Secretary, an election may be made under which if- (i) the target corporation was, before the transaction, a member of the selling consolidated group, and (ii) the target corporation recognizes gain or loss with respect to the transaction as if it sold all of its assets in a single transaction, then the target corporation shall be treated as a member of the selling consolidated group with respect to such sale, and (to the extent provided in regulations) no gain or loss will be recognized on stock sold or exchanged in the transaction by members of the selling consolidated group.
See 26 U.S.C. § 338(h)(10)(A).
Section 338(d)(3) defines a qualified stock purchase as an acquisition by another corporation, by purchase within the 12-month acquisition period, of stock meeting the section 1504(a)(2) ownership test.
The term "qualified stock purchase" means any transaction or series of transactions in which stock (meeting the requirements of section 1504(a)(2)) of 1 corporation is acquired by another corporation by purchase during the 12-month acquisition period.
See 26 U.S.C. § 338(d)(3).
The Treasury regulation permits a section 338(h)(10) election when the purchaser acquires qualifying stock in a qualified stock purchase from a selling consolidated group, a selling affiliate or the S corporation shareholders.
A section 338(h)(10) election may be made for T if P acquires stock meeting the requirements of section 1504(a)(2) from a selling consolidated group, a selling affiliate, or the S corporation shareholders in a qualified stock purchase.
See 26 C.F.R. § 1.338(h)(10)-1(c)(1).
The Treasury regulation requires a section 338(h)(10) election to be made jointly by the purchaser and the sellers on Form 8023, and requires consent from S corporation shareholders who do not sell.
A section 338(h)(10) election is made jointly by P and the selling consolidated group (or the selling affiliate or the S corporation shareholders) on Form 8023 in accordance with the instructions to the form. S corporation shareholders who do not sell their stock must also consent to the election.
See 26 C.F.R. § 1.338(h)(10)-1(c)(3).
Section 336(e) authorizes regulations under which a corporation that sells, exchanges or distributes all of its stock in a subsidiary meeting the section 1504(a)(2) test may elect to treat the transaction as a disposition of all of the subsidiary's assets, with no gain or loss recognized on the stock.
Under regulations prescribed by the Secretary, if- (1) a corporation owns stock in another corporation meeting the requirements of section 1504(a)(2), and (2) such corporation sells, exchanges, or distributes all of such stock, an election may be made to treat such sale, exchange, or distribution as a disposition of all of the assets of such other corporation, and no gain or loss shall be recognized on the sale, exchange, or distribution of such stock.
See 26 U.S.C. § 336(e).
The Treasury regulation defines a qualified stock disposition to include a sale, exchange or distribution of qualifying stock of a domestic corporation by the S corporation shareholders, as well as by another domestic corporation, during the 12-month disposition period.
The term qualified stock disposition means any transaction or series of transactions in which stock meeting the requirements of section 1504(a)(2) of a domestic corporation is either sold, exchanged, or distributed, or any combination thereof, by another domestic corporation or by the S corporation shareholders in a disposition, within the meaning of paragraph (b)(5) of this section, during the 12-month disposition period.
See 26 C.F.R. § 1.336-1(b)(6)(i).
The Treasury regulation states that, except where inconsistent with section 336(e), the results of section 336(e) should coincide with those of section 338(h)(10).
Generally, except to the extent inconsistent with section 336(e), the results of section 336(e) should coincide with those of section 338(h)(10).
See 26 C.F.R. § 1.336-1(a)(1).
Potomac Law Group explains that in an asset purchase the buyer acquires contracts by assignment, which typically triggers any anti-assignment clause and may require the counterparty's consent.
In an asset purchase, the buyer acquires contracts by assignment, which typically triggers any anti-assignment clause and may require the counterparty’s consent to assignment as a matter of contract law.
See Laurent Campo, The Change of Control Problem Nobody Owns in M&A Until It's Too Late, Potomac Law Group (Feb. 19, 2026).
Potomac Law Group explains that in a stock purchase the contracts remain with the same legal entity, so anti-assignment provisions are generally not implicated.
In a stock purchase, the contracts remain with the same legal entity, so anti-assignment provisions are generally not implicated.
See Laurent Campo, The Change of Control Problem Nobody Owns in M&A Until It's Too Late, Potomac Law Group (Feb. 19, 2026).
DLA Piper explains that a direct stock purchase generally does not trigger a simple anti-assignment provision because the target's assets are not conveyed to a different entity.
Like a reverse triangular merger, a direct stock purchase generally does not trigger a simple anti-assignment provision because the assets are not conveyed to a different entity.
See Kevin Criddle & Anthony Kappus, Assigning Contracts in the Context of M&A Transactions, DLA Piper, The Venture Alley (Oct. 24, 2012).
Potomac Law Group explains that stock purchases and reverse triangular mergers can still trigger change-of-control provisions.
But stock purchases and reverse triangular mergers can still trigger change of control provisions, particularly those capturing indirect ownership changes.
See Laurent Campo, The Change of Control Problem Nobody Owns in M&A Until It's Too Late, Potomac Law Group (Feb. 19, 2026).
Potomac Law Group lists the questions to ask of each change-of-control provision: whether it requires consent or only notice, the standard for the counterparty's action, any window to exercise a termination right, and the economic consequences of termination.
The pre-market audit should identify, for each material contract: whether a change of control provision exists, whether it requires consent or merely notice, what standard governs the counterparty’s right to act, whether the counterparty has a defined window in which to exercise a termination right, and what the economic consequences of termination would be.
See Laurent Campo, The Change of Control Problem Nobody Owns in M&A Until It's Too Late, Potomac Law Group (Feb. 19, 2026).
Delaware law permits a corporation's board to sell all or substantially all of the corporation's property and assets when authorized by a resolution adopted by the holders of a majority of the outstanding stock entitled to vote, at a meeting called on at least 20 days' notice.
Every corporation may at any meeting of its board of directors or governing body sell, lease or exchange all or substantially all of its property and assets, including its goodwill and its corporate franchises, upon such terms and conditions and for such consideration, which may consist in whole or in part of money or other property, including shares of stock in, and/or other securities of, any other corporation or corporations, as its board of directors or governing body deems expedient and for the best interests of the corporation, when and as authorized by a resolution adopted by the holders of a majority of the outstanding stock of the corporation entitled to vote thereon or, if the corporation is a nonstock corporation, by a majority of the members having the right to vote for the election of the members of the governing body and any other members entitled to vote thereon under the certificate of incorporation or the bylaws of such corporation, at a meeting duly called upon at least 20 days’ notice.
See 8 Del. C. § 271(a).
The Mellor Law Firm explains that in a stock purchase the buyer buys the owner's shares in the corporation or limited liability company.
In a stock purchase, you buy the owner’s shares in the corporation or LLC.
See Mark Mellor, Asset Purchase vs. Stock Purchase: What California Business Buyers Need to Know, The Mellor Law Firm, APLC (May 14, 2026).
Do the owners have to approve a sale of the company's assets?
A Delaware stock corporation that sells all or substantially all of its property and assets needs both its board's decision and a resolution adopted by the holders of a majority of its outstanding stock entitled to vote, under 8 Del. C. § 271(a).
Whether a sale reaches all or substantially all of the assets is not only a matter of size, because Delaware's Court of Chancery has held that a sale is beyond the board's power alone if it is of assets quantitatively vital to the operation of the corporation, is out of the ordinary, and substantially affects the corporation's existence and purpose.
Section 271 is a corporate statute, and for a Delaware limited liability company management is vested in the members in proportion to their interests in profits, with members owning more than 50 percent controlling, unless the LLC agreement provides otherwise or provides for management by a manager, so the LLC agreement is the first document that answers who approves a sale of the business.
A buyer can make the approvals a closing condition, as in one filed agreement where the buyer's obligation to close depended on receiving certified copies of the seller's board and shareholder resolutions authorizing the agreement and the transaction; the closing-deliverables question lists where those certificates fit.
Sources for this answer
8 Del. C. § 271(a) permits a corporation's board to sell all or substantially all of its property and assets when authorized by a resolution of the holders of a majority of the outstanding stock entitled to vote.
Every corporation may at any meeting of its board of directors or governing body sell, lease or exchange all or substantially all of its property and assets, including its goodwill and its corporate franchises, upon such terms and conditions and for such consideration, which may consist in whole or in part of money or other property, including shares of stock in, and/or other securities of, any other corporation or corporations, as its board of directors or governing body deems expedient and for the best interests of the corporation, when and as authorized by a resolution adopted by the holders of a majority of the outstanding stock of the corporation entitled to vote thereon or, if the corporation is a nonstock corporation, by a majority of the members having the right to vote for the election of the members of the governing body and any other members entitled to vote thereon under the certificate of incorporation or the bylaws of such corporation, at a meeting duly called upon at least 20 days’ notice.
See 8 Del. C. § 271(a)
The Court of Chancery held that a sale of assets quantitatively vital to the corporation's operation that is out of the ordinary and substantially affects its existence and purpose is beyond the board's power alone.
If the sale is of assets quantitatively vital to the operation of the corporation and is out of the ordinary and substantially affects the existence and purpose of the corporation, then it is beyond the power of the Board of Directors.
See Gimbel v. Signal Cos., 316 A.2d 599 (Del. Ch. 1974).
6 Del. C. § 18-402 vests LLC management in the members by their profit interests, with more than 50 percent controlling, unless the LLC agreement provides otherwise or provides for a manager.
Unless otherwise provided in a limited liability company agreement, the management of a limited liability company shall be vested in its members in proportion to the then current percentage or other interest of members in the profits of the limited liability company owned by all of the members, the decision of members owning more than 50 percent of the said percentage or other interest in the profits controlling; provided however, that if a limited liability company agreement provides for the management, in whole or in part, of a limited liability company by a manager, the management of the limited liability company, to the extent so provided, shall be vested in the manager who shall be chosen in the manner provided in the limited liability company agreement.
