{
  "type": "practice-guide",
  "canonical": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware",
  "links": [
    {
      "rel": "self",
      "href": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware.json",
      "type": "application/json"
    },
    {
      "rel": "alternate",
      "href": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware",
      "type": "text/html"
    },
    {
      "rel": "alternate",
      "href": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware/markdown",
      "type": "text/markdown"
    },
    {
      "rel": "alternate",
      "href": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware/json",
      "type": "application/json"
    },
    {
      "rel": "license",
      "href": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
      "type": "text/html",
      "external": true,
      "title": "CC BY 4.0"
    }
  ],
  "data": {
    "topic": "stay-or-pay",
    "state": "delaware",
    "frontmatter": {
      "title": "Stay-or-Pay and Employee Repayment in Delaware",
      "description": "Delaware has no generally applicable statute aimed at stay-or-pay terms in private employment, so repayment agreements are tested as contracts under the penalty rule, while the Wage Payment and Collection Act separately limits collecting the debt from pay.",
      "state": "Delaware",
      "lastReviewed": "2026-11-19",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "authors": [
        "steven-obiajulu"
      ],
      "summary": {
        "repaymentEnforceable": "generallyEnforceable",
        "bottomLine": "Apart from a physician-specific rule on termination damages, Delaware has no statute aimed at stay-or-pay or training-repayment terms in private employment; courts enforce a repayment amount that is a reasonable estimate of uncertain damages and refuse one that operates as a penalty, while collecting through payroll needs a signed authorization, may not cover shortages or damage, and, for an advance, generally may not exceed 15% of gross wages per pay period, with a larger final-pay deduction allowed only when the original agreement provides for it.",
        "keyLaw": [
          {
            "source": "de-swier-penalty-distinction"
          },
          {
            "source": "de-1107-withholding-limits"
          },
          {
            "source": "de-1328-advance-repayment-cap"
          }
        ],
        "clawbackEarnedComp": "unsettled",
        "wageDeductionFromFinalPay": "limited",
        "statutoryStayOrPayLimit": "none",
        "trainingRepayment": "sameAsBonus",
        "prorationOrCap": "no",
        "safestStructure": "The safest structure ties the repayment amount to a documented estimate of the employer's actual training or hiring costs, collects it by separate payment rather than by netting final wages, and uses payroll deductions only under a signed agreement that keeps each deduction at or below 15% of gross wages and leaves pay at or above minimum wage."
      },
      "about": [
        "Repayment and stay-or-pay terms",
        "Liquidated damages and penalties",
        "Clawback of compensation already paid",
        "Deductions from the final paycheck",
        "Training and tuition repayment",
        "Enforcement and remedies"
      ],
      "translations": [
        {
          "language": "中文",
          "status": "planned"
        },
        {
          "language": "Español",
          "status": "planned"
        },
        {
          "language": "Português",
          "status": "planned"
        },
        {
          "language": "Deutsch",
          "status": "planned"
        }
      ]
    },
    "questions": [
      {
        "slug": "repayment-enforceability",
        "label": "Are employee repayment or stay-or-pay terms enforceable?",
        "heading": "Are repayment terms enforceable in Delaware?",
        "answerText": "Delaware has no generally applicable statute that bans or limits stay-or-pay, training-repayment or sign-on bonus repayment terms in private employment, so a Delaware court tests the repayment amount under the contract rule that separates enforceable liquidated damages from an unenforceable penalty. For agreements among physicians, 6 Del. C. § 2707 voids a covenant restricting practice in a locale or for a period after termination, but keeps enforceable a provision requiring damages reasonably related to the injury suffered by reason of termination, which may include damages related to competition. Under that rule a penalty is void as against public policy and recovery is limited to actual damages, while a true liquidated damages provision is enforced according to its terms. The Delaware test comes from Lee Builders v. Wells: where the damages are uncertain and the amount agreed upon is reasonable, the agreement will not be disturbed. The Delaware Supreme Court applied that test to an employment agreement in Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier, which required a physician who left early to pay $25,000 in recognition of the expenses the employer incurred in hiring him and introducing him to the medical community. The court upheld the payment because the evidence showed that $25,000 was a reasonable forecast, rationally related to those expenses and not unconscionable. In Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski, the Superior Court granted summary judgment to employers on an employee repayment agreement whose repayment obligation was triggered when the employee gave notice of his intention to resign, holding the agreement valid and binding. The same opinion held that a $5,000 liquidated damages provision in the employment agreement was a reasonable forecast and not a penalty. A repayment term that is triggered by going to work for a competitor raises a separate question. In Cantor Fitzgerald, L.P. v. Ainslie, the Delaware Supreme Court distinguished a penalty enforced against an employee for breaching a restrictive covenant from a condition that excuses the employer from paying a deferred benefit. A repayment framed as a penalty for breaching a restrictive covenant falls outside that condition rationale, and an employer enforcing an overbroad covenant should not expect a court to narrow it: in Sunder Energy, LLC v. Jackson, the Delaware Supreme Court held that the Court of Chancery did not abuse its discretion by refusing to blue pencil the restrictive covenants.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "id": "de-swier-penalty-distinction",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=The%20distinction%20between%20a%20penalty%20and%20a%20liquidated,enforced%20according%20to%20its%20terms.",
            "proposition": "In *Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier*, the Delaware Supreme Court stated that a contractual penalty is void and limits recovery to actual damages, while a true liquidated damages provision is enforced according to its terms.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The distinction between a penalty and a liquidated damages clause is significant — if a provision is considered a penalty, it is void as against public policy and recovery is limited to actual damages; if the provision is a true liquidated damages provision, it will be enforced according to its terms.",
            "pullQuoteLocator": "The distinction between a penalty and a liquidated|enforced according to its terms.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-penalty-distinction"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-2707-physician-termination-damages",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "6 Del. C. § 2707",
            "citation": "6 Del. C. § 2707",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title6/c027/sc01/index.html",