See 6 Del. C. § 18-402
The Greenfield Online agreement conditioned the buyer's obligation to close on a good standing certificate and certified copies of the seller's board and shareholder resolutions authorizing the agreement.
(g) Seller shall have delivered to Buyer a Good Standing Certificate for Seller from the Secretary of State of the State of California and each other jurisdiction where Seller is qualified to do business dated as of a date within 5 days preceding the Closing Date; (h) Buyer shall have received certified copies of resolutions of Seller’s Board of Directors and shareholders authorizing the execution and delivery of this Agreement and the consummation of the transactions contemplated hereby;
See §7.1(g)–(h)
Can the buyer become responsible for the seller's debts?
Sometimes: an asset buyer can become liable for the seller's unpaid sales tax under California, New York and Texas statutes, and for some federal labor and employment claims under federal case law. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. Before paying, a buyer protects itself by filing the state's tax clearance request or notice and holding back enough of the price to cover the seller's tax until clearance or a statutory release permits payment, with any amount the agency claims kept for the tax, On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group. and by checking for pending employment claims so their cost can be reflected in the price or an indemnity.
| Liability | Rule | When it reaches an asset buyer | What protects the buyer |
|---|---|---|---|
| California sales and use tax | State statute: Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §§ 6811–6812 | The buyer of the business or its stock of goods pays without withholding enough to cover the seller's tax; liability up to the purchase price | Withholding until the seller produces a receipt or a certificate that no amount is due |
| New York sales tax | State statute: N.Y. Tax Law § 1141(c) | A bulk sale outside the ordinary course with no notice to the tax department; liability up to the higher of the price or the assets' fair market value | Notice by registered mail at least ten days before paying or taking possession , then holding back the amount of any tax claim the department identifies |
| Texas state taxes | State statute: Tex. Tax Code § 111.020 | The buyer of the business or its stock of goods pays without withholding enough to cover what the seller owes; liability up to the value of the price | A comptroller certificate that no tax is due , or withholding until the seller produces a comptroller receipt or that certificate |
| Texas taxes after a sham or below-value sale | State statute: Tex. Tax Code § 111.024 | The seller transferred the business to evade tax or without receiving reasonably equivalent value | A reasonably equivalent price answers only the below-value ground, not a transfer made to evade tax ; withholding alone is no defense if the amount withheld falls short and the price was not reasonably equivalent |
| Federal employment claims (NLRA, Title VII, FLSA) | Federal case law: Golden State Bottling (NLRA) , MacMillan Bloedel (Title VII) , Steinbach and Teed (FLSA) | Decided case by case ; the factors include notice of the claim, the seller's ability to provide relief and continuity of the business ; sale terms that disclaim the liability do not control | Diligence on pending charges and suits; a lower price or an indemnity clause |
| Any seller debt | State common law; four exceptions | The buyer agreed to assume it, the deal amounts to a merger, the buyer is a mere continuation of the seller, or the transfer was made fraudulently to escape liability for the seller's debts | A list of assumed liabilities that excludes everything else ; a seller indemnity backed by an escrow |
The tax statutes reach a buyer that skips the state's withholding or notice step. California and Texas cap the buyer's liability at the purchase price and New York at the higher of the price or the assets' fair market value, On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group. and the Texas rule covers amounts owed under the state-taxation title of its Tax Code.
Federal courts decide labor and employment successor claims case by case, weighing factors that start with whether the buyer had notice of the claim and whether the seller can provide relief, and include continuity of the business. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Outside the tax and employment rules, the traditional common-law starting point is that an asset purchaser does not take on the seller's liabilities unless it agreed to, the deal amounts to a consolidation or merger, the buyer is a mere continuation of the seller, or the transfer was made to escape the debts fraudulently, subject to other doctrines in particular states, such as California's product-line rule for product claims.
The sections below cover the tax clearance timeline, the California and New York and Texas statutes, federal employment claims, the common-law exceptions and indemnity and escrow, and, for a buyer of stock rather than assets, sales tax exposure in stock deals.
Tax clearance timeline: California, New York and Texas
Each of the three states gives the buyer a way to learn what the seller owes before the money goes out, and each releases the buyer if the agency does not answer in time. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 3 sources in this group.
| State | Form, certificate or notice | Agency | Who files | When, relative to closing or payment | If the agency misses its deadline |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| California | A written request for a tax clearance certificate | California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (the statute and regulation still refer to the board) | The purchaser | No fixed lead time; the agency has 60 days from the latest of its receipt of the request, the date of sale or the date the seller's records are made available for audit | The purchaser is released from further obligation to withhold |
| New York | Form AU-196.10, Notification of Sale, Transfer, or Assignment in Bulk | Tax Department | The purchaser | At least 10 days before paying for or taking possession of any business assets, whichever comes first ; the department answers within 5 business days with a release (Form AU-197.1) or a notice of claim (Form AU-196.2) and states any amount due within 90 days | No notice of claim within 5 business days of a proper, timely filing: the purchaser is not liable and may pay the full price ; no amount stated within 90 days: released from withholding |
| Texas | Form 86-114, Joint Request for Certificate of No Tax Due | Comptroller of Public Accounts | The seller and purchaser jointly | Before the sale closes ; the comptroller has 60 days after the request or after the seller's records are made available, and no more than 90 days after the request , and usually answers within 10 business days when no audit is needed | The purchaser is released from the obligation to withhold or pay |
The release does not end every exposure: in New York, assets bought from the seller may still be subject to the department's liens if there are outstanding warrants or judgments against the seller, and in Texas, a transfer made to evade tax or for less than reasonably equivalent value carries a separate liability, against which withholding is no defense if the amount withheld falls short and the price was not reasonably equivalent. California's regulation adds that when it is unclear whether a purchase triggers the rule, the purchaser should obtain a certificate.
A worked illustration. A buyer agrees to pay $1,000,000 for the assets of a California retailer that owes $120,000 in unpaid sales tax, and the purchase agreement gives the buyer an unsecured seller indemnity for that tax. If the buyer holds back enough of the price to cover that amount until the seller produces a receipt or a certificate that nothing is due, the tax is paid out of money the buyer still controls. If the buyer instead pays the full $1,000,000 at closing, it becomes personally liable for the $120,000 it should have withheld, and recovery under that unsecured indemnity may be worth far less if the seller has spent the proceeds. The figures are invented for the illustration.
For a state not covered here, the place to look is that state's revenue department guidance on successor liability, bulk sales or tax clearance; this guide covers only the three states in the table.
State tax statutes: California and New York
Some state tax statutes impose successor liability directly and set out a procedure for avoiding it. California uses a withholding rule: when a person liable for an amount under the state's sales and use tax law sells out the business or its stock of goods, the buyer must withhold enough of the price to cover that amount until the seller produces a receipt showing payment or a certificate that nothing is due. A purchaser that fails to withhold becomes personally liable for the amount it should have withheld, up to the purchase price.
New York uses a notice rule instead: when a seller that is required to collect sales tax makes a bulk sale of business assets outside the ordinary course, the purchaser must notify the tax authority at least ten days before taking possession or paying, whether or not the seller says it owes tax. A purchaser that fails to comply becomes personally liable for the seller's sales taxes, up to the higher of the purchase price or the fair market value of the assets. Giving the notice does not end the matter: if the tax authority tells the purchaser that a possible tax claim exists, or if the purchaser never gave notice, the price still owed to the seller is subject to a first-priority lien for the seller's taxes, and the purchaser may not pay it over to the extent of the state's claim. The tax authority has ninety days from receiving the notice to state the amount it claims, and if it does not, the purchaser is released from any further obligation to withhold.
These procedures affect the closing timetable and the amount paid at closing: the California amount is withheld until the seller produces the receipt or no-tax-due certificate, so a holdback or escrow for it can be released against that document rather than on a fixed date, while the New York notice has to go out at least ten days before the buyer pays or takes possession, and any amount the tax authority claims cannot be paid over to the seller.
Texas: withholding until the comptroller's receipt or certificate
Texas uses a withholding rule like California's, and it is not limited to sales tax: when a person liable for an amount under the state-taxation title of the Tax Code sells the business or its stock of goods, or quits the business, the buyer must withhold enough of the purchase price to pay the amount due until the seller provides a receipt from the comptroller showing payment or a certificate that no amount is due. A buyer that fails to withhold is liable for the amount it should have withheld, up to the value of the purchase price.
The purchaser and seller jointly request clearance on Form 86-114. Under the statute, on the comptroller's form, the purchaser may ask for a certificate that no tax is due or a statement of the amount that must be paid first, and the comptroller must answer within 60 days after the request or after the seller's records are made available for audit, whichever is later, and in any case within 90 days of the request. If the comptroller does not mail the certificate or statement within that period, the purchaser is released from the obligation to withhold or pay. The limitation period for enforcing the buyer's obligation starts on the later of the sale or a determination against the seller, so the exposure can surface after closing.
Withholding does not cover every case. A separate section makes a person who acquires a business or its assets through a fraudulent transfer or sham transaction liable for all of the seller's tax, penalty and interest, and a transfer counts as one if the seller made it to evade or hinder collection of the tax or without receiving reasonably equivalent value. The two grounds are alternatives, so a reasonably equivalent price answers only the second; a transfer made to evade or hinder collection is covered whatever the price. Compliance with the withholding rule is not a defense to that liability when the amount withheld does not fully cover the seller's liability and the price was not reasonably equivalent to the value of the business.
Federal employment claims: notice and continuity
Claims under federal labor and employment statutes follow a different rule from the state-law exceptions. In Teed v. Thomas & Betts Power Solutions, L.L.C., the Seventh Circuit explained that courts apply a distinct federal standard to those statutes because successor liability will often be needed to achieve their goals, and it extended that standard to suits under the Fair Labor Standards Act. The buyer there knew of the workers' pending lawsuit when it bought the business at a receiver's auction, which the court counted in favor of liability, and the sale conditions that would have protected it under Wisconsin law did not control under the federal standard.
The Supreme Court applied successor liability under the National Labor Relations Act in Golden State Bottling Co. v. NLRB. It explained that when a new employer has acquired substantial assets of its predecessor and continued its business operations without interruption or substantial change, retained employees will view their job situations as essentially unaltered, and it stated that the Board's orders run to the bona fide purchaser as well as to an evader.
The Sixth Circuit applied the doctrine to Title VII discrimination claims in EEOC v. MacMillan Bloedel Containers, Inc., holding that Title VII does not prohibit the successor doctrine but mandates its application, while stressing that a successor's liability is not automatic and is decided case by case. It listed the factors courts weigh, starting with whether the successor had notice of the charge and whether the predecessor can provide relief, and continuing through continuity of operations, plant, work force, supervisors, jobs, equipment and product.
The Ninth Circuit held in Steinbach v. Hubbard that successor liability exists under the Fair Labor Standards Act, borrowing the standard from the labor cases, under which successor liability can attach when the buyer was a bona fide successor and had notice of the potential liability. Steinbach also shows the limit: the court found that a company exploring an acquisition was not a bona fide successor and not liable, because the arrangement was a temporary trial lease of the assets.
Notice is what lets a buyer protect itself. The Supreme Court in Golden State reasoned that because the successor must have notice before liability can be imposed, its potential liability can be reflected in the price it pays, or it can secure an indemnity clause in the sales contract. The Ninth Circuit in Steinbach gave the same reason for the notice requirement: it guarantees that a successor had an opportunity to negotiate a lower price or an indemnity clause. Diligence on pending charges, wage claims and suits is what gives a buyer that opportunity before the price is fixed.
The four common-law exceptions
The traditional rule, as the California Supreme Court described it in Ray v. Alad Corp., is that an asset purchaser does not assume the seller's liabilities unless one of four exceptions applies. The New York Court of Appeals states the same rule for tort claims: a corporation that purchases another corporation's assets is not liable for the seller's torts, subject to four exceptions. In Omnicare Pharmacy of Florida, LLC v. Lake City Nursing, LLC, an unreported 2026 ruling on a personal-jurisdiction motion, the Delaware Superior Court applied the same general rule and the same four exceptions: assumption, de facto merger or consolidation, mere continuation and fraud. Other states' versions of the rule need separate review; one federal appeals court has observed that many states have adopted rules expanding successor liability in products liability cases.
In California, Ray v. Alad Corp. also held that a party that acquires a manufacturing business and continues its product line, in the circumstances presented there, assumes strict tort liability for defects in units of that line the predecessor made; that product-line rule is a separate California doctrine for product claims, not a fifth general exception. Other states have declined to adopt it: the New York Court of Appeals rejected a product-line fifth exception in Semenetz v. Sherling & Walden, Inc., and the Wisconsin Supreme Court declined to adopt it in Fish v. Amsted Industries, Inc.
A governing-law clause in the purchase agreement does not necessarily decide which state's rule applies to a creditor's successor-liability claim: in Berg Chilling Systems, Inc. v. Hull Corp., the Third Circuit, applying Pennsylvania choice-of-law rules, held that the asset purchase agreement's choice-of-law provision should not apply to whether the transaction in fact constituted a merger.
The purchase agreement bears directly on the first exception, which turns on whether there was an express or implied agreement of assumption. One filed agreement states that the buyer will not assume any obligation or liability of the seller outside its definition of assumed liabilities. In Omnicare, the court held that the creditor had failed to establish that the new operators of the business expressly or impliedly assumed the old operators' liabilities. The same opinion states that courts narrowly construe the mere-continuation theory.
Indemnity and escrow
A seller indemnity for retained liabilities allocates the loss between the parties, but an unsecured indemnity from an individual seller who has spent the proceeds is worth far less than its face value. A holdback or escrow keeps part of the price available for those claims; one filed agreement held its escrow amount as security for the seller's indemnification obligations.
Sales tax exposure in stock deals
In a stock purchase the company keeps its past sales tax liabilities, so the buyer inherits them through the company it now owns: the company being acquired retains all of its liabilities as a matter of law. The state clearance procedures for asset buyers do not reach this case; New York's bulk-sale guidance gives the purchase of all of a corporation's stock as an example of a transaction that is not a bulk sale, because the company's assets have not been transferred.
The exposure has grown since 2018. In South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., the Supreme Court overruled its earlier decisions requiring a seller's physical presence in a state before the state could make it collect sales tax, and stated that physical presence is not necessary to create a substantial nexus. The South Dakota statute before the Court, as it stood in 2018, reached sellers delivering more than $100,000 of goods or services into the state or engaging in 200 or more separate transactions there each year.
Those 2018 figures are not today's rule everywhere. South Dakota dropped the 200-transaction test effective July 1, 2023, leaving only the $100,000 sales test. California applies a $500,000 test to sales of tangible personal property for delivery in the state in the preceding or current calendar year, New York has a business with no physical presence in the state check for more than $500,000 in sales of tangible personal property delivered in the state and more than 100 such sales over the preceding four sales tax quarters, and Texas excuses a remote seller with less than $500,000 of Texas revenue in the previous 12 months. The current threshold for any other state is on that state's revenue department guidance for remote sellers.
Sales tax diligence on a stock deal covers:
- Sales by state against each state's threshold. The count can include marketplace sales: Texas includes them in its $500,000 calculation even when the marketplace collects the tax.
- Registrations. The requirements and marketplace exceptions vary by state. In New York a business with no physical presence that meets the thresholds must register as a vendor, and in South Dakota a remote seller over the $100,000 test must be licensed; Texas does not require a permit from a remote seller selling only through a marketplace that has accepted in good faith the marketplace provider's certification that it will collect the tax, but a remote seller over the $500,000 threshold that also sells through its own website must collect tax on those website sales.
- Exemption and resale certificates. In New York, a seller that accepts a properly completed exemption certificate in good faith within 90 days need not collect the tax, and a seller that accepts one later shares the burden of proving the exemption and may be liable for the tax.
- Marketplace-facilitator sales. In Texas a marketplace provider is required to certify to the seller that it will collect the tax, and in New York the provider's obligation to collect applies whether or not the seller must register.
- The tax software's configuration, tested against what the target actually charged, since the failure alleged in the case discussed next was sales tax software that was not set up properly.
Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Investments, LLC (Del. Ch. 2021) shows how the problem surfaces after closing. The buyer of a company's stock sued the sellers for fraud, alleging that representations in the stock purchase agreement were known to be false when made. It alleged that the company had not been using its sales tax software properly and that significant state sales and use taxes went uncollected over several years, and that another bidder had put the exposure at $8 to 9 million and had asked for an escrow of at least $15 million or a price reduction. Those were allegations, and the decision came on the defendants' motion to dismiss, which the court denied. The agreement provided that all representations terminated at closing, but the court held that this survival clause did not defeat the buyer's claim that the representations were knowingly false.
For a small deal the case bears on drafting. The sellers relied on survival, anti-reliance and non-recourse provisions, and the court held that under Delaware law a party cannot invoke provisions of a contract it knew to be an instrument of fraud to avoid a claim grounded in that fraud. Where the agreement gives little or no indemnity, or only an unsecured indemnity from an individual seller, a claim that the representations were knowingly false may be the buyer's main recourse after closing, so the wording of those three clauses bears directly on what recourse remains.
Three protections respond to the exposure:
- A voluntary disclosure agreement. A target that finds unpaid tax before closing can come forward under a state program; in Texas, the agreement lets a taxpayer pay previously unpaid tax with relief from penalties and, in most cases, interest, the review is limited to four years except for tax collected and not remitted, and the program is closed to a business the comptroller has already contacted about the liability or notified of an audit. A business with exposure in several states can approach them together through the Multistate Tax Commission's National Nexus Program.
- A separate tax indemnity. One filed stock purchase agreement defines its Indemnified Taxes to include the company's unpaid pre-closing taxes and keeps the indemnity for them in force until 60 days after the limitation period for assessing or collecting those taxes expires, longer than its general representations survive.
- An escrow. Part of the price is held back against the exposure, as the other bidder in Online HealthNow had proposed.
Sources for this answer
The Delaware Superior Court stated the general rule that a buyer of assets is not liable for a seller's debts or tortious conduct.
As a general rule, a buyer of assets is not liable for a seller’s debts or tortious conduct.
See Omnicare Pharmacy of Fla., LLC v. Lake City Nursing, LLC, C.A. No. N25C-01-233 KMM (Del. Super. Ct. Aug. 31, 2026).
The Delaware Superior Court stated that the general rule does not apply where the buyer assumed the liability, there is a de facto merger or consolidation, the buyer is a mere continuation of the seller, or there was fraud in the transaction.
However, this general rule does not apply where (i) the buyer assumed the seller’s liability; (ii) there is a de facto merger or consolidation; (iii) the buyer is a mere continuation of the seller under a different name; or (iv) there was fraud in the transaction.
See Omnicare Pharmacy of Fla., LLC v. Lake City Nursing, LLC, C.A. No. N25C-01-233 KMM (Del. Super. Ct. Aug. 31, 2026).
The Third Circuit observed that many states have adopted rules expanding successor liability in products liability cases.
Additionally, many states have adopted rules expanding successor liability in products liability cases.
See Berg Chilling Sys., Inc. v. Hull Corp., 435 F.3d 455 (3d Cir. 2006).
The California Supreme Court described the traditional rule that an asset purchaser does not assume the seller's liabilities, with four listed exceptions.
As typically formulated the rule states that the purchaser does not assume the seller’s liabilities unless (1) there is an express or implied agreement of assumption, (2) the transaction amounts to a consolidation or merger of the two corporations, (3) the purchasing corporation is a mere continuation of the seller, or (4) the transfer of assets to the purchaser is for the fraudulent purpose of escaping liability for the seller’s debts.