            "proposition": "6 Del. C. § 2707 voids physician covenants not to compete but enforces provisions requiring damages reasonably related to the injury from termination, including competition-related damages.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Any covenant not to compete provision of an employment, partnership or corporate agreement between and/or among physicians which restricts the right of a physician to practice medicine in a particular locale and/or for a defined period of time, upon the termination of the principal agreement of which the said provision is a part, shall be void; except that all other provisions of such an agreement shall be enforceable at law, including provisions which require the payment of damages in an amount that is reasonably related to the injury suffered by reason of termination of the principal agreement. Provisions which require the payment of damages upon termination of the principal agreement may include, but not be limited to, damages related to competition.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-2707-physician-termination-damages"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-brazen-lee-builders-test",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Brazen v. Bell Atlantic Corp.",
            "citation": "Brazen v. Bell Atl. Corp., 695 A.2d 43 (Del. 1997)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1952344/brazen-v-bell-atlantic-corp/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1952344/brazen-v-bell-atlantic-corp/#:~:text=Analyzing%20the%20Validity%20of%20Liquidated%20Damages%20In,agreement%20will%20not%20be%20disturbed.%E2%80%9D",
            "proposition": "In *Brazen v. Bell Atlantic Corp.*, the Delaware Supreme Court restated the *Lee Builders* test: an agreed amount stands where the damages are uncertain and the amount is reasonable.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Analyzing the Validity of Liquidated Damages In Lee Builders v. Wells, a case involving a liquidated damages provision equal to 5% of the purchase price in a contract for the sale of land, the Court of Chancery articulated the following two-prong test for analyzing the validity of the amount of liquidated damages: “Where the damages are uncertain and the amount agreed upon is reasonable, such an agreement will not be disturbed.”",
            "pullQuoteLocator": "Analyzing the Validity of Liquidated Damages In|agreement will not be disturbed.”",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-brazen-lee-builders-test"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-swier-early-termination-clause",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=In%20recognition%20of%20the%20expenses,termination%20penalty%20equal%20to%20%2425%2C000.00.",
            "proposition": "The employment agreement in *Swier* required the physician to pay $25,000 on early termination in recognition of the employer's hiring and introduction expenses.",
            "verbatimQuote": "In recognition of the expenses incurred by Employer in employing Employee and introducing Employee to the medical community, and aiding the procurement by Beebe Medical Center, of certain equipment needed by Employee to perform certain procedures at the hospital, if Employee terminates this agreement prior to the end of its term, Employed agrees to pay Employer an early termination penalty equal to $25,000.00.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-early-termination-clause"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-swier-reasonable-forecast",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=The%20evidence%20showed%20that%20%2425%2C000,result%20of%20hiring%20Dr.%20Swier.",
            "proposition": "In *Swier*, the Delaware Supreme Court found that the $25,000 early-termination payment was a reasonable forecast, rationally related to the employer's hiring expenses and not unconscionable.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The evidence showed that $25,000 was a reasonable forecast, rationally related and not unconscionable, given Dr. Katz’s testimony regarding the expenses DBSS incurred as a result of hiring Dr. Swier.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-reasonable-forecast"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-kosloski-resignation-trigger",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski",
            "citation": "Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski, C.A. No. N23C-01-183 PAW (Del. Super. Ct. Apr. 21, 2025)",
            "url": "https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=378390",
            "proposition": "In *Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski*, the employee repayment obligation was triggered by notice of voluntary resignation.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Under the Employee Repayment Agreement, Kosloski’s repayment obligation was triggered when he gave notice of his intention to voluntarily terminate his employment.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-kosloski-resignation-trigger"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-kosloski-agreement-binding",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski",
            "citation": "Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski, C.A. No. N23C-01-183 PAW (Del. Super. Ct. Apr. 21, 2025)",
            "url": "https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=378390",
            "proposition": "*Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski* held the employee repayment agreement valid and binding and its repayment obligation triggered.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Therefore, the Employee Repayment Agreement is not void, the Employee Repayment Agreement is a valid, binding contract, and Kosloski’s Resignation Email triggered his repayment obligation under Paragraph 2(a).",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-kosloski-agreement-binding"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-kosloski-reasonable-forecast",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski",
            "citation": "Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski, C.A. No. N23C-01-183 PAW (Del. Super. Ct. Apr. 21, 2025)",
            "url": "https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=378390",
            "proposition": "*Troy Ventures, LLC v. Kosloski* found a $5,000 employment-agreement liquidated damages amount a reasonable forecast rather than a penalty.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The record here shows that $5,000 was a reasonable forecast, rationally related and not unconscionable, of the amount of injury that would be sustained by a contractual breach by Kosloski.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-kosloski-reasonable-forecast"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-cantor-condition-not-penalty",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Cantor Fitzgerald, L.P. v. Ainslie",
            "citation": "Cantor Fitzgerald, L.P. v. Ainslie, 312 A.3d 674 (Del. 2024)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9469727/cantor-fitzgerald-lp-v-ainslie/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9469727/cantor-fitzgerald-lp-v-ainslie/#:~:text=Unlike%20in%20Halpen%20and%20Wark%2C,receive%20a%20deferred%20financial%20benefit.",
            "proposition": "In *Cantor Fitzgerald, L.P. v. Ainslie*, the Delaware Supreme Court distinguished a penalty enforced for breach of a restrictive covenant from a condition precedent to a deferred benefit.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Unlike in Halpen and Wark, the provision at issue here is not a penalty enforced against an employee based on the breach of a restrictive covenant; it is a condition precedent that excuses Cantor Fitzgerald from its duty to pay if the plaintiffs fail to satisfy the condition to which they agreed to be bound in order to receive a deferred financial benefit.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-cantor-condition-not-penalty"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-sunder-no-blue-pencil",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Sunder Energy, LLC v. Jackson",