See Ray v. Alad Corp., 19 Cal. 3d 22 (1977).
The California Supreme Court held that a party acquiring a manufacturing business and continuing its product line, in the circumstances presented, assumes strict tort liability for defects in units of that line previously made by the predecessor.
We therefore conclude that a party which acquires a manufacturing business and continues the output of its line of products under the circumstances here presented assumes strict tort liability for defects in units of the same product line previously manufactured and distributed by the entity from which the business was acquired.
See Ray v. Alad Corp., 19 Cal. 3d 22 (1977).
The New York Court of Appeals, restating the Schumacher rule, stated that a corporation that acquires another corporation's assets is generally not liable for the predecessor's torts, subject to four exceptions: express or implied assumption, consolidation or merger, mere continuation, and a fraudulent transaction to escape the obligations.
“while, in general, a corporation which acquires the assets of another is not liable for the torts of the predecessor corporation, there [are] exceptions to the rule.” These exceptions arise where a successor corporation “expressly or impliedly assume[s] [its] predecessor’s tort liability”; or “there [is] a consolidation or merger of seller and purchaser”; or “the purchasing corporation [is] a mere continuation of the selling corporation”; or “the transaction is entered into fraudulently to escape such obligations”
See Semenetz v. Sherling & Walden, Inc., 7 N.Y.3d 194, 198 (2006) (quoting Schumacher v. Richards Shear Co., 59 N.Y.2d 239, 245 (1983)).
The New York Court of Appeals declined to add the product-line exception as a fifth exception to the rule that an asset buyer is not liable for the seller's torts.
Plaintiff Bridget Semenetz asks us to revisit Schumacher to endorse a fifth exception — the “product line” exception in cases of strict products liability. For the reasons that follow, we reject the “product line” exception.
See Semenetz v. Sherling & Walden, Inc., 7 N.Y.3d 194 (2006).
The Wisconsin Supreme Court declined to adopt the product-line exception to the traditional rule of no successor corporation liability.
We decline to adopt the “product line” exception to the traditional rule of no successor corporation liability.
See Fish v. Amsted Indus., Inc., 126 Wis. 2d 293, 376 N.W.2d 820 (1985).
Applying Pennsylvania choice-of-law rules, the Third Circuit held that an asset purchase agreement's choice-of-law provision should not apply to whether the transaction in fact constituted a merger.
A de facto merger inquiry investigates whether a transaction labeled “Asset Purchase Agreement” in fact constituted a merger — a determination that does not arise purely from the agreement itself. Thus, SPI and Hull could not have controlled, through express contractual language, whether their agreement in fact constituted a merger. Though strict adherence solely to the Restatement might lead to a different result, under Pennsylvania’s flexible combination of Restatement and interest-based analysis, the contractual choice of law provision should not apply to the issue.
See Berg Chilling Sys., Inc. v. Hull Corp., 435 F.3d 455 (3d Cir. 2006).
The Grove agreement states that the buyer will not assume any seller obligation or liability outside its definition of assumed liabilities.
Buyer will not assume or have any responsibility, however, with respect to any other obligation or liability of Seller not included within the definition of Assumed Liabilities.
See §2.2(a)
The Delaware Superior Court held that the creditor failed to establish that the new operators expressly or impliedly assumed the old operators' liabilities.
Omnicare failed to establish that New Operators expressly or impliedly assumed the liabilities of Old Operators.
See Omnicare Pharmacy of Fla., LLC v. Lake City Nursing, LLC, C.A. No. N25C-01-233 KMM (Del. Super. Ct. Aug. 31, 2026).
The Delaware Superior Court stated that courts narrowly construe the mere-continuation theory.
Courts narrowly construe the mere continuation theory.
See Omnicare Pharmacy of Fla., LLC v. Lake City Nursing, LLC, C.A. No. N25C-01-233 KMM (Del. Super. Ct. Aug. 31, 2026).
New York requires a purchaser in a bulk sale of business assets to notify the tax authority at least ten days before taking possession or paying, whether or not taxes are known to be owed.
Whenever a person required to collect tax shall make a sale, transfer, or assignment in bulk of any part or the whole of his business assets, otherwise than in the ordinary course of business, the purchaser, transferee or assignee shall at least ten days before taking possession of the subject of said sale, transfer or assignment, or paying therefor, notify the tax commission by registered mail of the proposed sale and of the price, terms and conditions thereof whether or not the seller, transferrer or assignor, has represented to, or informed the purchaser, transferee or assignee that he owes any tax pursuant to this article, and whether or not the purchaser, transferee, or assignee has knowledge that such taxes are owing, and whether any such taxes are in fact owing.
See N.Y. Tax Law § 1141(c).
A New York bulk-sale purchaser that fails to comply is personally liable for the seller's sales taxes, limited to the higher of the purchase price or the fair market value of the assets.
For failure to comply with the provisions of this subdivision the purchaser, transferee or assignee, in addition to being subject to the liabilities and remedies imposed under the provisions of article six of the uniform commercial code, shall be personally liable for the payment to the state of any such taxes theretofore or thereafter determined to be due to the state from the seller, transferrer or assignor, except that the liability of the purchaser, transferee or assignee shall be limited to an amount not in excess of the purchase price or fair market value of the business assets sold, transferred or assigned to such purchaser, transferee, or assignee, whichever is higher, and such liability may be assessed and enforced in the same manner as the liability for tax under this article.
See N.Y. Tax Law § 1141(c).
Under New York Tax Law § 1141(c), if the purchaser fails to give the bulk-sale notice or the tax authority informs it that a possible tax claim exists, the consideration owed to the seller is subject to a first-priority lien for the seller's taxes and the purchaser may not transfer it to the seller to the extent of the state's claim.
Whenever the purchaser, transferee or assignee shall fail to give notice to the tax commission as required by the preceding paragraph, or whenever the tax commission shall inform the purchaser, transferee or assignee that a possible claim for such tax or taxes exists, any sums of money, property or choses in action, or other consideration, which the purchaser, transferee or assignee is required to transfer over to the seller, transferrer or assignor shall be subject to a first priority right and lien for any such taxes theretofore or thereafter determined to be due from the seller, transferrer or assignor to the state, and the purchaser, transferee or assignee is forbidden to transfer to the seller, transferrer or assignor any such sums of money, property or choses in action to the extent of the amount of the state's claim.
See N.Y. Tax Law § 1141(c).
Under New York Tax Law § 1141(c), the tax authority must state the amount of tax it claims within ninety days of receiving the bulk-sale notice, and its failure to do so releases the purchaser from any further obligation to withhold.
Within ninety days of receipt of the notice of the sale, transfer, or assignment from the purchaser, transferee or assignee, the tax commission shall give notice to the purchaser, transferee or assignee and to the seller, transferrer, or assignor of the total amount of any tax or taxes which the state claims to be due from the seller, transferrer, or assignor to the state, and whenever the tax commission shall fail to give such notice to the purchaser, transferee, or assignee and the seller, transferrer, or assignor within ninety days from receipt of notice of the sale, transfer, or assignment, such failure will release the purchaser, transferee or assignee from any further obligation to withhold any sums of money, property or choses in action, or other consideration, which the purchaser, transferee or assignee is required to transfer over to the seller, transferrer or assignor, except that with respect to pending matters such ninety day periods shall not begin to run until ninety days after the effective date of this provision.
See N.Y. Tax Law § 1141(c).
California requires a buyer of a business or stock of goods to withhold enough of the price to cover the seller's sales or use tax until the seller produces a receipt or no-tax-due certificate.
If any person liable for any amount under this part sells out his business or stock of goods or quits the business, his successors or assigns shall withhold sufficient of the purchase price to cover such amount until the former owner produces a receipt from the board showing that it has been paid or a certificate stating that no amount is due.
See Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code § 6811.
A California purchaser that fails to withhold becomes personally liable for the amount it should have withheld, up to the purchase price.
(a) If the purchaser of a business or stock of goods fails to withhold from the purchase price as required, he or she becomes personally liable for the payment of the amount required to be withheld by him or her to the extent of the purchase price, valued in money.
See Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code § 6812(a).
Conor Meyers observes that an unsecured indemnity from an individual seller who has spent the proceeds is worth far less than its face value.
Where the seller is an individual who will have spent the proceeds, an unsecured indemnity is worth far less than its face value.
See Conor Meyers, Reps and Warranties in a Business Sale, Clark Meyers (Aug. 21, 2026).
The Luna agreement held its escrow amount as security for the seller’s indemnification obligations.
The Escrow Amount delivered by Buyer at Closing pursuant to the Escrow Agreement shall be held in an escrow account and shall serve as security for payment of any indemnification obligations of Seller (the “Escrow Fund”).
See §2.10
Texas Tax Code § 111.020, in the state-taxation title, requires the buyer of a business or its stock of goods to withhold enough of the price to pay what the seller owes under that title until the seller provides a comptroller receipt or no-amount-due certificate, and makes a buyer that fails to withhold liable for the amount up to the value of the purchase price.
(a) If a person who is liable for the payment of an amount under this title sells the business or the stock of goods of the business or quits the business, the successor to the seller or the seller's assignee shall withhold an amount of the purchase price sufficient to pay the amount due until the seller provides a receipt from the comptroller showing that the amount has been paid or a certificate stating that no amount is due. (b) The purchaser of a business or stock of goods who fails to withhold an amount of the purchase price as required by this section is liable for the amount required to be withheld to the extent of the value of the purchase price.
See Tex. Tax Code § 111.020(a)–(b).
Texas Tax Code § 111.020(c) lets the purchaser of a business ask the comptroller for a no-tax-due certificate or a statement of the amount to be paid, and requires the comptroller to answer within 60 days after the request or after the seller's records are made available for audit, whichever is later, and in any event within 90 days of the request.
(c) The purchaser of a business may request, on an affidavit or other form prescribed by the comptroller, that the comptroller issue a certificate stating that no tax is due or issue a statement of the amount required to be paid before a certificate may be issued. The comptroller shall issue the certificate or statement within 60 days after receiving the request or within 60 days after the day on which the records of the former owner of the business are made available for audit, whichever period expires later, but in either event the comptroller shall issue the certificate or statement within 90 days after the date of receiving the request.
See Tex. Tax Code § 111.020(c).
Texas Tax Code § 111.020(d) releases the purchaser from the obligation to withhold or pay if the comptroller fails to mail the certificate or statement within the statutory period.
(d) If the comptroller fails to mail the certificate or statement within the applicable period provided by Subsection (c) of this section, the purchaser is released from the obligation to withhold the purchase price or pay the amount due.
See Tex. Tax Code § 111.020(d).
Under Texas Tax Code § 111.020(e), the limitation period for enforcing the purchaser's obligation begins on the later of the sale or a determination against the former owner.
(e) A period of limitation during which the obligation of a purchaser under this section may be enforced begins when the former owner of the business sells the business or stock of goods or when a determination is made against the former owner, whichever event occurs later.
See Tex. Tax Code § 111.020(e).
Under Texas Tax Code § 111.020(f), withholding is not a defense to fraudulent-transfer liability under § 111.024 when the amount withheld does not fully cover the seller's liability and the price was not reasonably equivalent to the value of the business or stock of goods.
(f) Compliance with Subsection (a) is not a defense to an assessment of tax liability under Section 111.024 if: (1) the amount withheld from the purchase price is not sufficient to fully satisfy the liability of the seller of the business or stock of goods; and (2) the purchase price paid to the seller for the business or stock of goods is not reasonably equivalent to the value of the business or stock of goods.
See Tex. Tax Code § 111.020(f).
Texas Tax Code § 111.024 makes a person who acquires a business or its assets through a fraudulent transfer or sham transaction liable for the seller's tax, penalty and interest, and treats a transfer as one if the seller made it to evade or hinder tax collection or without receiving reasonably equivalent value.
(a) A person who acquires a business or the assets of a business from a taxpayer through a fraudulent transfer or a sham transaction is liable for any tax, penalty, and interest owed by the taxpayer. (b) A transfer of a business or the assets of a business is considered to be a fraudulent transfer or a sham transaction if the taxpayer made the transfer or undertook the transaction: (1) with intent to evade, hinder, delay, or prevent the collection of any tax, penalty, or interest owed under this title; or (2) without receiving a reasonably equivalent value in exchange for the business or business assets subject to the transfer or transaction.
See Tex. Tax Code § 111.024(a)–(b).
The Seventh Circuit explained that a distinct federal successor-liability standard applies to federal labor and employment statutes because successor liability will often be necessary to achieve their goals, and extended that logic to Fair Labor Standards Act suits.
The idea behind having a distinct federal standard applicable to federal labor and employment statutes is that these statutes are intended either to foster labor peace, as in the National Labor Relations Act, or to protect workers’ rights, as in Title VII, and that in either type of case the imposition of successor liability will often be necessary to achieve the statutory goals because the workers will often be unable to head off a corporate sale by their employer aimed at extinguishing the employer’s liability to them. This logic extends to suits to enforce the Fair Labor Standards Act.
See Teed v. Thomas & Betts Power Sols., L.L.C., 711 F.3d 763 (7th Cir. 2013).
The Seventh Circuit stated that the sale conditions limiting the buyer's liabilities would have protected it under Wisconsin law but do not control when the federal standard applies.
If Wisconsin state law governed the issue of successor liability, Thomas & Betts would be off the hook because of the conditions. But as we said, they do not control, or even figure, when the federal standard applies.
See Teed v. Thomas & Betts Power Sols., L.L.C., 711 F.3d 763 (7th Cir. 2013).
The Seventh Circuit treated the buyer's notice of the pending lawsuit when it bought the business at a receiver's auction as a factor favoring successor liability.
(1) Whether the successor had notice of the pending lawsuit, which Thomas & Betts unquestionably had when it bought Packard at the receiver’s auction; this is a factor favoring successor liability.
See Teed v. Thomas & Betts Power Sols., L.L.C., 711 F.3d 763 (7th Cir. 2013).
The Supreme Court explained that when a new employer acquires substantial assets of its predecessor and continues its business operations without interruption or substantial change, retained employees will view their job situations as essentially unaltered.
When a new employer, such as All American, has acquired substantial assets of its predecessor and continued, without interruption or substantial change, the predecessor’s business operations, those employees who have been retained will understandably view their job situations as essentially unaltered.
See Golden State Bottling Co. v. NLRB, 414 U.S. 168, 184 (1973).
The Supreme Court stated that National Labor Relations Board orders run to the bona fide purchaser of a business as well as to an evader, because the Board must effectuate the policies of the Act.
The Board’s orders run to the evader and the bona fide purchaser, not because the act of evasion or the bona fide purchase is an unfair labor practice, but because the Board is obligated to effectuate the policies of the Act.
See Golden State Bottling Co. v. NLRB, 414 U.S. 168, 177 (1973).
The Supreme Court reasoned that because a successor must have notice before liability is imposed, its potential liability can be reflected in the price it pays or covered by an indemnity clause in the sales contract.
Since the successor must have notice before liability can be imposed, “his potential liability for remedying the unfair labor practices is a matter which can be reflected in the price he pays for the business, or he may secure an indemnity clause in the sales contract which will indemnify him for liability arising from the seller’s unfair labor practices.”
See Golden State Bottling Co. v. NLRB, 414 U.S. 168, 185 (1973) (quoting Perma Vinyl Corp., 164 N.L.R.B. 968, 969 (1967)).
The Sixth Circuit held that Title VII does not prohibit but mandates application of the successor doctrine, while stating that a successor's liability is not automatic and is determined case by case.
We emphasize that the liability of a successor is not automatic, but must be determined on a case by case basis. We hold only that Title VII per se does not prohibit the application of the successor doctrine; but rather mandates its application.
See EEOC v. MacMillan Bloedel Containers, Inc., 503 F.2d 1086, 1091 (6th Cir. 1974).
The Sixth Circuit listed the factors relevant to successorship, from notice of the charge and the predecessor's ability to provide relief through continuity of operations, plant, work force, supervisors, jobs, equipment and product.
These include: 1) whether the successor company had notice of the charge, 2) the ability of the predecessor to provide relief, 3) whether there has been a substantial continuity of business operations, 4) whether the new employer uses the same plant, 5) whether he uses the same or substantially the same work force, 6) whether he uses the same or substantially the same supervisory personnel, 7) whether the same jobs exist under substantially the same working conditions, 8) whether he uses the same machinery, equipment and methods of production and 9) whether he produces the same product.
See EEOC v. MacMillan Bloedel Containers, Inc., 503 F.2d 1086, 1094 (6th Cir. 1974).
The Ninth Circuit held that successor liability exists under the Fair Labor Standards Act but found that a company exploring an acquisition of the business was not a bona fide successor and not liable.
We hold that successorship liability exists under the Fair Labor Standards Act. On the facts of this case, however, we conclude that Care's dipping its toe in the water and exploring the acquisition of Hubbard does not make it a bona fide successor. Considering all the equities, we find Care not liable.
See Steinbach v. Hubbard, 51 F.3d 843 (9th Cir. 1995).
The Ninth Circuit found no successor liability because the arrangement involved a temporary trial lease of assets.
Because the arrangement involved a temporary trial lease of assets, FLSA's policies would best be promoted by finding no liability.
See Steinbach v. Hubbard, 51 F.3d 843 (9th Cir. 1995).
The Ninth Circuit adopted for Fair Labor Standards Act claims the labor-law standard under which successor liability can attach when the later employer was a bona fide successor and had notice of the potential liability.
We borrow as well the same basic standards used in these other employment contexts. Under the NLRA, successor liability can attach when 1) the subsequent employer was a bona fide successor and 2) the subsequent employer had notice of the potential liability.
See Steinbach v. Hubbard, 51 F.3d 843 (9th Cir. 1995).
The Ninth Circuit stated that the notice requirement ensures a successor had an opportunity to protect against liability by negotiating a lower price or an indemnity clause.
The principle reason for the notice requirement is to ensure fairness by guaranteeing that a successor had an opportunity to protect against liability by negotiating a lower price or indemnity clause.
See Steinbach v. Hubbard, 51 F.3d 843 (9th Cir. 1995).
California's successor-liability regulation releases a purchaser from further obligation to withhold if it obtains a no-tax-due certificate, or if it makes a written request for a certificate and the agency does not issue it or mail a notice of the amount due within 60 days after the latest of the agency's receipt of the request, the date of sale, or the date the former owner's records are made available for audit.
The purchaser of the business or stock of goods will be released from further obligation to withhold the purchase price if he obtains a certificate from the board stating that no taxes, interest, or penalties are due from a predecessor. He will also be released if he makes a written request to the board for a certificate and if the board does not issue the certificate or mail to the purchaser a notice of the amount of the tax, interest, and penalties that must be paid as a condition of issuing the certificate within 60 days after the latest of the following dates: (1) The date the board receives a written request from the purchaser for a certificate. (2) The date of the sale of the business or stock of goods. (3) The date the former owner's records are made available for audit.
See Cal. Code Regs. tit. 18, § 1702(c).
California's successor-liability regulation states that, in cases of doubt as to possible liability, the purchaser should obtain a certificate.
In cases of doubt as to possible liability, the purchaser should obtain a certificate as provided in subdivision (c) above.
See Cal. Code Regs. tit. 18, § 1702(f).
The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration explains that buyers can be held responsible for a seller's unpaid taxes unless a tax clearance certificate is obtained.
Understanding a successor’s liability, where buyers can be held responsible for a seller’s unpaid taxes unless a tax clearance certificate is obtained.