            "citation": "Sunder Energy, LLC v. Jackson, No. 455, 2023 (Del. Dec. 10, 2024)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10291288/sunder-energy-llc-v-tyler-jackson/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10291288/sunder-energy-llc-v-tyler-jackson/#:~:text=The%20Court%20of%20Chancery%20did,blue%20pencil%20the%20restrictive%20covenants.",
            "proposition": "In *Sunder Energy, LLC v. Jackson*, the Delaware Supreme Court held that the Court of Chancery did not abuse its discretion by refusing to blue pencil overbroad restrictive covenants.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The Court of Chancery did not abuse its discretion by refusing to blue pencil the restrictive covenants.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-sunder-no-blue-pencil"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "slug": "clawback-earned-comp",
        "label": "Can an employer claw back compensation the employee already earned or received?",
        "heading": "Can a Delaware employer claw back pay already received?",
        "answerText": "Delaware enforces a forfeiture-for-competition provision requiring an employee who voluntarily resigns to return equity benefits already received as an ordinary contract term, subject to ordinary contract defenses. Separately, an employer may not recover wages by withholding them from pay outside the deductions the Wage Payment and Collection Act allows. In LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge, the Delaware Supreme Court held that the rule of Cantor Fitzgerald, under which a forfeiture-for-competition provision is enforced as an ordinary contract term rather than reviewed for reasonableness, is not limited to limited partnerships. The court added that the fact that the restricted stock unit agreements required the return of benefits already received did not alter its analysis. The court left open whether a clawback so extreme in duration and financial hardship that it precludes an unsophisticated employee's choice should be reviewed for reasonableness. Those decisions concern equity awards and partnership distributions, and in our review we found no Delaware appellate decision applying them to a cash sign-on bonus, a retention bonus or a training-cost repayment, so the conservative course for those terms is to assume the Swier penalty test applies. Under that test an agreed amount stands where the damages are uncertain and the amount is reasonable, and Swier upheld an amount the evidence showed was a reasonable forecast of the employer's hiring expenses, so the repayment amount should rest on a documented estimate of the employer's costs. Whatever the contract says, the Act provides that no provision of the wage-payment chapter may be contravened or set aside by private agreement.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "id": "de-lkq-voluntary-termination",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge",
            "citation": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge, No. 110, 2024 (Del. Dec. 18, 2024)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/#:~:text=Under%20the%20employee%20choice%20doctrine%2C,employee%20voluntarily%20terminated%20her%20employment.%E2%80%9D",
            "proposition": "*LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge* states that under the employee choice doctrine courts do not review forfeiture-for-competition provisions for reasonableness if the employee voluntarily terminated employment.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Under the employee choice doctrine, “courts do not review forfeiture-for-competition provisions for reasonableness so long as the employee voluntarily terminated her employment.”",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-lkq-voluntary-termination"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-lkq-employee-choice",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge",
            "citation": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge, No. 110, 2024 (Del. Dec. 18, 2024)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/#:~:text=Instead%2C%20we%20endorsed%20the%20employee,ordinary%20breach%20of%20contract%20defenses.",
            "proposition": "In *LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge*, the Delaware Supreme Court described *Cantor Fitzgerald* as treating a forfeiture-for-competition provision as an enforceable term subject to ordinary breach-of-contract defenses.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Instead, we endorsed the employee choice doctrine, meaning that the reviewing court should treat the limited partnership provision as an enforceable term subject to ordinary breach of contract defenses.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-lkq-employee-choice"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-lkq-not-limited-partnership",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge",
            "citation": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge, No. 110, 2024 (Del. Dec. 18, 2024)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/#:~:text=We%20answer%20the%20first%20certified,to%20the%20limited%20partnership%20context.",
            "proposition": "*LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge* held that *Cantor Fitzgerald* is not restricted to the limited partnership context.",
            "verbatimQuote": "We answer the first certified question as follows: Cantor Fitzgerald is not restricted to the limited partnership context.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-lkq-not-limited-partnership"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-lkq-already-received",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge",
            "citation": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge, No. 110, 2024 (Del. Dec. 18, 2024)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/#:~:text=B.%20The%20fact%20that%20the,does%20not%20alter%20our%20analysis.",
            "proposition": "*LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge* held that a requirement to return benefits already received does not change the analysis of a forfeiture-for-competition provision.",
            "verbatimQuote": "B. The fact that the LKQ RSU Agreements require the return of benefits already received does not alter our analysis.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-lkq-already-received"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-lkq-extreme-clawback-reserved",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge",
            "citation": "LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge, No. 110, 2024 (Del. Dec. 18, 2024)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10296559/lkq-corporation-v-robert-rutledge/#:~:text=It%20might%20be%20the%20case,should%20be%20reviewed%20for%20reasonableness.",
            "proposition": "*LKQ Corp. v. Rutledge* reserved whether an extreme clawback that precludes an unsophisticated employee's choice should be reviewed for reasonableness.",
            "verbatimQuote": "It might be the case that a forfeiture-for-competition provision which requires a claw back is so extreme in duration and financial hardship that it precludes employee choice by an unsophisticated party and should be reviewed for reasonableness.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-lkq-extreme-clawback-reserved"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-swier-penalty-clawback",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=The%20distinction%20between%20a%20penalty%20and%20a%20liquidated,enforced%20according%20to%20its%20terms.",
            "proposition": "*Swier* states that a contractual penalty is void and limits recovery to actual damages, while true liquidated damages are enforced as written.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The distinction between a penalty and a liquidated damages clause is significant — if a provision is considered a penalty, it is void as against public policy and recovery is limited to actual damages; if the provision is a true liquidated damages provision, it will be enforced according to its terms.",