See Cal. Dep't of Tax & Fee Admin., Publication 74, Closing Out Your Account (rev. Apr. 2026).
New York's Tax Department states that a purchaser notifies it of a pending bulk sale by filing Form AU-196.10 at least 10 days before paying for or taking possession of any business assets, whichever happens first.
A purchaser must notify the Tax Department of a pending bulk sale by filing Form AU-196.10, Notification of Sale, Transfer, or Assignment in Bulk, at least 10 days before paying for or taking possession of any business assets, whichever happens first.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Bulk Sales, TB-ST-70 (June 24, 2013).
New York's Tax Department states that within five business days after receiving Form AU-196.10 it issues the purchaser either a release on Form AU-197.1 or a notice of claim on Form AU-196.2.
Within five (5) business days after receiving Form AU-196.10, the Tax Department will issue the purchaser either: - Form AU-197.1, Purchaser’s and/or Escrow Agent’s Release - Bulk Sale, if the seller does not have any unpaid sales taxes and an additional review or audit is not necessary; or - Form AU-196.2, Notice of Claim to Purchaser, if the seller owes unpaid sales tax, is scheduled for a review, or is under audit.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Bulk Sales, TB-ST-70 (June 24, 2013).
New York's Tax Department states that the purchaser is not liable for the seller's unpaid sales and use taxes and may pay the full price if the department fails to issue a notice of claim within five business days after receiving a properly completed and timely filed Form AU-196.10.
The purchaser will not be held liable for any of the seller’s unpaid sales and use taxes and may pay the seller the full purchase price if the Tax Department: - fails to issue the purchaser Form AU-196.2 within five (5) business days after receipt of a properly completed and timely filed Form AU-196.10; or - incorrectly sends the purchaser Form AU-197.1 stating that the seller has no outstanding liability.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Bulk Sales, TB-ST-70 (June 24, 2013).
New York's Tax Department notes that, whichever form the purchaser receives, the assets bought from the seller may still be subject to the department's liens if there are outstanding warrants or judgments against the seller.
Note: Whether a purchaser receives Form AU-197.1 or AU-196.2 from the Tax Department, the assets purchased from the seller may still be subject to the department’s liens if there are outstanding warrants or judgments against the seller for past unpaid taxes.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Bulk Sales, TB-ST-70 (June 24, 2013).
New York's Tax Department gives the purchase of all of a corporation's stock as an example of a transaction that is not a bulk sale, because the corporation's business assets have not been transferred.
Example: Corporation A purchases all the issued and outstanding stock of Corporation B, which is required to collect sales tax. Corporation A and Corporation B will continue to exist as separate legal entities. Since the business assets of Corporation B have not been transferred in connection with the sale of its stock, this is not a bulk sale.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Bulk Sales, TB-ST-70 (June 24, 2013).
The Texas Comptroller states that, after Senate Bill 873 (2021), the seller and purchaser must jointly submit Form 86-114, Joint Request for Certificate of No Tax Due.
Due to changes made by Senate Bill 873, 87th Session, 2021, the seller and purchaser of the business or assets must jointly submit Form 86-114, Joint Request for Certificate of No Tax Due (PDF).
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Publication 98-117, Buying an Existing Business (Nov. 2024).
The Texas Comptroller states that a purchaser who closes without a Certificate of No Tax Due is liable for the seller's unpaid taxes up to the purchase price, and that the certificate must be requested before the sale closes to absolve the purchaser.
If the current business owner owes taxes and escrow closes without a Certificate of No Tax Due, the purchaser is liable for the unpaid taxes up to the purchase price for the business, including any assumption of indebtedness. The Certificate of No Tax Due must be requested before the sale closes in order to absolve the purchaser of liability.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Publication 98-117, Buying an Existing Business (Nov. 2024).
The Texas Comptroller states that a request can take up to 90 days if an audit is necessary, and that otherwise the certificate or statement of account is usually issued within 10 business days of a proper request.
Processing a request for the Certificate of No Tax Due can take up to 90 days if an audit of the seller’s books and records is necessary. If an audit is not required, the Certificate of No Tax Due or Statement of Account listing the amounts owed is usually issued within 10 business days from the date of receiving a proper request on Form 86-114, Joint Request for Certificate of No Tax Due (PDF).
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Publication 98-117, Buying an Existing Business (Nov. 2024).
Kahn, Dees, Donovan & Kahn explains that a stock buyer acquires the company as an entity and so assumes its liabilities, which the company retains as a matter of law.
In a stock purchase, the buyer purchases the target company as an entity, and therefore assumes the seller’s liabilities, since the company being acquired retains all of its liabilities as a matter of law. By restructuring the transaction as an asset purchase rather than a stock purchase, a buyer is provided with a much greater level of protection against liability for the target company’s obligations.
See Jeffrey K. Helfrich, Successor Liability in the Purchase of a Business: Express or Implied Assumption of Obligations (Part 1 of 8), Kahn, Dees, Donovan & Kahn, LLP (May 5, 2015).
The Supreme Court held that the physical presence rule of Quill is unsound and incorrect and overruled Quill and National Bellas Hess.
For these reasons, the Court concludes that the physical presence rule of Quill is unsound and incorrect. The Court’s decisions in Quill Corp. v. North Dakota, 504 U. S. 298 (1992), and National Bellas Hess, Inc. v. Department of Revenue of Ill., 386 U. S. 753 (1967), should be, and now are, overruled.
See South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., 585 U.S. 162 (2018).
The Supreme Court held that the nexus was sufficient based on the sellers' economic and virtual contacts with South Dakota, where the law applied only to sellers delivering more than $100,000 of goods or services into the state or engaging in 200 or more separate transactions there annually.
Here, the nexus is clearly sufficient based on both the economic and virtual contacts respondents have with the State. The Act applies only to sellers that deliver more than $100,000 of goods or services into South Dakota or engage in 200 or more separate transactions for the delivery of goods and services into the State on an annual basis.
See South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., 585 U.S. 162 (2018).
The Supreme Court stated that physical presence is not necessary to create a substantial nexus.
Physical presence is not necessary to create a substantial nexus.
See South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., 585 U.S. 162 (2018).
The Court of Chancery described the buyer's fraud claims as arising from representations and warranties in a stock purchase agreement that allegedly were known to be false when made.
Plaintiffs, Online HealthNow, Inc. (“OHN”) and Bertelsmann, Inc. (“Bertelsmann” or the “Buyer”), bring fraud and related claims against Defendants, CIP Capital Fund, L.P. (“CIP Capital”), its holding company CIP OCL Investments, LLC (“CIP OCL” or the “Seller”) and its beneficial owners and agents, arising from representations and warranties within a Stock Purchase Agreement (“SPA”) that allegedly were known to be false when made.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Court of Chancery recited the allegation that the company discovered it was not using its sales tax software properly, including by failing to connect it to entire subsidiaries' sales platforms and by mis-coding products.
As early as June 2015, OCL discovered that it was not using Avalara properly (the “Avalara Issue”), including by failing to: (1) connect AvaTax to the online sales platforms of entire subsidiaries and product lines of OCL; (2) track inventory by improperly assigning SKUs to thousands of products sold by OCL, which was not charging sales tax to the purchaser of the products, regardless of applicable tax laws; and (3) properly code products with SKUs in the Avalara system for purposes of identifying and collecting applicable state sales and use taxes from its customers.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Court of Chancery recited the allegation that the software problems resulted in significant state sales and use taxes not being collected or remitted over several years.
These miscues resulted in significant state sales and use taxes that were not collected and/or remitted over a period of several years.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Court of Chancery recited the allegation that another bidder told the sellers it estimated the company's sales and use tax exposure at $8 to 9 million.
With this information in hand, the other bidder informed the CIP Working Group, including Lipton, Formica, Sheahan and Wilson, that it estimated OCL’s sales and use tax liability exposure to be in the range of $8–9 million.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Court of Chancery recited the allegation that the other bidder required either a one-year escrow of at least $15 million for the sales and use tax liability or a price reduction based on the final tax analysis.
Consequently, as a condition to pursuing the acquisition further, the other bidder required either a substantial one-year escrow of at least $15 million for OCL’s sales and use tax liability, or a reduction in the purchase price based on Thompson Tax’s final analysis of the full scope of OCL’s sales and use tax liability in the pre-closing period.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Court of Chancery denied the defendants' motion to dismiss.
For reasons explained below, Defendants’ motion to dismiss must be denied.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Court of Chancery described the agreement's survival clause, under which all representations and warranties terminated at closing and did not survive it for any purpose.
In Section 10.1 (the “survival clause”), the parties agreed that all representations and warranties in the agreement “terminate effective as of the Closing and shall not survive the Closing for any purpose, and thereafter there shall be no liability on the part of” any party involved in the sale.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Court of Chancery held that the survival clause cannot, and does not, defeat the buyer's contractual fraud claims.
Based on the weight of authority, and Delaware’s public policy, I am satisfied that the SPA’s survival clause cannot, and does not, defeat Plaintiffs’ contractual fraud claims.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Texas Comptroller states that a voluntary disclosure agreement lets a taxpayer pay previously unpaid taxes voluntarily, with relief from penalties and, in most cases, interest.
The program provides a taxpayer with the opportunity to pay these taxes voluntarily, with relief from penalties and, in most cases, from interest.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Publication 96-576, Voluntary Disclosure Program (Aug. 2026).
The Texas Comptroller limits its review under a voluntary disclosure agreement to reports due in the four years before the business first contacts it, with no limit for taxes collected and not remitted.
The Comptroller’s office will limit its review to reports due four years from the date the business initially contacts us. However, there is no limit on the lookback period for taxes collected and not remitted to the Comptroller’s office.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Publication 96-576, Voluntary Disclosure Program (Aug. 2026).
The Texas Comptroller states that a business qualifies for a voluntary disclosure agreement only if it has not previously been contacted about the liability and has not received notice of an audit or examination.
A business qualifies if - it has any liability for a tax or fee administered by the Comptroller’s office, other than taxes collected under the International Fuel Tax Agreement (IFTA); - it has not been previously contacted by the Comptroller, either verbally or in writing, concerning a liability or estimated liability; and - it has not received a notification of an audit or examination.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Publication 96-576, Voluntary Disclosure Program (Aug. 2026).
A filed stock purchase agreement defines Indemnified Taxes to include the company's pre-closing taxes that were not taken into account in closing indebtedness and not otherwise paid, and taxes imposed on the company as a transferee or successor for pre-closing transactions.
(bbb) “Indemnified Taxes” means any and all liabilities for Taxes (i) that are Pre-Closing Taxes that have not been taken into account in determining Closing Indebtedness and have not been paid in accordance with Section 5.3(a)(iii), (ii) of any member of an affiliated, consolidated, combined or unitary group of which the Company or any Subsidiary is or was a member on or prior to the Closing Date (which shall, for the avoidance of doubt, include the Seller and Parent for Indian tax purposes), including pursuant to Treasury Regulation Section 1.1502-6 or any analogous or similar state, local or foreign law or regulation, and (iii) of any person if such liability for Taxes is imposed on the Company or any of its Subsidiaries (as determined prior to the Closing) for any period as a transferee or successor in respect of a transaction occurring on or before the Closing Date, by contract, operation of law or otherwise.
See §7.1(bbb)
The same agreement has general representations survive 18 months but keeps the obligation to indemnify for Indemnified Taxes in force until 60 days after the applicable statute of limitations expires.
The parties hereto, intending to modify any applicable statute of limitations, agree that (i) the representations and warranties of the Company, the Seller, and the Buyer contained in this Agreement (other than the Fundamental Representations, the Buyer Fundamental Representations and the Tax Representations) or in any schedule, exhibit or certificate attached hereto or delivered pursuant to this Agreement shall survive the Closing until the date that is eighteen (18) months following the Closing Date and shall not survive such date for any purpose; (ii) the Fundamental Representations and the Buyer Fundamental Representations shall survive the Closing until the date that is twenty four (24) months following the Closing Date and shall not survive such date for any purpose, except that the Tax Representations and the obligation to indemnify for Indemnified Taxes hereunder shall survive the Closing until 60 days after the expiration of the statute of limitations applicable to the assessment of the relevant Taxes or their collection;
See §6.1
The South Dakota Department of Revenue states that, effective July 1, 2023, the remote seller criteria no longer include the 200-transaction threshold, and only remote sellers with more than $100,000 in South Dakota gross sales in the previous or current calendar year must be licensed and remit sales tax.
Effective July 1, 2023, the remote seller registration criteria no longer includes the 200 or more transactions threshold. Only remote sellers with more than $100,000 in gross sales in South Dakota in the previous or current calendar year are required to be licensed and remit South Dakota sales tax.
See S.D. Dep't of Revenue, 2023 Legislative Updates (SB 30).
The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration states that, from April 1, 2019, a retailer whose sales of tangible personal property for delivery in California meet the $500,000 threshold in the preceding or current calendar year must register, collect use tax and pay it to the agency.
Accordingly, operative April 1, 2019, any retailer whose sales of tangible personal property for delivery in California meet the $500,000 sales threshold in the preceding or current calendar year is a retailer engaged in business in the state. As such, these retailers are required to register with CDTFA, collect California state use tax, and report and pay the tax to CDTFA.
See Cal. Dep't of Tax & Fee Admin., Use Tax Collection Requirements Based on Sales into California Due to the Wayfair Decision: General Information.
New York's Tax Department states that a business with no physical presence in the state determines whether it must register by checking for more than $500,000 in sales of tangible personal property delivered in the state and more than 100 such sales in the preceding four sales tax quarters.
To determine if you are required to register, see if you had more than $500,000 in sales of tangible personal property delivered in the state and conducted more than 100 sales of tangible personal property delivered in the state in the immediately preceding four sales tax quarters.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Registration Requirement for Businesses with No Physical Presence in New York State (accessed Nov. 14, 2026).
New York's Tax Department states that a business with no physical presence in the state that meets the thresholds must register as a New York State vendor.
Therefore, a business that has no physical presence in New York State but meets the requirements outlined above must register as a New York State vendor.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Registration Requirement for Businesses with No Physical Presence in New York State (accessed Nov. 14, 2026).
The Texas Comptroller states that a remote seller need not obtain a permit and collect use tax if its total Texas revenue is less than $500,000 in the previous 12 calendar months.
The safe harbor provision provides that a remote seller is not required to obtain a tax permit and collect use tax, if its total Texas revenue is less than $500,000 in the previous 12 calendar months.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Remote Sellers and Marketplace Frequently Asked Questions (accessed Nov. 14, 2026).
The Texas Comptroller states that, from April 1, 2020, a remote seller includes all sales in the safe harbor calculation, including marketplace sales, even if the marketplace provider collects and remits the tax.
Yes. As of April 1, 2020, you must include all sales in the safe harbor calculation, including marketplace sales, even if the marketplace provider is collecting and remitting the sales tax.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Remote Sellers and Marketplace Frequently Asked Questions (accessed Nov. 14, 2026).
The Texas Comptroller states that a marketplace provider is required to certify to the seller that it will collect sales and use tax.
A marketplace provider is required to certify to you that it will collect sales and use tax.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Remote Sellers and Marketplace Frequently Asked Questions (accessed Nov. 14, 2026).
New York's Tax Department states that a marketplace provider's obligation to collect sales tax applies regardless of whether the marketplace seller is required to register.
A marketplace provider’s obligation to collect New York State and local sales tax applies regardless of whether the marketplace seller is required to register for sales tax purposes.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Sales Tax Requirements for Marketplace Providers (accessed Nov. 14, 2026).
New York's Tax Department states that a seller need not collect sales tax from a purchaser who furnishes a properly completed exemption certificate that the seller accepts in good faith within 90 days of the sale.
You are not required to collect sales tax from a purchaser who furnishes you with a properly completed exemption certificate that you accept in good faith within 90 days of the delivery of property or rendition of a service.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Publication 750, A Guide to Sales Tax in New York State (11/15).
New York's Tax Department states that if a seller accepts an exemption certificate after 90 days, the seller and purchaser share the burden of proving the exemption and both may be liable for the tax, penalties and interest if the sale is taxable.
If you accept a certificate after 90 days, both you and the purchaser share the burden of proving that the sale was exempt, and additional substantiation may be required. Also, both you and the purchaser may be liable for any tax, penalties, and interest due in the event the sale is determined to be taxable.
See N.Y. Dep't of Tax'n & Fin., Publication 750, A Guide to Sales Tax in New York State (11/15).
The Texas Comptroller notes that multistate businesses wishing to approach several states at once may use the Multistate Tax Commission's National Nexus Program.
Multistate businesses who wish to approach several states simultaneously may choose to use the services of the National Nexus Program of the Multistate Tax Commission even if the business has unreported or underpaid taxes in multiple states.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Publication 96-576, Voluntary Disclosure Program (Aug. 2026).
The Court of Chancery described the stock purchase agreement's survival, anti-reliance and non-recourse provisions, which the buyer argued were unenforceable as a matter of Delaware law and public policy.
While the SPA contains remarkably robust survival, anti-reliance and non-recourse provisions that appear to atomize Plaintiffs’ claims across all of the recognized planes of contractual limitations, invoking ABRY Partners and its progeny, Plaintiffs maintain these provisions are unenforceable as a matter of Delaware law and public policy.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Court of Chancery stated that under Delaware law a party cannot invoke provisions of a contract it knew to be an instrument of fraud to avoid a claim grounded in that same contractual fraud.
Under Delaware law, a party cannot invoke provisions of a contract it knew to be an instrument of fraud as a means to avoid a claim grounded in that very same contractual fraud.
See Online HealthNow, Inc. v. CIP OCL Invs., LLC, C.A. No. 2020-0654-JRS (Del. Ch. Aug. 12, 2021).
The Texas Comptroller, answering whether a remote seller that only sells through a marketplace needs a permit, states that it does not need one if it has received and accepted in good faith a certification that the marketplace provider will collect sales and use tax, but must keep records of marketplace sales for at least four years.
No. You do not need a permit if you have received and accepted in good faith a certification that the marketplace provider will collect sales and use tax. However, you must retain required records of all marketplace sales for at least four years.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Remote Sellers and Marketplace Frequently Asked Questions (accessed Nov. 14, 2026).
The Texas Comptroller's example states that a remote seller whose combined website and marketplace sales into Texas exceed the safe harbor must collect and remit tax on its website sales, while the marketplace providers collect on marketplace sales.
For example, during a 12-month period, a remote seller makes $300,000 in total sales into Texas through its website and $300,000 in sales through multiple marketplaces that certify they are collecting and remitting the tax. Because the combined total sales is $600,000, the remote seller is not covered by the safe harbor provision and is required to collect and remit tax for Texas sales made through its website. The marketplace providers are responsible for collecting and remitting tax on sales made through a marketplace.
See Tex. Comptroller of Pub. Accounts, Remote Sellers and Marketplace Frequently Asked Questions (accessed Nov. 14, 2026).
Should the company owner sign as well as the company?
When the owner of a selling company personally holds a U.S. copyright used in the business, 17 U.S.C. § 204(a) requires a transfer of that copyright, other than by operation of law, to be in a writing signed by that owner or the owner's authorized agent.
The company signs as seller of the assets it owns, and the intellectual-property conveyances can be made in separate short-form assignments, as in two filed asset purchase agreements that called for separate trademark and copyright assignments at closing alongside the bill of sale. On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group.