            "pullQuoteLocator": "The distinction between a penalty and a liquidated|enforced according to its terms.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-penalty-clawback"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-brazen-test-clawback",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Brazen v. Bell Atlantic Corp.",
            "citation": "Brazen v. Bell Atl. Corp., 695 A.2d 43 (Del. 1997)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1952344/brazen-v-bell-atlantic-corp/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1952344/brazen-v-bell-atlantic-corp/#:~:text=Analyzing%20the%20Validity%20of%20Liquidated%20Damages%20In,agreement%20will%20not%20be%20disturbed.%E2%80%9D",
            "proposition": "*Brazen v. Bell Atlantic Corp.* restated the *Lee Builders* test: an agreed amount stands where the damages are uncertain and the amount is reasonable.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Analyzing the Validity of Liquidated Damages In Lee Builders v. Wells, a case involving a liquidated damages provision equal to 5% of the purchase price in a contract for the sale of land, the Court of Chancery articulated the following two-prong test for analyzing the validity of the amount of liquidated damages: “Where the damages are uncertain and the amount agreed upon is reasonable, such an agreement will not be disturbed.”",
            "pullQuoteLocator": "Analyzing the Validity of Liquidated Damages In|agreement will not be disturbed.”",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-brazen-test-clawback"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-swier-forecast-clawback",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=The%20evidence%20showed%20that%20%2425%2C000,result%20of%20hiring%20Dr.%20Swier.",
            "proposition": "In *Swier*, the Delaware Supreme Court found that the $25,000 early-termination payment was a reasonable forecast, rationally related to the employer's hiring expenses and not unconscionable.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The evidence showed that $25,000 was a reasonable forecast, rationally related and not unconscionable, given Dr. Katz’s testimony regarding the expenses DBSS incurred as a result of hiring Dr. Swier.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-forecast-clawback"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1107-withholding-clawback",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1107",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1107",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1107 bars withholding or diverting wages except where required or empowered by law, for qualifying medical deductions, or under a signed authorization for a lawful purpose benefiting the employee.",
            "verbatimQuote": "No employer may withhold or divert any portion of an employee’s wages unless: (1) The employer is required or empowered to do so by state or federal law; or (2) The deductions are for medical, surgical or hospital care or service, without financial benefit to the employer, and are openly, clearly and in due course recorded in the employers’ books; or (3) The employer has a signed authorization by the employee for deductions for a lawful purpose accruing to the benefit of the employee",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1107-withholding-clawback"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1110-no-private-waiver",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1110",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1110",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1110 provides that the wage-payment chapter may not be contravened or set aside by private agreement except as the chapter provides.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Except as provided in this chapter, no provision of this chapter may in any way be contravened or set aside by private agreement.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1110-no-private-waiver"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "slug": "final-pay-deduction",
        "label": "Can repayment be deducted from the final paycheck?",
        "heading": "Can repayment come out of a Delaware final paycheck?",
        "answerText": "A Delaware employer may take a repayment out of wages, including final wages, only within the deductions section 1107 allows, which for a repayment means a signed authorization by the employee for a lawful purpose that benefits the employee. Final wages must be paid in compliance with sections 1104 and 1107. The Department of Labor's deduction regulation, which the Department amended by an order published in the June 2026 Delaware Register and effective 10 days after publication, narrows that authorization. An employee-authorized deduction must be expressly authorized in writing, for the employee's benefit, and given voluntarily only after the employee receives written notice of the payment's terms and the manner of deduction. A cash advance or charges for goods or services may be repaid through payroll only under a written agreement signed by both parties that specifies the amount, the repayment schedule and the method, and no such agreement may provide for repayment of more than 15% of the employee's gross wages per pay period. A balance above 15% of gross wages may be withheld from final compensation only if the original agreement included that arrangement. Cash or inventory shortages, and losses from damage to the employer's or a customer's property, may not be deducted in any case. The regulation does not prevent an employee from voluntarily reimbursing an employer. Separately, the minimum wage is $15.00 per hour from January 1, 2025, and an agreement to work for less than the minimum wage is no defense to the employee's action for the shortfall. In Swier, decided in 2006, the Delaware Supreme Court held that when an employee leaves owing an employment-related debt, the employer may deduct the debt from final wages where reasonable grounds for a dispute arising out of the employment contract exist. The current version of section 1103 ties the reasonable-grounds defense to disputes under sections 1104 and 1107 and requires final wages to be paid in compliance with those sections; in our review we found no Delaware appellate decision applying Swier to that text, so the conservative course is to pay final wages in full unless a signed authorization covers the deduction and to collect any remaining balance separately.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "id": "de-1103-final-pay-compliance",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(1)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(1)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(1) requires final wages to be paid in compliance with sections 1104 and 1107.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(b) (1) Wages paid under subsection (a) of this section must be paid in compliance with the requirements under §§ 1104 and 1107 of this title.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1103-final-pay-compliance"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1107-withholding-limits",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1107",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1107",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1107 bars withholding or diverting wages except where required or empowered by law, for qualifying medical deductions, or under a signed authorization for a lawful purpose benefiting the employee.",