Recording the short form protects the buyer against a later purchaser who takes without notice: a patent assignment is void against a later purchaser or mortgagee for value without notice unless it is recorded in the Patent and Trademark Office within three months from its date or before the later purchase or mortgage. A trademark assignment is void against a later purchaser for value without notice unless the prescribed information is recorded in the Patent and Trademark Office within 3 months after the assignment or before the later purchase. Copyright transfers are recorded in the Copyright Office instead, and between two conflicting transfers the one executed first prevails if it is recorded within one month after execution in the United States, two months if executed abroad, or at any time before the later transfer is recorded. Recording in the Copyright Office gives constructive notice only if the document identifies the work and the work has been registered.
Patent and trademark assignment records at the Patent and Trademark Office are open to public inspection, On a touch screen, a tap shows all 2 sources in this group. and so are the Copyright Office's records of recorded documents.
Under Delaware law, a member of a limited liability company is not personally obligated for the company's debts, obligations and liabilities solely by reason of being a member, but a member may agree, in the LLC agreement or another agreement, to be personally obligated for any or all of them. An owner can therefore join only for purposes of named sections, as the selling company's shareholder did in one filed agreement by becoming a party solely for purposes of one section, under which he indemnified the buyer for breaches of two listed seller representations and for fraud. In another, an individual agreed that, solely for purposes of three listed sections, he would be treated as a shareholder and bound by a shareholder's obligations under them.
An owner can also join to give a seller restrictive covenant, as in one filed agreement that required non-competition agreements executed by each of the selling parties at closing. Evidence that the company authorized the sale belongs in the closing deliverables; one filed agreement required a secretary's certificate attaching the board and shareholder resolutions approving the agreement, and the owner-approval question covers whether the owners' approval is legally required.
In a stock or membership-interest purchase, by contrast, the buyer buys the owners' shares in the corporation or limited liability company, so each owner sells its own interest; the structure question compares the two.
Sources for this answer
Section 204(a) requires a signed writing for a copyright ownership transfer other than by operation of law.
A transfer of copyright ownership, other than by operation of law, is not valid unless an instrument of conveyance, or a note or memorandum of the transfer, is in writing and signed by the owner of the rights conveyed or such owner’s duly authorized agent.
See 17 U.S.C. §204(a)
The Grove agreement required the selling parties to deliver at closing a bill of sale and assignment and separate assignments of patents, trademarks and copyrights.
The Selling Parties shall deliver to the Buyer: (i) A Bill of Sale and Assignment in the form of Exhibit E executed by Seller; and (ii) An Assignment of Patents, Assignment of Servicemarks and Trademarks and Assignment of Copyrights in the form of Exhibits F-1, F-2 and F-3 executed by Seller; and (iii) Non-Competition Agreements in the form of Exhibit G (the "Selling Parties’ Non-Competition Agreements") executed by each of the Selling Parties;
See §2.5(a)
The Greenfield Online agreement listed an assignment and bill of sale, an assignment of trademarks and an assignment of copyrights among the closing transfer documents.
Such documents shall include, without limitation, an Assignment and Bill of Sale in the form attached hereto as Exhibit 2.5, an Assignment of Trademarks in the form attached hereto as Exhibit 2.5(a), an Assignment of Copyrights in the form attached hereto as Exhibit 2.5(b), and any assignments or other documents necessary to effect such transfer and conveyance of the Transferred Assets.
See §2.5(c)
35 U.S.C. § 261 makes an unrecorded patent assignment void against a later purchaser or mortgagee for value without notice unless it is recorded in the USPTO within three months or before the later purchase or mortgage.
An interest that constitutes an assignment, grant or conveyance shall be void as against any subsequent purchaser or mortgagee for a valuable consideration, without notice, unless it is recorded in the Patent and Trademark Office within three months from its date or prior to the date of such subsequent purchase or mortgage.
See 35 U.S.C. § 261
15 U.S.C. § 1060(a)(4) makes a trademark assignment void against a later purchaser for value without notice unless its prescribed information is recorded in the USPTO within 3 months or before the later purchase.
(4) An assignment shall be void against any subsequent purchaser for valuable consideration without notice, unless the prescribed information reporting the assignment is recorded in the United States Patent and Trademark Office within 3 months after the date of the assignment or prior to the subsequent purchase.
See 15 U.S.C. § 1060(a)(4)
17 U.S.C. § 205(d) gives priority to the first-executed copyright transfer if it is recorded within one month after U.S. execution, two months after foreign execution, or before the later transfer is recorded.
As between two conflicting transfers, the one executed first prevails if it is recorded, in the manner required to give constructive notice under subsection (c), within one month after its execution in the United States or within two months after its execution outside the United States, or at any time before recordation in such manner of the later transfer.
See 17 U.S.C. § 205(d)
17 U.S.C. § 205(c) makes Copyright Office recordation constructive notice only if the document identifies the work and the work is registered.
Recordation of a document in the Copyright Office gives all persons constructive notice of the facts stated in the recorded document, but only if- (1) the document, or material attached to it, specifically identifies the work to which it pertains so that, after the document is indexed by the Register of Copyrights, it would be revealed by a reasonable search under the title or registration number of the work; and (2) registration has been made for the work.
See 17 U.S.C. § 205(c)
37 C.F.R. § 1.12(a)(1) states that USPTO assignment records for patents and published patent applications are open to public inspection.
The assignment records, relating to original or reissue patents, including digests and indexes (for assignments recorded on or after May 1, 1957), and published patent applications, are open to public inspection at the United States Patent and Trademark Office, and copies of patent assignment records may be obtained upon request and payment of the fee set forth in § 1.19 of this chapter.
See 37 C.F.R. § 1.12(a)(1)
37 C.F.R. § 2.200(a)(1) states that USPTO assignment records for trademark applications and registrations are open to public inspection.
The assignment records relating to trademark applications and registrations (for assignments recorded on or after January 1, 1955) are open to public inspection at the Office, and copies of those assignment records may be obtained upon request and payment of the fee set forth in § 2.6 of this chapter.
See 37 C.F.R. § 2.200(a)(1)
17 U.S.C. § 705 requires the Copyright Office to maintain records of recordations and makes those records open to public inspection.
(a) The Register of Copyrights shall ensure that records of deposits, registrations, recordations, and other actions taken under this title are maintained, and that indexes of such records are prepared. (b) Such records and indexes, as well as the articles deposited in connection with completed copyright registrations and retained under the control of the Copyright Office, shall be open to public inspection.
See 17 U.S.C. § 705(a)–(b)
6 Del. C. § 18-303(a) states that an LLC member or manager is not personally obligated for the company's debts, obligations or liabilities solely by reason of that status.
(a) Except as otherwise provided by this chapter, the debts, obligations and liabilities of a limited liability company, whether arising in contract, tort or otherwise, shall be solely the debts, obligations and liabilities of the limited liability company, and no member or manager of a limited liability company shall be obligated personally for any such debt, obligation or liability of the limited liability company solely by reason of being a member or acting as a manager of the limited liability company.
See 6 Del. C. § 18-303(a)
6 Del. C. § 18-303(b) permits an LLC member or manager to agree, in the LLC agreement or another agreement, to be personally obligated for the company's debts, obligations and liabilities.
(b) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (a) of this section, under a limited liability company agreement or under another agreement, a member or manager may agree to be obligated personally for any or all of the debts, obligations and liabilities of the limited liability company.
See 6 Del. C. § 18-303(b)
The Greenfield Online agreement made the selling company's shareholder a party solely for purposes of Section 9.7.
This ASSET PURCHASE AGREEMENT (this “Agreement”), dated as of August 18th, 2004, is by and among GREENFIELD ONLINE, INC., a Delaware corporation having its principal offices located at 21 River Road, Wilton, Connecticut 06897 (“Buyer”) and THE DOHRING COMPANY, a California corporation, having its principal offices located at 412 West Broadway, Third Floor, Glendale, CA 91204 (“Seller”) and, solely for purposes of Section 9.7 hereof, DOUG C. DOHRING (“Shareholder”).
See Preamble
In Section 9.7 of the Greenfield Online agreement, the shareholder indemnified the buyer for breaches of two listed seller representations and for the seller's fraud, subject to stated limits.
Shareholder shall indemnify and hold harmless the Buyer Indemnitees, subject to the limits set forth in Section 9.3, in respect of any and all Damages incurred by any Buyer Indemnitee in connection with, or resulting from, any or all of the following: (a) Any breach of the representations or warranties made by Seller pursuant to Sections 3.8 and 3.15 of this Agreement; and (b) Any fraudulent statement or representation of Seller contained in this Agreement, or supplied to Buyer by Seller in writing after the execution of this Agreement, where “fraudulent” means knowing, intentional fraud.
See §9.7
The Meta Financial agreement bound an individual as a shareholder solely for purposes of three listed sections.
Lodge agrees that solely for purposes of Section 10.1(b), Section 10.3 and Section 10.6, he shall be included in the definition of “Shareholder” and shall be bound by the obligations of a Shareholder as set forth therein.
See §10.9
The Luna agreement required the seller to deliver a secretary's certificate attaching the board and shareholder resolutions approving the agreement and certifying officer incumbency.
(xi) a certificate of the Secretary of Seller, dated as of the Closing Date, certifying, as complete and accurate as of the Closing, attached copies of the Governing Documents of Seller, (i) certifying and attaching all requisite resolutions or actions of Seller’s board of directors and shareholders approving the execution and delivery of this Agreement and the consummation of the Contemplated Transactions and the change of name contemplated by Section 10.4 and (ii) certifying as to the incumbency and signatures of the officers of Seller executing this Agreement and any other Transaction Document;
See §2.7(c)(xi)
The Mellor Law Firm explains that in a stock purchase the buyer buys the owner's shares in the corporation or limited liability company.
In a stock purchase, you buy the owner’s shares in the corporation or LLC.
See Mark Mellor, Asset Purchase vs. Stock Purchase: What California Business Buyers Need to Know, The Mellor Law Firm, APLC (May 14, 2026).