            "verbatimQuote": "No employer may withhold or divert any portion of an employee’s wages unless: (1) The employer is required or empowered to do so by state or federal law; or (2) The deductions are for medical, surgical or hospital care or service, without financial benefit to the employer, and are openly, clearly and in due course recorded in the employers’ books; or (3) The employer has a signed authorization by the employee for deductions for a lawful purpose accruing to the benefit of the employee",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1107-withholding-limits"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-advance-repayment-cap",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.2 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.2, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 10.2 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328, as amended in June 2026, bars a payroll repayment schedule for an advance above 15% of gross wages per pay period.",
            "verbatimQuote": "No such agreement shall provide for a repayment schedule of more than 15% of an employee’s gross wages per pay period.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-advance-repayment-cap"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-advance-signed-agreement",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.1 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.1, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 10.1 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328, as amended in June 2026, requires a written agreement signed by both parties to repay an advance through payroll.",
            "verbatimQuote": "If a cash advance or charges for goods or services are to be repaid through payroll deductions, both the employer and the employee must sign a written agreement specifying the amount of the advance or the value of the goods or services, the repayment schedule, and the method of repayment.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-advance-signed-agreement"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-final-pay-advance-balance",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.3 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.3, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 10.3 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 permits withholding an advance balance above 15% from final compensation only if the original agreement so provided.",
            "verbatimQuote": "If, upon termination, an employee owes an amount greater than 15% of gross wages, that amount may be withheld from the employee's final compensation, but only if such an arrangement was included in the original agreement.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-final-pay-advance-balance"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-voluntary-written-authorization",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 8.1.2 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 8.1.2, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 8.1.2 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328, as amended in June 2026, allows an employee-authorized deduction only on a voluntary written authorization given after written notice of its terms.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Are expressly authorized in writing by the employee and are for the benefit of the employee, provided that the authorization is voluntary and only given following receipt by the employee of a written notice of all terms and conditions of the payment or its benefits and the details of the manner in which the deductions are made.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-voluntary-written-authorization"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-amendment-effective-date",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026), Final Order",
            "citation": "29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "The Department of Labor order amending 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 took effect 10 days after its publication in the Delaware Register of Regulations.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The effective date of this Order shall be 10 days from the date this Order is published in the Delaware Register of Regulations.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-amendment-effective-date"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-shortage-bar",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 2.1 (codified text)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 2.1 (codified text)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/AdminCode/title19/1328",
            "proposition": "The codified text of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 bars deducting cash or inventory shortages from pay and treats an agreement permitting them as a section 1107 violation.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Cash and/or inventory shortages may not be deducted from an employee's pay in any case. Any written agreement permitting an employer to make such deductions is in violation of §1107.3 of the Wage Payment and Collection Act.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-shortage-bar"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-damage-bar",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 11.0 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 11.0, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 11.0 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328, as amended in June 2026, bars deducting losses from damage to employer or customer property from pay.",
            "verbatimQuote": "A financial loss suffered by an employer due to damage to the employer’s property or to that of a customer or client may not be deducted from an employee's pay in any case.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-damage-bar"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-voluntary-reimbursement",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 6.1 (codified text)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 6.1 (codified text)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/AdminCode/title19/1328",
            "proposition": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 6.1 states that the regulation does not prevent an employee from voluntarily reimbursing an employer.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Nothing in these regulations should be construed as preventing an employee from voluntarily reimbursing an employer.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-voluntary-reimbursement"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-902-minimum-wage-floor",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 902(a)(5)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 902(a)(5)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c009/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 902(a)(5) sets the Delaware minimum wage at not less than $15.00 per hour effective January 1, 2025.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(5) Not less than $15.00 per hour effective January 1, 2025. Upon the establishment of a federal minimum wage in excess of the state minimum wage, the minimum wage in this State shall be equal in amount to the federal minimum wage, except as may otherwise be provided under this chapter.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-902-minimum-wage-floor"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-911-agreement-no-defense",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 911(a)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 911(a)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c009/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 911(a) makes an employer that pays less than the minimum wage liable for the shortfall, costs and attorney's fees, and says an agreement to work for less is no defense.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(a) Any employer who pays any employee less than the full amount of the wages to which the employee is entitled under this chapter shall be liable to such employee in a civil action for the full amount of such wages less any amount actually paid to such employee by the employer and for the costs of the action, necessary expenses of prosecution and reasonable attorney’s fees. Any agreement between such employee and the employer to work for less than the minimum wage rate under this chapter shall be no defense to such action.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-911-agreement-no-defense"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-swier-reasonable-grounds",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=Consistent%20with%20Hollingsworth%2C%20we%20hold,out%20of%20the%20employment%20contract.",
            "proposition": "In *Swier*, the Delaware Supreme Court held that under section 1103(b) an employer may withhold wages when there are reasonable grounds for a dispute arising out of the employment contract.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Consistent with Hollingsworth, we hold that under § 1103(b) an employer may withhold wages when there are reasonable grounds for a dispute between the employer and employee arising out of the employment contract.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-reasonable-grounds"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-swier-final-wage-offset",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=In%20other%20words%2C%20when%20an,employee%E2%80%99s%20debt%20from%20final%20wages.",
            "proposition": "*Swier* stated that an employer may deduct an employment-related debt from a departing employee's final wages.",
            "verbatimQuote": "In other words, when an employee leaves owing an employment-related debt to his employer, the employer may deduct the employee’s debt from final wages.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-final-wage-offset"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1103-reasonable-grounds-current",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(2)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(2)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(2) imposes liquidated damages on an employer that fails to pay wages without reasonable grounds for dispute under section 1104 or section 1107.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(2) If an employer, without any reasonable grounds for dispute under § 1104 or § 1107 of this title, fails to pay an employee wages as required under this chapter, the employer is also liable to the employee for liquidated damages in the amount of the lower of the following: a. Ten percent of the unpaid wages for each day, except Sunday and legal holidays, upon which the failure continues after the day upon which payment is required. b. An amount equal to the unpaid wages.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1103-reasonable-grounds-current"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "slug": "training-repayment",
        "label": "Are training, tuition, or relocation repayment terms treated differently?",
        "heading": "Are Delaware training or tuition repayments treated differently?",
        "answerText": "For private employers, Delaware law does not treat training, tuition or relocation repayment differently from other repayment terms: no Delaware statute addresses them in private employment, and the same penalty rule and wage-deduction limits apply. The closest Delaware Supreme Court decision is Swier, which upheld a $25,000 early-departure payment as liquidated damages because the evidence tied it to the expenses the employer incurred in hiring the employee. In our review we found no Delaware appellate decision on a training-repayment agreement as such, so the conservative course is to treat a training repayment as liquidated damages that must reflect a reasonable estimate of uncertain training costs. Payroll collection of a training balance faces the same limits as any other debt. Federal law adds a separate floor: under the Fair Labor Standards Act regulations, the Act's wage requirements are not met where the employee kicks back to the employer, directly or indirectly, the whole or part of the wage delivered, and the regulation's example treats the cost of employer-required tools as a violation in any workweek when it cuts into the required minimum or overtime wages.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "id": "de-brazen-test-training",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Brazen v. Bell Atlantic Corp.",
            "citation": "Brazen v. Bell Atl. Corp., 695 A.2d 43 (Del. 1997)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1952344/brazen-v-bell-atlantic-corp/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1952344/brazen-v-bell-atlantic-corp/#:~:text=Analyzing%20the%20Validity%20of%20Liquidated%20Damages%20In,agreement%20will%20not%20be%20disturbed.%E2%80%9D",
            "proposition": "*Brazen v. Bell Atlantic Corp.* restated the *Lee Builders* test: an agreed amount stands where the damages are uncertain and the amount is reasonable.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Analyzing the Validity of Liquidated Damages In Lee Builders v. Wells, a case involving a liquidated damages provision equal to 5% of the purchase price in a contract for the sale of land, the Court of Chancery articulated the following two-prong test for analyzing the validity of the amount of liquidated damages: “Where the damages are uncertain and the amount agreed upon is reasonable, such an agreement will not be disturbed.”",
            "pullQuoteLocator": "Analyzing the Validity of Liquidated Damages In|agreement will not be disturbed.”",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-brazen-test-training"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1107-withholding-training",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1107",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1107",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1107 bars withholding or diverting wages except where required or empowered by law, for qualifying medical deductions, or under a signed authorization for a lawful purpose benefiting the employee.",
            "verbatimQuote": "No employer may withhold or divert any portion of an employee’s wages unless: (1) The employer is required or empowered to do so by state or federal law; or (2) The deductions are for medical, surgical or hospital care or service, without financial benefit to the employer, and are openly, clearly and in due course recorded in the employers’ books; or (3) The employer has a signed authorization by the employee for deductions for a lawful purpose accruing to the benefit of the employee",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1107-withholding-training"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-swier-forecast-training",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=The%20evidence%20showed%20that%20%2425%2C000,result%20of%20hiring%20Dr.%20Swier.",
            "proposition": "In *Swier*, the Delaware Supreme Court found that the $25,000 early-termination payment was a reasonable forecast, rationally related to the employer's hiring expenses and not unconscionable.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The evidence showed that $25,000 was a reasonable forecast, rationally related and not unconscionable, given Dr. Katz’s testimony regarding the expenses DBSS incurred as a result of hiring Dr. Swier.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-forecast-training"
          },
          {
            "id": "fed-531-35-kickback-rule-training",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "29 C.F.R. § 531.35",
            "citation": "29 C.F.R. § 531.35",
            "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-29/subtitle-B/chapter-V/subchapter-A/part-531/subpart-C/subject-group-ECFRd42c2e4b995d7cd/section-531.35",
            "proposition": "29 C.F.R. § 531.35 provides that FLSA wage requirements are not met where the employee kicks back part of the wage to the employer, directly or indirectly.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The wage requirements of the Act will not be met where the employee “kicks-back” directly or indirectly to the employer or to another person for the employer's benefit the whole or part of the wage delivered to the employee.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-fed-531-35-kickback-rule-training"
          },
          {
            "id": "fed-531-35-kickback-training",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "29 C.F.R. § 531.35",
            "citation": "29 C.F.R. § 531.35",
            "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-29/subtitle-B/chapter-V/subchapter-A/part-531/subpart-C/subject-group-ECFRd42c2e4b995d7cd/section-531.35",
            "proposition": "29 C.F.R. § 531.35 treats an employer-required cost borne by the employee as an FLSA violation in any workweek when it cuts into required minimum or overtime wages.",
            "verbatimQuote": "For example, if it is a requirement of the employer that the employee must provide tools of the trade which will be used in or are specifically required for the performance of the employer's particular work, there would be a violation of the Act in any workweek when the cost of such tools purchased by the employee cuts into the minimum or overtime wages required to be paid him under the Act.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-fed-531-35-kickback-training"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "slug": "enforcement",
        "label": "How is the rule enforced, and can an employee sue?",
        "heading": "What happens to a Delaware employer that over-collects a repayment from pay?",
        "answerText": "An employee whose wages are withheld without authorization may sue to recover the unpaid wages and liquidated damages, and a judgment for the employee must include the costs of the action and reasonable attorney's fees. Where the employer had no reasonable grounds for dispute under section 1104 or section 1107, the liquidated damages are the lower of ten percent of the unpaid wages for each day, excluding Sundays and legal holidays, that the failure continues after payment is due, or an amount equal to the unpaid wages. The Department of Labor may also bring an action to collect unpaid wages, and an employer that violates the chapter or its regulations is subject to a civil penalty of $1,000 to $5,000 for each violation. A claim for wages, or for damages or penalties from failing to pay them, must be brought within two years after it accrues.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "id": "de-1113-civil-action-enforcement",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1113(a)–(c)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1113(a)–(c)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1113 authorizes employee and Department actions for unpaid wages and liquidated damages and requires costs and attorney's fees in a judgment for the plaintiff.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(a) A civil action to recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages may be maintained in any court of competent jurisdiction. (b) Whenever the Department determines that wages, as required under this chapter, have not been paid, the Department may bring any legal action necessary to collect such claim. With the consent of the aggrieved employee, the Department shall have the power to settle and adjust any such claim to the same extent as might the assigning employee. (c) Any judgment entered for a plaintiff in an action brought under this section shall include an award for the costs of the action, the necessary costs of prosecution and reasonable attorney’s fees, all to be paid by the defendant.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1113-civil-action-enforcement"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1103-liquidated-enforcement",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(2)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(2)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(2) sets liquidated damages for wages unpaid without reasonable grounds for dispute at the lower of ten percent per day or the unpaid amount.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(2) If an employer, without any reasonable grounds for dispute under § 1104 or § 1107 of this title, fails to pay an employee wages as required under this chapter, the employer is also liable to the employee for liquidated damages in the amount of the lower of the following: a. Ten percent of the unpaid wages for each day, except Sunday and legal holidays, upon which the failure continues after the day upon which payment is required. b. An amount equal to the unpaid wages.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1103-liquidated-enforcement"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1112-civil-penalty-enforcement",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1112(a)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1112(a)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1112(a) subjects an employer that violates the chapter or its regulations to a civil penalty of $1,000 to $5,000 per violation.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(a) Any employer who violates or fails to comply with any requirement of this chapter or any regulation published thereunder shall be deemed in violation of this chapter and shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than $1,000 nor more than $5,000 for each such violation.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1112-civil-penalty-enforcement"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-8111-two-year-limit",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "10 Del. C. § 8111",
            "citation": "10 Del. C. § 8111",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title10/c081/index.html",
            "proposition": "10 Del. C. § 8111 requires a claim for wages, or for damages or penalties from failing to pay them, to be brought within two years after it accrues.",
            "verbatimQuote": "No action for recovery upon a claim for wages, salary, or overtime for work, labor, or personal services performed, or for damages (actual, compensatory, or punitive, liquidated or otherwise), or for interest or penalties resulting from the failure to pay any such claim, or for any other benefits arising from such work, labor, or personal services performed or in connection with any such action, shall be brought after the expiration of 2 years from the accruing of the cause of action on which such action is based.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-8111-two-year-limit"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "slug": "safest-structure",
        "label": "What structure is safest under the Delaware rule?",
        "heading": "What repayment structure is safest under Delaware law?",
        "answerText": "The safest Delaware repayment term sets an amount the employer can show was a reasonable forecast of uncertain costs, such as documented training or hiring expenses, because Delaware enforces an agreed amount where the damages are uncertain and the amount is reasonable. If the employer plans to collect through payroll, the deduction needs the employee's signed authorization for a lawful purpose accruing to the employee's benefit, given voluntarily after written notice of its terms. If the repayment is structured as a cash advance, the regulation's advance rules also apply: both parties sign a written agreement stating the amount, the repayment schedule and the method, no scheduled deduction exceeds 15% of gross wages per pay period, and an advance balance above 15% can come out of final compensation only if the original agreement provided for it. Each deduction should also leave pay at or above the $15.00 hourly minimum wage. Because final wages must be paid in compliance with section 1107, any balance a signed authorization does not cover is safer collected by a separate demand or action than by withholding the last paycheck.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "id": "de-brazen-test-structure",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Brazen v. Bell Atlantic Corp.",
            "citation": "Brazen v. Bell Atl. Corp., 695 A.2d 43 (Del. 1997)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1952344/brazen-v-bell-atlantic-corp/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1952344/brazen-v-bell-atlantic-corp/#:~:text=Analyzing%20the%20Validity%20of%20Liquidated%20Damages%20In,agreement%20will%20not%20be%20disturbed.%E2%80%9D",
            "proposition": "*Brazen v. Bell Atlantic Corp.* restated the *Lee Builders* test: an agreed amount stands where the damages are uncertain and the amount is reasonable.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Analyzing the Validity of Liquidated Damages In Lee Builders v. Wells, a case involving a liquidated damages provision equal to 5% of the purchase price in a contract for the sale of land, the Court of Chancery articulated the following two-prong test for analyzing the validity of the amount of liquidated damages: “Where the damages are uncertain and the amount agreed upon is reasonable, such an agreement will not be disturbed.”",
            "pullQuoteLocator": "Analyzing the Validity of Liquidated Damages In|agreement will not be disturbed.”",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-brazen-test-structure"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-swier-forecast-structure",
            "authorityType": "case-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "Delaware Bay Surgical Services, P.A. v. Swier",
            "citation": "Del. Bay Surgical Servs., P.A. v. Swier, 900 A.2d 646 (Del. 2006)",
            "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/",
            "deepLink": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2402207/delaware-bay-surgical-services-pa-v-swier/#:~:text=The%20evidence%20showed%20that%20%2425%2C000,result%20of%20hiring%20Dr.%20Swier.",
            "proposition": "In *Swier*, the Delaware Supreme Court found that the $25,000 early-termination payment was a reasonable forecast, rationally related to the employer's hiring expenses and not unconscionable.",
            "verbatimQuote": "The evidence showed that $25,000 was a reasonable forecast, rationally related and not unconscionable, given Dr. Katz’s testimony regarding the expenses DBSS incurred as a result of hiring Dr. Swier.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-swier-forecast-structure"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1107-authorization-structure",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1107(3)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1107(3)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1107(3) permits an employee-authorized deduction only under a signed authorization for a lawful purpose accruing to the employee's benefit, subject to Department regulation.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(3) The employer has a signed authorization by the employee for deductions for a lawful purpose accruing to the benefit of the employee, except that the Department, upon finding that it is acting in the public interest, may, by regulation, prohibit such withholding or diverting for such purpose.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1107-authorization-structure"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-signed-agreement-structure",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.1 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.1, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 10.1 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 requires a written agreement signed by both parties, stating amount, schedule and method, to repay an advance through payroll.",
            "verbatimQuote": "If a cash advance or charges for goods or services are to be repaid through payroll deductions, both the employer and the employee must sign a written agreement specifying the amount of the advance or the value of the goods or services, the repayment schedule, and the method of repayment.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-signed-agreement-structure"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-authorization-structure",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 8.1.2 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 8.1.2, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 8.1.2 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 allows an employee-authorized deduction only on a voluntary written authorization given after written notice of its terms.",
            "verbatimQuote": "Are expressly authorized in writing by the employee and are for the benefit of the employee, provided that the authorization is voluntary and only given following receipt by the employee of a written notice of all terms and conditions of the payment or its benefits and the details of the manner in which the deductions are made.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-authorization-structure"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-final-balance-structure",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.3 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.3, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 10.3 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 permits withholding an advance balance above 15% from final compensation only if the original agreement so provided.",
            "verbatimQuote": "If, upon termination, an employee owes an amount greater than 15% of gross wages, that amount may be withheld from the employee's final compensation, but only if such an arrangement was included in the original agreement.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-final-balance-structure"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1328-cap-structure",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.2 (as amended June 2026)",
            "citation": "19 Del. Admin. Code 1328 § 10.2, as amended by 29 Del. Reg. 999 (June 1, 2026)",
            "url": "https://regulations.delaware.gov/register/june2026/final/29%20DE%20Reg%20999%2006-01-26",
            "proposition": "Section 10.2 of 19 Del. Admin. Code 1328, as amended in June 2026, bars a payroll repayment schedule for an advance above 15% of gross wages per pay period.",
            "verbatimQuote": "No such agreement shall provide for a repayment schedule of more than 15% of an employee’s gross wages per pay period.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1328-cap-structure"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-902-floor-structure",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 902(a)(5)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 902(a)(5)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c009/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 902(a)(5) sets the Delaware minimum wage at not less than $15.00 per hour effective January 1, 2025.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(5) Not less than $15.00 per hour effective January 1, 2025. Upon the establishment of a federal minimum wage in excess of the state minimum wage, the minimum wage in this State shall be equal in amount to the federal minimum wage, except as may otherwise be provided under this chapter.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-902-floor-structure"
          },
          {
            "id": "de-1103-compliance-structure",
            "authorityType": "primary-law",
            "tier": "primary-source-backed",
            "title": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(1)",
            "citation": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(1)",
            "url": "https://delcode.delaware.gov/title19/c011/index.html",
            "proposition": "19 Del. C. § 1103(b)(1) requires final wages to be paid in compliance with sections 1104 and 1107.",
            "verbatimQuote": "(b) (1) Wages paid under subsection (a) of this section must be paid in compliance with the requirements under §§ 1104 and 1107 of this title.",
            "anchor": "https://openagreements.org/practice-guides/stay-or-pay/us/delaware#src-de-1103-compliance-structure"
          }
        ]
      }
    ]
  }
}
